I'll be interested to see the TAR5 write up. I really don't remember anything about that season, so it'll be a refresher.
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
troynuncdicit |
|||
|
PI <33333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333333 Seriously, everything about it <3. Great write up, really hit all the good points of this
season.
I'll be interested to see the TAR5 write up. I really don't remember anything about that season, so it'll be a refresher. |
|||
CrystalOwnage |
|||
|
Pearl Islands SEETHING LOVE
I was planning on watching TAR3 before TAR5...maybe I should switch it around? |
|||
Mega64 |
|||
|
I think I'll go ahead and start my TAR5 write-up so I don't have to do it tomorrow morning.
Also posting this to see how long it will take (though I'm expecting a couple of interruptions anyway). |
|||
A Dying Clown |
|||
|
This list has made me a bit depressed that if I had the patience to do something like this (which I don't), it'd be about twice as long :/
Among all the token old team, they had the best placement average, but got eliminated because of airline tickets issue... A huge reason why I rate TAR2 above TAR1/TAR3/TAR5 is that the earlier boots were all filler teams, while the other classic seasons lost too many good people right at the start (even TAR3 would have been much better with Tramel/Talicis, Dandrew v1 or Heave in JVJ's place). I would have much rather seen Bob/Joyce get through to the finals instead of the luckier screechy Bowling Moms. |
|||
Mega64 |
|||
|
1. The Amazing Race 5
Wikipedia Reality Blurred Archive The Amazing Race 5 was the fifth installment of the American reality television show, The Amazing Race. It aired between July 6, 2004 and September 21, 2004.So we got four TAR seasons with pretty iffy ratings, and it really started to look like the show wasn't going to last much longer. The show won an Emmy, and after much deliberation, it was finally renewed, albeit with some new twists and stunt casting. You'd think with limited Fast Forwards, the Yield, stunt casting (Big Brother's Alison, Miss Texas, a little person) that the show wouldn't be up to par with old seasons, but despite all those, it turned out to be incredible, gathering media attention and finding a new fan base. This was the season that was going to save The Amazing Race, and the producers ended up getting together one of the most amazing casts ever, putting them through one hell of a race course, and gave us something incredible. The drama, the excitement, the hilarity, the tension, this season had it all. Great characters, some amazing villains, and some daunting tasks that really tested the limits of some teams. Ladies and gentlemen, my favorite season of reality TV.
|
|||
Mega64 |
|||
|
Holy shit. That took awhile, but I've finally finished. I'm surprised actually that I finished. It's been a blast writing them, and I'm glad
you all enjoyed them. Gotta thank everyone for participating and posting along and giving your input, whether it agreed with my thoughts or not. Thanks to
everyone who participated or even just lurked and read the things, as at least that means I didn't completely waste my time writing this (well, I still
probably did, but oh well).
I'll probably do a few extra things, like do word/page counts, show lists, and thoughts on a few shows that I watched after starting this list. But that's pretty much it as far as the list goes. Kinda nice that I'm officially done now. I have another project idea that won't be a ranking or write-up or anything, but I'll wait a few months for that idea, probably. |
|||
Lake Like The Ocean |
|||
|
|||
XtremeInnovator420 |
|||
|
Y'know, I liked your writeup until you started praising Charla/Mirna....I've NEVER hated a TAR team like I hated those two, I mean nobody even comes
close. Just....ugh.
|
|||
Mega64 |
|||
|
I actually hated them at first since I was posting at TWoP at the time and had that brainwashing Kool-Aid of Miss Alli's.
So I probably made that write-up more one-sided than necessary. |
|||
Mega64 |
|||
|
Bonus lists, sorted by show! Number in parentheses are overall ranking.
