Ted may not know about cooking, but he knows about eating. To me, that is as important in judging as the cooking. Have someone who knows their own palate in there with those who know the ins and outs of the trade. So to speak.
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
cginspace |
|||
|
Ted may not know about cooking, but he knows about eating. To me, that is as important in judging as the cooking. Have someone who knows their own palate in there with those who know the ins and outs of the trade. So to speak. |
|||
The Smoking Nun |
|||
cginspace wrote:Good point. Plus Ted is charming, likable and fun to watch. |
|||
Drew B |
|||
cginspace wrote: Gail's not a chef, either, but she has a very sophisticated understanding of all things food. From what I understand (and I'm no expert), Ted is a reality show personality who got the "Queer Eye" gig because he's gay rather than because he has much expertise. He doesn't really have much of a resume. |
|||
cginspace |
|||
|
From Wiki:
Allen then became a freelancer for Chicago magazine, eventually becoming a senior editor, and often writing about food, wine and luminaries of the culinary world. He joined Esquire in 1997 as a contributing editor. He contributed to an Esquire food series, profiled many celebrities and somehow co-authored the magazine's popular "Things a Man Should Know" series. He has written for a variety of other magazines and continues as a contributing editor for Esquire. Allen gained great visibility in 2003, when he became a cast member of the reality television series Queer Eye for the Straight Guy. Allen was the
show's food and wine specialist. He continued to make television appearances as a gourmet, including as a frequent guest judge on Food Network's Iron
Chef America. Allen hosted a six-part documentary, "Uncorked: Wine Made Simple," on PBS starting May 7, 2007.
Edirted to correct a bad word choice
Last Edited By: cginspace
06/03/09 7:01 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
Drew B |
|||
|
A community weekly newspaper... A regional variety magazine... A fashion magazine... Gail is a big wig at a FOOD magazine. There's no comparison. Ted is a
dilettante with a certain knowledge of food. Gail is an EXPERT.
|
|||
Cousin Oliver |
|||
Drew B wrote: Last year, we just had Jaime as the sole lesbian. It was Season 4 that we had Zoi, the one who was doing it for Zoi, and Lisa. |
|||
cginspace |
|||
Drew B wrote: You said Ted does not know shit about it. He has been doing reviews, and for reputable sources if not FOOD mags, since the early 90s. I never said I didn't like Gail. All I am saying is that Ted knows his stuff, and is not just some fly by night gay. |
|||
Drew B |
|||
|
I said (and I've heard) that he doesn't know shit about cooking - as in doing it himself. That is not the same as to say that he doesn't
know shit about food. He probably has a great deal more knowledge about food than a standard lay person, but not as much as a true expert like Gail. I probably
overstated...
|
|||
Halo8 |
|||
|
I don't like how scripted Toby comes off, but if he will challenge Tom's opinions, I'm all for it. I can't stand Tom, he is such a freaking
bully on that panel. I used to at least respect his expert opinions, but last season he just became too obnoxious and unbearable.
Agreed w/ all the people who love Ripert. He is a hot piece for someone his age and he always offers fair and constructive criticisms. Same goes to Ted. |
|||
For Petes Sake |
|||
|
On the bright side, we could be listening to Jeffrey Steingarten fail to suppress his mommy issues
|
|||
Carboys Desire |
|||
Drew B wrote: Ted was always showing the straight guys how to prepare dishes on Queer Eye. True they were easy dishes, but he knows something. |
|||
cginspace |
|||
|
Thank you, CD. I will get your back at a later date :) Ted Allen was actually my favorite Queer Eyes. One of the few who seemed to actually know WTF he was
talking about.
|
|||
Drew B |
|||
cginspace wrote: Kyan didn't know about lotion and zhuzhing? [clutches pearls!] |
|||
Kenscookie |
|||
|
I used to hate Gail (she just looks like a bitch), but I have come to respect her opinion. I believe she knows a hell
of a lot more about food than Tom and Padma put together. Plus, I'm kind of sick of Tom's douchiness. Padma's pretty to look at and all, but meh.
What is it with that face she makes every time she's about to tell someone to pack their knives and go? She looks like she's in pain. Is she trying to
be dramatic? Because it's awful. Padma, quit trying to act and just read your lines.
My dream judges panel would be Ripert, Ted Allen and Gail.
Last Edited By: Kenscookie
06/05/09 12:42 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
Carboys Desire |
|||
|
I hate the way the judges look at the chefs disappointingly as they walk in to face the panel, as if they all just raped a baby and sold a video of it on the
internet.
|
|||
Will |
|||
|
Did somebody say LISA?
|
|||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
Carboys Desire wrote: Not giving Gail enough food is worse than wanting to hook up with an underage girl. They need to have a Dateline about that. ** Padma, Tom, and Gail is given a dish of spagehetti. The menu clearly states loaded with meatballs yet Gail only gets 10, Padma and Tom both get 12. Gail shakes her head. Chris Hanson walks off ** Chris - Hey how you doing? Chris Hanson. . .To Catch a Skimpy Chef Chef - What's going on? Chris - You menu says loaded with Meatballs does that plate look loaded with meatballs. Gail - Padma got more! I didn't get enough. This is the worstest day in the history of anyone. I feel violated. |
|||
cginspace |
|||
|
Gail would not go ballistic over meatballs. Foie Gras, perhaps. |
|||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
cginspace wrote: You must not know the judges MO multiple times each season each judge has the same gripe they use over and over. Padma will always find something in her food. Gail will always complain about the size of her meal. Tom will always say something is simple. |
|||
Naked Paul |
|||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote:That's why we love to hate them. A total lovefest would be B.O.R.I.N.G. |
|||