| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
Carboys Desire |
|||
|
Regarding Kris, all that matters is a good song and a good marketing strategy. If he wins he'll have good songs thrown at him left and right, as the
American Idol, and the marketing comes with it. If he loses, it's not going to be as easy. With Adam I think it's different. He'll make it no
matter what.
|
|||
kitty |
|||
Hunterdonn wrote: Yes and they've called the finale right since they started. Whereas DI has been pretty wrong all season. Between http://www.zabasearch.com/ai_stats.php and Bettors I'd be kinda surprised if Kris won. (I feel bad for whomever has to record that piece of shit Kara wrote. Maybe they won't insist on it being on the album this year?)
Last Edited By: kitty
05/20/09 2:30 PM.
Edited 2 times.
|
|||
Podunk Town |
|||
Bottom line? Adam Lambert is much more popular than Kris Allen based on the number of searches being done for their names. As a matter of fact, it's not even close. Whether you look at searches worldwide, or just in the States, Lambert is more popular by a very wide margin. Geographically, Kris Allen only received more searches for his name in one location in the entire world..........that would be the state of Arkansas, where he is from. I don't understand how this write reconciles those two statements. If Adam doesn't win, it is because the show is a popularity contest? Does that mean they think Kris is more popular? They just said Adam is more popular. If Adam wins, doesn't it meant that he won because is more popular? And yes, Adam is very talented, but I just don't like the timbre of his voice. I hate the crazy vibrato. I hate the screeching. I don't dislike him because of religion, sexual orientation, looks, or any number of other factors that go into decisions as to whether or not I like a person. I like Kris more than Adam based on their singing, which this show is about. I hate how people think that people aren't voting based on singing just because they don't like their preferred contestant. All music is subjective. Some people like certain genres of music and dislike others. It's not because one is inherently inferior than the other. It is a matter of personal preference. Yes, Adam is good, but I would prefer not to have him screech at me all the time. Some people like that. I don't. |
|||
kooyah |
|||
Carboys Desire wrote: As if it was ever really anything more than a popularity contest... |
|||
Hunterdonn |
|||
|
If you look at the Dial Idol Raw percentages, in the totals area, only .20 separates the votes between Kris and Adam.
Kris comes up with a total of 380.12, Adam with 379.92. Way to close to call based on Dial Idol. And I still stand by my comments that Dial Idol isn't dependable. That 1.1 margin that did not change for over four hours last night, not realistic. All it means is that the site was overloaded and they could not process any more than that amount of information at the time. |
|||
benjamin linus |
|||
Podunk Town wrote: X. I hate when I try to have a rational discussion on my opinion of Adam and the whole 'ZOMG!!!ELEVENTY!!ONE! Adam is so edgy and you're just homophobic if you don't want him to win!" argument ensues. Just because I don't like Adam's wild banshee of a voice, doesn't mean it's because he's gay. I could care less about that. |
|||
McWolcott |
|||
Hunterdonn wrote: Dial Idol doesn't count text votes at all, right? |
|||
drawrein |
|||
Podunk Town wrote:Not necessary, because the number of votes do not reflect the number of fans -- a lot of people don't vote, and a lot of people power vote. |
|||
seaguy |
|||
ZombieLinda wrote:Actually I thought it was the opposite. He said he'd rather not do musical theatre. I think it'll be close but I think Adam will still win. eta: Carboy I got my confirmation text this morning as well. Just 12 hours or so later. |
|||
XianneKei |
|||
seaguy wrote:I agree. I remember Adam saying he wanted to do a rock album and rock was what he was interested in. I'm 100% for Adam, but I would not be distraught over a Kris win. Both of them will be successful, no matter what. |
|||
Us Kids Know |
|||
Carboys Desire wrote: I love how that article claims that it matters that Adam is gay because "it doesn't matter anymore" despite the fact that the article exists and then goes into lengths about how much it matters. Anyone who votes against Adam because he's gay is an idiot. Anyone who votes FOR Adam because he's gay is an idiot. I've been wanting Adam to get booted all season because I think he sucks. |
|||
Penalty Shot |
|||
|
Has South Dakota weighed in yet at DI, or did the entire state take a pass this year? |
|||
Tsathoggua |
|||
|
They let the cows vote?
|
|||
Carboys Desire |
|||
Us Kids Know wrote: To clarify, I did not vote for Adam because he is gay. I voted for him because I love his singing. I want him to win because 1) I love his singing and 2) because he is gay. Sorry if that's hard to understand, but it's true. |
|||
mungobuh |
|||
Carboys Desire wrote:I'll add to the fray with a little honesty... I voted for Adam CHIEFLY because of his talent and charisma....but I do admit that around 5% of my decision came from the prospect of aneurysms from those actively voting against him CHIEFLY due to his sexuality. So does that make a small part of me idiotic? Maybe, but I'll live with it. I also don't believe that Adam must win just so the gay community can make a political point....though I'll admit it would be a nice, not necessary, side effect. |
|||
BarbH918 |
|||
|
I voted for Kris because his is the CD I'd buy. Adam is immensely talented and will be a great star. But - I wouldn't buy his music - it's not what
I listen to. It has nothing to do with his looks, age, eyeliner, anything. To me, it's just who I'd buy.
On the other hand - I think that the control factor that 19 Entertainment has over someone's career for that first year will be much harder for Adam than Kris. Spin doctors will be working overtime on Adam's image. |
|||
underYa |
|||
|
I want Kris to win:
-because I can pinpoint the type of gay Adam is (which we don't see on screen), and I sure as hell don't like it. So yeah, in a way, I don't want him to win because he's gay.. I do not want someone like that furthering untrue stereotypes about myself -I DO NOT like Adam's singing at all, especially his screeching.. I don't understand how people can listen to that crap.. he doesn't belong in rock... his "Mad world" rendition was good; I can deal with that, but the rest of the crap he sings - FUCKEN TERRIBLE. Are people serious? DO PEOPLE HAVE NO TASTE IN MUSIC?? So even though Kris' style is somewhat boring, I just can't stand Adam's. So, go Kris, and fuck you Adam. |
|||
Carboys Desire |
|||
|
Yes, underYa. People are serious. Millions of them are serious. We all like crap. Our ears are not as keen as yours, unfortunately.
And if Adam wins everyone is going to know that what he does, you do too! Cuz you are gay just like him. Just like when Elton John came out of the closet everyone looked and pointed at you and accused you of being the sick pervert that you are. You probably have a Pepsi bottle up your ass right now. Despicable. |
|||
McWolcott |
|||
underYa wrote:
|
|||
kooyah |
|||
Carboys Desire wrote:So long as you people realize that... |
|||