midnightproblay wrote:
Roxbury means that the nominations probably really turned out like this (not exactly but random rough estimates):
LEAD: 1. Winslet (TR), 2. Winslet (RR), 3. Streep, 4. Hathaway, 5. Jolie, 6. Leo
SUPPORTING: 1. Cruz, 2. Winslet (TR), 3. Tomei, 4. Davis, 5. Adams, 6. Henson
So technically, she got enough for 3 nominations this year; however, since you can only be nominated once in a category she wouldn't be able to get a nomination for Revolutionary Road, and since you can only be nominated once for the same film (except that guy in Going My Way) she would have to forfeit her supporting nomination (assuming she got more votes in lead for The Reader than she did in supporting). It's confusing to explain, but it's very likely the way that it went down.
Ah...Ok...got it! ( duhhhhhhh )
Sorry for misunderstanding, roxbury! :)
And I definitely think In Bruges was one of the year's best.
IMO, way more brilliantly subtle in ALL aspects of the film, over the in-your-face-tug-at-your-heartstrings-this-is for-the-Oscar movies such as Ben Button and Slumdog Millionaire ( as I said before, liked them both, just wasn't TOTALLY enamored. ).
And I'd choose Death at a Funeral, for some of the same reasons. A really clever, witty, GROWN UP comedy...which, in this day and age of the juvenile satire ( Scary Movie, et al ), is really hard to pull off.


















