| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 fanofcoils |
America's Tribal Council Winner |
Lead | |
|
Posts: 3177 (12/30/06 10:21 PM) I need a life |
For each season if they had one:
Borneo - Rudy Australia - Colby Africa - Tom Marquesas - Kathy Thailand - Helen Amazon - Matt Pearl Islands - Rupert Vanuatu - Twila? Palau - Stephenie Guatamala - Rafe Exile Island - Cirie Cook Islands - Ozzy What are yours? |
||
|
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 5949 (12/30/06 10:24 PM) Registered User |
Er.........um......
On another note, Terry would have easily won the Panama ATC, not Cirie. Cirie only won the car because the audience saw Terry win one........ |
||
|
alcoholocost |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 152 (12/30/06 10:36 PM) |
Elisabeth would have won S2 and Ethan could have won S3. I don't think Kathy was that popular with the general public either, so it could have been Paschal.
Jan probably would have won Thailand, and Christy Amazon. Basically, America's TC is a horrible wretched demonic idea. |
||
|
fsmdud |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 1679 (12/30/06 10:42 PM) Registered user |
For each season if they had one:
Borneo - Stephenie Australia - Stephenie Africa - Stephenie Marquesas - Stephenie Thailand - Stephenie Amazon - Stephenie Pearl Islands - Stephenie ASS - Stephenie Vanuatu - Stephenie? Palau - Stephenie Guatamala - Stephenie Exile Island - Stephenie Cook Islands - Stephenie Fiji - Stephenie Greece - Stephenie Bahamas - Stephenie Madagascar - Stephenie Samoa - Stephenie Japan - Stephenie ASS2 (Panama) - Stephenie Maldives - Stephenie Guam - Stephenie British Columbia - Stephenie Peru - Stephenie Battle of the Winners - Stephenie What are yours? |
||
|
chapera rocks |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 9645 (12/30/06 10:46 PM) Registered User |
Borneo: Rudy, maybe Gretchen
Australia: Elisabeth Africa: Ethan Marquesas: Gina? Thailand: Ken/Jake? Amazon: Matt Pearl Islands: Rupert Vanuatu: Chad? Palau: Steph Guatemala: Steph? Exile: Terry Cook Islands: Ozzy |
||
|
TheRoundPeg |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 368 (12/31/06 12:09 AM) Registered user |
No one remembers Colleen from S1.
|
||
 Kirblar |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 6463 (12/31/06 12:23 AM) Registered user |
Cirie won the America's choice vote for S12, didn't she?
|
||
|
The Purple Parrot |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 6769 (12/31/06 1:14 AM) Registered user |
Quote: Yes. And there is no way that Colleen would have not won a viewer's choice poll of the first season. |
||
|
Maniacboy888 |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 2513 (12/31/06 1:16 AM) Registered user |
Quote: I think Teresa could have had a shot at that. |
||
|
cantthinkofaname |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 1200 (12/31/06 1:33 AM) Registered User |
In the America's TC show, they narrowed it down to the 4 who got the most votes before revealing the winner.
People that could be in the Final 4 1 - Rudy, Colleen, Kelly, Gretchen, Greg 2 - Colby, Elisabeth, Rodger?, Michael, Kel?? 3 - Tom, Kelly, Teresa, Kim P.?, 4 - Kathy, Paschal, Hunter, Gina?, 5 - Helen, Shii Ann, Jake?, Ken?, 6 - Matt, Christy, Rob, Butch??, Deena? 7 - Rupert, Darrah, Andrew, Ryan O?, Christa? 9 - Chad, Julie, Twila??, Eliza??, Sarge?, (this one's tough) 10 - Ian, Bobby Jon, Stephenie, Coby?, Angie? 11 - Rafe, Lydia, Brandon, Brian, Amy?, Gary?, Cindy? 12 - Terry, Cirie, Bruce, Tina?, Sally?, 13 - Ozzy, Sundra?, Jonathan??, (this one's tough too) |
||
|
chapera rocks |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 9645 (12/31/06 1:41 AM) Registered User |
