Do we have a thread to rage about epic robbage? in American Idol/X-Factor Forum

0 Points

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Do we have a thread to rage about epic robbage?

Started By

Comment

pjadedd

[-]

Posts: 13550

04/06/12 05:14 PM

Registered User

Max, total agreeance on Ricky. Not so much on Mishovanna.

Advertisement
	Remove this ad /td>

Miraclemax

[-]

Posts: 3945

04/06/12 06:03 PM

Registered User

Ricky should've made it over the wife killing turd and Mishovanna should've got to sing in the wildcard instead of Jasmine.

suckshardcore

[-]

Posts: 38414

04/06/12 07:24 PM

Registered user

Mishovanna epic robbage.

pjadedd

[-]

Posts: 13550

04/06/12 08:27 PM

Registered User

I don't get the Mishovanna love. She was standard semifinal fodder that probably wouldn't have even made it was a top 24.

aspects13

[-]

Posts: 1352

04/06/12 11:18 PM

Registered user

1) Lisa Leuschner, havigng Randy Jackson say something like "You have one of the best voices"... and then to say she would not perform in the wild card round.
2) AJ Tabaldo, but like Leslie Hunt said "America doesn't like jazz."
3) Alexandréa Lushington, she got Archuleta'd again.
4) Marque Lynche, only because his brother could come on and get so far while being so much worse.
5) Vanessa Olivarez, the only finalist since people were put off by a scripted line she was made to say, was the only finalist not on the CD that season and the only finalist not on the tour since Charles Grigsby replaced Corey Clark but they decided not to replace Josh Gracin.

eternaljoy

[-]

Posts: 6828

04/06/12 11:19 PM

Registered User

Mishavonna was great!

stratocat

[-]

Posts: 35

04/06/12 11:38 PM

great personality wrote:

I'm an Elise fan and her going at any point from here on out wouldn't qualify her as robbed. If anything, she's gotten a lot further than most expected
------------------------

I just started watching this year, you guys are the experts on the ways of this show. I'll defer to your judgement, no more complaining from me.

Last Edited By: stratocat 04/06/12 11:43 PM. Edited 1 times.

pigbenis

[-]

Posts: 595

04/07/12 02:03 AM

Lauren Turner and Kendra Chantelle? They sing better than Jovani Baretto and Asthon...

Anyway, J-lo always pick Latino for the wildcard, no matter how fodder they are (Jovani and Jeremy)

Wildcat612

[-]

Posts: 2827

04/07/12 01:42 PM

Registered user

I always say that the most robbed person in Idol history is Canadian Idol Season 3's Ashley Leitao.

But I assume we're chatting American Idol only, so I'd say that Angela Peel, Kelli Glover, Amy Adams, Jennifer Hudson, Gedeon McKinney, Sabrina Sloan, David Hernandez, Felicia Barton, Katelyn Epperly, and Candace Glover all went home far too soon. (I just noticed that 70% of my picks are contestants of color. Sad.)

Last Edited By: Wildcat612 04/07/12 01:50 PM. Edited 1 times.

SteveX

[-]

Posts: 264

04/07/12 05:37 PM

aspects13 wrote:
1) Lisa Leuschner, havigng Randy Jackson say something like "You have one of the best voices"... and then to say she would not perform in the wild card round.
2) AJ Tabaldo, but like Leslie Hunt said "America doesn't like jazz."
3) Alexandréa Lushington, she got Archuleta'd again.
4) Marque Lynche, only because his brother could come on and get so far while being so much worse.
5) Vanessa Olivarez, the only finalist since people were put off by a scripted line she was made to say, was the only finalist not on the CD that season and the only finalist not on the tour since Charles Grigsby replaced Corey Clark but they decided not to replace Josh Gracin.

I never understood why Lisa Leuschner didn't get to perform in the wild-card, and didn't go through in the first place. I must have missed the explanation??

Advertisement
	Remove this ad

burberrylad

[-]

Posts: 5869

04/07/12 05:55 PM

Registered user

They never gave an excuse for Lisa. Simon was never keen on Lisa so I guess he had something to do with it. She was definately robbed though. Most of the wildcard picks that week sounded shit.
Which leads me on to Suzy Vulaca who I also felt was robbed of a Top 12 place. She was one of the few good wildcard singers that year and yet Paula picked Leah LaBelle? And then America picked JPL? I suppose I have to give America some slack because JPL was kinda fun and likeable in a goofy way and the Top 12 had hardly any boys that year but Paula picking Leah over Suzy was inexcusable and I can only assume it was due to her being medicated?

billhill

[-]

Posts: 8605

04/07/12 07:40 PM

David Hernandez was not robbed, he was just bad. He made my skin crawl.

GabeBabe

[-]

Posts: 3305

04/07/12 08:08 PM

Mishavonna is amazeballs! "Drops of Jupiter" was pretty good, and I love her EPs (find them on iTunes lol)!!

Nods

[-]

Posts: 13816

04/07/12 08:28 PM

Registered User

Season 7 could have been the greatest ever if instead of Chikeze and David Hernandez we got Kady Mallory and Asiah Mallory

pjadedd

[-]

Posts: 13550

04/07/12 09:29 PM

Registered User

A's'i'a'h? Ser *inaudible noise* iously?

Wildcat612

[-]

Posts: 2827

04/08/12 01:08 AM

Registered user

billhill wrote:
David Hernandez was not robbed, he was just bad. He made my skin crawl.

His "Midnight Hour" was spectacular and "Papa was a Rolling Stone" not too bad either.

And I completely forgot about Suzy Vulaca. Loved her too.

R Nucleus

[-]

Posts: 40

04/08/12 01:39 AM

Nods wrote:
Season 7 could have been the greatest ever if instead of Chikeze and David Hernandez we got Kady Mallory and Asiah Mallory

I'm assuming that you meant Asia'h Epperson. And I disagree completely. Kady was awful and Asia'h was average at best. Chikezie and David H. were much better than them.

msacras

[-]

Posts: 1257

04/09/12 01:16 AM

Season 7 was probably the only season with that top 24 format (2m2f booted 3 weeks) that did not feature any semi suprise or epic robbage of any semifinalists. AmeriKa got the top 12 completely (or at least 90%) right.

ETA: Although I didn't watch season 5, so correct me if I'm wrong (that looked like a strong roster of finalists out of the top 24)

Last Edited By: msacras 04/09/12 01:18 AM. Edited 1 times.

burberrylad

[-]

Posts: 5869

04/09/12 10:02 AM

Registered user

Syesha Mercaodo. Even when she was good the judges shat on her because they didn't want another black female winner.

suckshardcore

[-]

Posts: 38414

04/09/12 02:53 PM

Registered user

Syesha made it to 3rd place, as much as they may have tried to screw her (I mean, the Happy Feet song), she was hardly robbed. I wasn't a fan of Screamesha but it was obvious they'd stop at nothing to get that little Archbot into the F2.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Do we have a thread to rage about epic robbage?