Top 20 Survivors to Never Win as Ranked by SecretAgent079 in Clubs that Suck. No, Really. Forum

0 Points

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Top 20 Survivors to Never Win as Ranked by SecretAgent079

Started By

Comment

SecretAgent079

Top 20 Survivors to Never Win as Ranked by SecretAgent079

Lead

[-]

Posts: 1065

05/20/12 04:13 PM

Hey friends, thanks for coming to see my first ever Survivor ranking! I will be posting (probably about one per day) what is, in my opinion, the top 20 players to never win a season of Survivor. The criteria varies for person to person, but for the most part they will be ranked on their games in a particular season. Not as much focus will be had on their chances in future seasons.

I hope everyone enjoys!

And feel free to insult me and my ranking over the next few months.

Spoiler [+]

1.
2.
3.
4.
5.   Amanda Kimmel
6.   Jon "Fairplay" Dalton
7.   Yau-Man Chan
8. Lex van den Berghe
9.   Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien
10. Benjamin "Coach" Wade
11. Stephen Fishbach
12. Terry Deitz
13. Holly Hoffman
14. Brett Clouser
15. Kelly Wiglesworth
16. Colby Donaldson
17. Rafe Judkins
18. Ian Rosenberger
19. Stephenie LaGrossa
20. Jessica "Sugar" Kiper

Last Edited By: SecretAgent079 07/05/12 11:54 AM. Edited 22 times.

Advertisement
	Remove this ad Remove this ad

SecretAgent079

[-]

Posts: 1065

05/20/12 04:17 PM

Hint for Number 20: Two time player, made the finals once and didn't make the merge once.

Also, how do I create a "Spoiler [+]" and insert my list into it.

Slicer37

[-]

Posts: 2348

05/20/12 05:46 PM

The only one I can think of that fits that description is...Sugar

:

white lancer

[-]

Posts: 2288

05/20/12 05:51 PM

I have no idea what you did with that spoiler tag.

I'd advise you to prepare for an onslaught of scorn and insults when you rank Russell at #1.

PoorYorick

[-]

Posts: 1932

05/20/12 05:59 PM

[.spoiler]These words are hidden[./spoiler]

Remove the periods.

TraverseTown

[-]

Posts: 649

05/20/12 06:04 PM

If Rafe Judkins is not in this ranking, then you know nothing about the best survivors who never won.

SecretAgent079

[-]

Posts: 1065

05/20/12 06:12 PM

PoorYorick wrote:
[.spoiler]These words are hidden[./spoiler]

Remove the periods.

Thank you very much.

SecretAgent079

[-]

Posts: 1065

05/20/12 06:14 PM

@TraverseTown and white lancer, I hope you stick around to see.

PS, my 700th post!!!

SleepTight

[-]

Posts: 1614

05/20/12 06:15 PM

What a bonehead.

spoiler Russell wins.

Blueberry.celebprowresting

[-]

Posts: 24251

05/20/12 06:27 PM

Registered user

Steph
DDL
Sash
Matt Elrod
Chelsea
Chase
Cirie
PG
Holly
Brenda

<333

SecretAgent079

[-]

Posts: 1065

05/20/12 07:05 PM

Maybe I should make my future hints more ambiguous because the only poster to make a guess, Slicer37, got it correct.

20. Jessica "Sugar" Kiper

Survivor: Gabon(3rd) / Survivor: Heroes vs Villains(20th)

I'd like to start this off by saying that I had 19 very good players to never win and that I was forced to think of a twentieth to make my countdown begin with a good, round number. The reason that Sugar earned the honor(?) of being on my list is that she played one of the most dominant games ever played by a female, controlling most votes from start to finish. Most would say that Sugar played too emotionally, constantly crying and voting out people that she didn't like rather than people who were threats. In fact, her decisions were for the most part, wrong, but it is because she had the power to make these decisions that makes her Gabon game an impressive one in my mind.

There has only been about one player per season who was a dominant force, and even few of them were women, I find it very impressive the way Sugar controlled the situation at all times and was able to make big moves. I expect this to be one of the most controversial posts on my list, and I ask people to, for a moment, take away all opinions about her and her personality, and to judge her as a player. One who was never in trouble of going home and who controlled the way that Survivor: Gabon played out.

Last Edited By: SecretAgent079 05/28/12 02:36 PM. Edited 2 times.

Advertisement
	Remove this ad

SecretAgent079

[-]

Posts: 1065

05/20/12 07:08 PM

Hint for Number 19: Played on Heroes vs Villains.

Blueberry.celebprowresting

[-]

Posts: 24251

05/20/12 07:08 PM

Registered user

I play like her in ORGs =o

Slicer37

[-]

Posts: 2348

05/20/12 07:18 PM

Russell wins

dabu

[-]

Posts: 7591

05/20/12 07:21 PM

It doesn't fucking matter how much control she had if the way she used her control was incredibly self-destructive. It makes no difference whether you decide with 100% certainty how every single person votes every single round if you're making them all vote in a way that prevents you from winning. Control is only a good thing if it's bringing you toward the end goal of winning.

And the fact that she actually said "I don't think you have to vote for me" at FTC doesn't help.

Astro Snake

[-]

Posts: 2045

05/20/12 07:21 PM

Since Russell is #1, I'm going to say #19 is the Amanda Kimmel.

survivorgirl22

[-]

Posts: 8197

05/20/12 07:22 PM

To be fair,her goal was not winning so while I don't think she's a good player it's not that she was doing all this and still expecting to get votes...

FistOLegend

[-]

Posts: 2779

05/20/12 07:23 PM

Have to agree. Sugar is by far the worst player ever to make the finals. Consciously and actively playing to lose is indefensible.

white lancer

[-]

Posts: 2288

05/20/12 07:30 PM

dabu wrote:
It doesn't fucking matter how much control she had if the way she used her control was incredibly self-destructive. It makes no difference whether you decide with 100% certainty how every single person votes every single round if you're making them all vote in a way that prevents you from winning. Control is only a good thing if it's bringing you toward the end goal of winning.

And the fact that she actually said "I don't think you have to vote for me" at FTC doesn't help.

This.

It's much easier to control the game if everyone wants to sit next to you at FTC because they know you're not going to get any votes. I like Sugar but she wasn't a good player at all.

SecretAgent079

[-]

Posts: 1065

05/20/12 07:34 PM

Sugar did what she wanted from the game. She didn't want to win, she wanted a good experience and to see someone that she liked win. Sugar was not dragged to the end, she was in a position where she got to select any two players out of the final six to go to the end with her.

PoorYorick

[-]

Posts: 1932

05/20/12 07:36 PM

SecretAgent079 wrote:
Sugar did what she wanted from the game. She didn't want to win, she wanted a good experience and to see someone that she liked win. Sugar was not dragged to the end, she was in a position where she got to select any two players out of the final six to go to the end with her.

But she was in that position because everyone wanted to take her to the FTC and beat her...

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Top 20 Survivors to Never Win as Ranked by SecretAgent079

Top 20 Survivors to Never Win as Ranked by SecretAgent079