Quote: Yes, but because Terry was not on the ballot. IIRC, Terry was well ahead of Cirie in the polls each week. Re: Teresa, maybe, Kim P was higher in the polls, and Ethan was well ahead of everyone (90%+). If it was down to 4 each season (not sures in brackets) : Borneo: Rudy, Gretchen, Colleen (Gervase?) Australia: Elisabeth, Rodger, Colby, Tina Africa: Ethan, Kim P, Teresa, Tom Marquesas: Gina, Kathy, Paschal (Hunter/Neleh?) Thailand: Ken, Jake, Helen (Shii Ann/Erin?) Amazon: Matthew, Butch, Rob, Christy Pearl Islands: Rupert, Sandra (Andrew? Darrah?) Vanuatu: Chad, Chris, Sarge (Julie/Twila?) Palau: Tom, Ian, Stephenie, Bobby Jon Guatemala: Danni, Stephenie, Rafe, Lydia Panama Exile Island: Terry, Cirie, Aras (Sally/Bruce?) Cook Islands: Yul, Ozzy, Jonathan (Parvati? Because she was next in line for the car vote) |
||
|
MultiGeminii |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 1029 (12/31/06 2:32 AM) Registered user |
I bolded where my choice differs from "America's":
Borneo - Rudy or Rich (I liked them both) Australia - Elisabeth Africa - Ethan Marquesas - Kathy Thailand - Helen Amazon - Matt Pearl Islands - Rupert Vanuatu - Twila? Palau - Stephenie Guatamala - Rafe Exile Island - Cirie Cook Islands - Yul Edited to admit my early love for Elisabeth. I'm so ashamed of that now! |
||
|
MJSLawrence |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 1450 (12/31/06 2:57 AM) Registered user |
OfCOURSE we remember Colleen from S1!!!
But it would have been Kelly W anyways. She was the fan fave at the time... And noone ever stood a chance against Elizabeth, Rupert, Cesternino or Stephenie in their seasons. The fans are like magnets to those people. |
||
|
Prydefull |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 437 (12/31/06 3:02 AM) Registered user |
Quote: Most people (save you I guess) could tell Terry was a smug asshole. Cirie would easily have won. |
||
|
SurvivorSurvivorSurvivor |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 5949 (12/31/06 3:18 AM) Registered User |
Wrong. Most people here despised Terry......the general public liked the guy. As long as you win a shitload of immunity challenges, you'll usually be the fan favorite.
|
||
|
MJSLawrence |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 1450 (12/31/06 3:22 AM) Registered user |
I know and I HATE that...they're always the favorites!! The ones I wish 'd been canned 15 episodes ago, I don't get it.
|
||
|
beatles20147 |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 11734 (12/31/06 3:23 AM) Registered User |
Kelly the fan fave in Borneo? I like her but she was never a fan fave. It was Colleen and Rudy all the way (with Gervase not too far behind).
|
||
|
Cuauhtemoc Gilmore |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 12900 (12/31/06 3:32 AM) |
Gervase? Ugh. I was cheering when he got the exit. Serves that lazy fucker right.
|
||
|
AwesumCrush00 |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 2373 (12/31/06 3:41 AM) Registered User |
youre all fucking retarded if you think america would vote for Gina in a final americas vote. gina who? she made it to the sixth episode and was shit the whole time.
01. colleen haskell 02. elisabeth filarski 03. teresa cooper 04. kathy vanderick 05. jake billingsley 06. rob cesterino 07. rupert boneham 08. rupert boneham 09. twila tanner/ julie berry 10. stephenie lagrossa 11. bobby jon drinkard/ gary hawkins 12. cirie fields 13. yul kwon |
||
|
MJSLawrence |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 1450 (12/31/06 4:06 AM) Registered user |
gina rocked my world...
and usually the votes for money or cars are made AFTER the season or towards the end...so by then, everyone felt so bad for KElly and loathed rich so much that I definitely think she would have taken it. Sue was the best anyways. It's too bad she pulled such a huge Ghandia an killed her fanbase in AllStars. Not so many of us still standin' behind her after that one... |
||
|
survivorsims07 |
Re: America's Tribal Council Winner | ||
|
Posts: 1292 (12/31/06 2:02 PM) Hey! I kinda like it here! |
I am not including the winner in my picks because it was revealed after the winner was named.
Borneo: Rudy or Colleen Australia: Elisabeth would have won with out a doubt Africa: Kim P., Teresa, and Tom Marquases: Neleh or Pappy then maybe Kathy Thailand: Helen Amazon: Christy would have won Pearl Islands: Rupert Vanuatu: Ami Palau: Ian or Steph Guatemala: Steph or Rafe Exile Island: Terry or Cirie Cook Islands: Ozzy, Johnathan |
||
