But yeah, the blood was just starting to flow.
I think the killer is doing dirty things with uncle marty's and beth's bottom halves.
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
ustrasana |
|||
|
There is nothing sympathetic about that woman. And she must have JUST been killed. As in right before people walked outside. So whoever was in the group that
walked outside, is the killer (Jimmy/Henry) Sorry if that had already been said, I didn't go through every page.
But yeah, the blood was just starting to flow. I think the killer is doing dirty things with uncle marty's and beth's bottom halves. |
|||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
|
Is Beth missing her other arm too? If yes then she must have been placed in some kinda device that chopped her in half as she reached out for help with her
free arm.
|
|||
FermatsLastThm |
|||
|
Can someone post an updated Bingo-card-of-death please?
|
|||
Miles Edgeworth |
|||
|
All Im saying is that the killings have ramped up since muffin has dissapeared.
Muffin is the killer. Book it
Last Edited By: Miles Edgeworth
06/14/09 4:36 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
crazy1500 |
|||
Drew B wrote: I think people have a problem with this theory, because as some have pointed out why wouldn't the killer just off Malcolm too? I'm surprised that so many of you were surprised by Katherine's death. I kind of expected it. And I don't think Katherine had to have been killed RIGHT then. Isn't it possible that she was dead, but the blood started "seeping" out once Shane shook her? |
|||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
crazy1500 wrote: I was wondering that too but maybe the killer offed only Booth b/c two missing groomsman would have drawn too much attention too soon. With killing Booth and then hiding his body makes Malcom look crazy when he brought the guys back. |
|||
pjadedd |
|||
crazy1500 wrote:If they're going to argue Malcolm not being killed, they can also argue why wasn't Shane killed when the guard was? |
|||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
pjadedd wrote: The killer is a female with PMS. One moment she kills and then a second later she has a change of heart and wants to make a chocolate pie followed by sex. |
|||
Drew B |
|||
crazy1500 wrote: I think the killer has motives for how and when he/she kills people*. Otherwise, he/she could have blown up the ferry coming over to the island or burned the Candlewick to the ground and killed tons of people quickly and efficiently... I also think that testing Malcolm's behavior with the money and tormenting him with guilt was part of the motivation... |
|||
crazy1500 |
|||
pjadedd wrote: I suppose, but as evidenced by this thread the show can be picked apart a million different ways. Maybe the killer is Jimmy, and he didn't want to kill Shane? No, but seriously, I'm still a bit confused as to what the point of letting JD out of jail was at all. Hopefully all is explained when we learn who the killer is. |
|||
crazy1500 |
|||
Drew B wrote: This, I agree with. For the most part, the killer is definitely killing people for certain reasons - excluding Lucy and Beth, I guess. ETA: I'm not one of the people who have a problem with the theory that the killer shot Booth. I would actually buy it either way, I just think it would be somewhat lame if Booth did actually off himself, especially considering that it was the only death of the episode.
Last Edited By: crazy1500
06/14/09 4:51 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
AmightyRo |
|||
PinotEnvy wrote:If I remember correctly, they showed Malcom's grave for Booth and Booth was fully buried with a few rocks on Booth's mound, so I'm gonna throw out the "he just threw some leaves over Booth" theory (respectfully). And with that, the dirt the next day in Malcom's room could have come from him after burying Booth (which is what I believe). The shower was running because Malcom used it to wash off, but forgot to turn it off because like you said, he's not cool under pressure and was in too much of a daze. My point was, if Booth were to fake his own death, he'd be a genius to KNOW to plant a bag of exploding blood under his pants KNOWING that someone like Malcom would HAPPEN to chase after him later so he could plan perfectly to "accidently" shoot and kill himself, and have the person who chased after him (Malcom) not think to take Booth's body to some medical attention and have it examined only to discover he had faked his own death but INSTEAD hold his breath under the dirty mound Malcom made for him and wait for Malcom to leave before he came up from the ground and started killing everyone again. |
|||
pjadedd |
|||
|
And, not only would Booth have to survive underground, but he would have had to unearth himself, but also replace the entire "grave" to the exact
setting so that Malcolm doesn't think anything was off.
Oh, and I love the Tim Curry idea. Viva La Clue. |
|||
PinotEnvy |
|||
|
All great points, A-Ro, and if this were real life and not a t.v. murder mystery/horror show I would be right with you. However, shows like these tend to blur
the lines of reason and reality beyond all logic, so Booth faking his death and fooling Malcolm is possible in the world of horror and common plot holes. ;-)
|
|||
E Moch |
|||
|
I just watched the last 6 episodes on my Tivo.
I really wish this show had been executed better...but I am anxious to know the mystery behind everything. |
|||
Katy Carney |
|||
|
Not to mention, why would Booth fake his death out in the woods with no one around? What if Malcolm's money was never discovered? What if Malcolm
didn't follow him? It just doesn't make sense to go through the trouble to fake your own death when someone might not even know.
|
|||
AlwaysAwesomeAdam |
|||
AmightyRo wrote:The only problem with that theory is Booth would have had to know he was going to hide the money in the woods and know that Malcom was going to follow him and then leave him alone in the woods opposed to getting help. Its too many "what ifs" for Booth to actually be the killer. |
|||
iismepeter |
|||
|
Did Malcolm bury Booth?! I doubt he had like a coffin with him, so wouldn't he have to hold his breath for a long ass time while getting buried?
|
|||
tullfan2 |
|||
crazy1500 wrote: I think that the killer's intended target at the jail was the short wave radio and he needed to take out the deputy to gain access to the room where it was. The killer took the opportunity to shoot the deputy after he left the room to tell Shane to shut up and he had his back facing the killer. There is no way that the killer could guarantee that JD would be able to get the keys and free himself. Here is to hoping that at the end the whole cast dies and that Gigi is the only survivor. People who seem safe for a while: Abby - she is the killer's main target and she won't be killed until all the other wedding guests are dead. Sheriff Mills - He won't be killed until after Abby is dead. The killer wants him to suffer the pain of Abby's death Shane - He isn't part of the wedding party and he has no connection to Abby. The only locals that have been killed so far either are connected to Wakefield (Kelly, Cole) or were killed to accomplish an objective (the Reverend, Deputy Garrett). Maggie - Similar reason to Shane but she could be killed if she stands in the way of an objective the killer needs to accomplish. |
|||
Kenneth |
|||
April R wrote: Seriously. Is Sucks like 80% of Harper's Island's viewing audience? There's a lot of posts for a show that gets such shitty ratings. Sorry I skimmed the "And then there were none" discussion, but did anyone mention how Katherine's death is eerily reminiscent of how the killer stages his death in "ATTWN" so he can continue to kill undetected once the number of suspects starts dwindling? |
|||