Survivor: 1. Survivor: Pearl Islands (2) 2. Survivor: Borneo (3) 3. Survivor: Panama - Exile Island (16) 4. Survivor: The Australian Outback (25) 5. Survivor: China (27) 6. Survivor: Micronesia (34) 7. Survivor: Tocantins (40) 8. Survivor: Palau (41) 9. Survivor: Guatemala (44) 10. Survivor: Marquesas (46) 11. Survivor: Amazon (49) 12. Survivor: Vanuatu (53) 13. Survivor: Gabon (58) 14. Survivor: Africa (59) 15. Survivor: Thailand (62) 16. Survivor: All-Stars (67) 17. Survivor: Fiji (69) 18. Survivor: Cook Islands (71) The Amazing Race: 1. The Amazing Race 5 (1) 2. The Amazing Race 1 (4) 3. The Amazing Race 3 (11) 4. The Amazing Race 9 (21) 5. The Amazing Race 2 (35) 6. The Amazing Race 12 (39) 7. The Amazing Race 14 (42) 8. The Amazing Race: All-Stars (45) 9. The Amazing Race 13 (52) 10. The Amazing Race 7 (57) 11. The Amazing Race 10 (64) 12. The Amazing Race 4 (65) 13. The Amazing Race 6 (68) 14. The Amazing Race: Family Edition (77) VH1 Celebreality: 1. Flavor of Love 2 (9) 2. Rock of Love Bus with Bret Michaels (10) 3. Flavor of Love Girls: Charm School (12) 4. Rock of Love: Charm School (13) 5. Rock of Love 1 (14) 6. I Love Money 2 (17) 7. I Love Money 1 (19) 8. Flavor of Love 1 (22) 9. I Love New York 2 (23) 10. Rock of Love 2 (28) 11. I Love New York 1 (36) 12. Flavor of Love 3 (55) 13. For the Love of Ray J (70) 14. Real Chance of Love (75) The Apprentice: 1. The Apprentice 1 (8) 2. The Apprentice 4 (24) 3. The Apprentice 3 (30) 4. The Apprentice 2 (33) 5. The Apprentice: Martha Stewart (38) 6. The Celebrity Apprentice 2 (56) 7. The Apprentice 5 (61) 8. The Apprentice 6 (76) Big Brother: 1. Big Brother 2 (6) 2. Big Brother 3 (15) 3. Big Brother: All Stars (18) 4. Big Brother 8 (20) 5. Big Brother 5 (32) 6. Big Brother 4 (74) 7. Big Brother 1 (78) Hell's Kitchen: 1. Hell's Kitchen 5 (29) 2. Hell's Kitchen 3 (31) 3. Hell's Kitchen 4 (48) The Contender: 1. The Contender 1 (7) 2. The Contender 2 (47) 3. The Contender 3 (66) Rock Star: 1. Rock Star: INXS (5) 2. Rock Star: Supernova (26) Misc: 1. Kitchen Nightmares 1 (37) 2. The Mole 5 (43) 3. Project Runway 3 (50) 4. Treasure Hunters (51) 5. The Rebel Billionaire (54) 6. Pirate Master (60) 7. Cupid (63) 8. The Pick-Up Artist 2 (71) 9. Mr. Personality (72) |
|||
A Dying Clown |
|||
|
I'd call Brandon/Nicole the best strategists in TAR history, so take umbrage to them being called mediocre. No other team has been able to take advantage
of so many other people's good will and make zero enemies. Look at how many alliances they ditch in the first few episodes, yet somehow manage to remain
well-liked.
another strong old team until Fran & Barry =o I think they were pretty much as inept as Meredith/Gretchen at the tasks, if not moreso (especially early on) - the difference is that TAR9 had tons of self-driving, while TAR7 had almost none. |
|||
Annoying Tool Fanboy |
|||
|
To be fair paying 100 dollars for a cab ride in Tanzania is complete bullshit. I'd be pissed too if some asshole driver overcharged because I was a
foreigner and then drove on a bad tire to top it of and made me lose position on the race.
|
|||
wakwakwak |
|||
A Dying Clown wrote:But all the teams eliminated early in TAR1 were more obvious fillers, leaving the strong/interesting teams in the F4/F6. (Yes, F6, because Lenny & Karyn are just <3333333) Imho, in terms of awesomeness, TAR5>>TAR1>TAR2>TAR3 |
|||
troynuncdicit |
|||
|
Congratulations on finishing your ranking! I really enjoyed this one a lot, it was a really great read. I still don't remember too much about TAR5 now, but
maybe that calls for a rewatch sometime soon??
On another note, your appreciation for the Celebreality shows makes me wanna watch some of the ones I've never seen. Do you know where I can rewatch them, or should I just wait for VH1 to show some marathons? I've tried the VH1 website and they only have clips, no full episodes. |
|||
Mega64 |
|||
troynuncdicit wrote:I don't think VH1 airs reruns that much anymore. I think the TVGuide channel sometimes airs reruns of Flavor of Love and may have a couple more shows, not sure. A lot of the earlier shows, such as Flavor of Love, I Love New York, and Rock of Love are on DVD as well. Other than that, I guess torrents and IRC are your best bets. There's a good IRC channel that has plenty of reality shows, but I don't remember the server/channel. I may post the link here once I get to my desktop. They've got pretty much everything, and it's how I managed to download both seasons of Rock Star. |
|||
spnintendo |
|||
|
Omg PI seething ownage <333
It's my favo season too! I don't think it'll ever be topped character-wise. |
|||
CAPSattack |
|||
spnintendo wrote: THIS |
|||
bryanpasa |
|||
|
TAR5 Won!
Should have gone this way:
Last Edited By: bryanpasa
08/07/09 10:45 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
Thailandsurvivor |
|||
|
Although Amazon and Thailand are way too low, great list. TAR 5 was an amazing season (although Charla and Mirna are overrated and vile). Both the Bowling Moms
and Chip/Kim could be considered my second favorite team ever.
|
|||
SurvivorFanGP |
|||
|
Yaaay Pearl Islands!
Chu never knew what was gon' happen next =O and Sandra! <3 Pre-merge AND post-merge were just epic. <3 |
|||