If Erik wins immunity, Amanda is definitely the next one gone. If he doesn't win it and Amanda doesn't win it, I'd say it's a toss up between Erik and Amanda.
If Amanda can make it to the end then her winning would be ok.
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
CatNamedRudy |
|||
|
Unless Amanda wins immunity next week, I just don't even see how she is not the next boot. MAYBE Erik but since Amanda was supposed to go this time around
and with her Idol out of play now, she's got a giant target on her back.
If Erik wins immunity, Amanda is definitely the next one gone. If he doesn't win it and Amanda doesn't win it, I'd say it's a toss up between Erik and Amanda. If Amanda can make it to the end then her winning would be ok. |
|||
platinumtlc |
|||
|
At this point if Amanda makes it to F3, I do think she has a good shot not because of her alleged 'gameplay' but because I think Ozzy will campaign for
her to win because she fucked him.
|
|||
Juggler 8o8 |
|||
|
After what she did last tribal I will greatly enjoy an Amanda win!
|
|||
assface killah |
|||
platinumtlc wrote: Your right... it would have nothing to do with how well liked she is or that fact that she is a great gamer... all stated by her own tribe mates. Say she
is boring... to YOU... and I would have no need to complain. However.... making dumb shit up just because you do like someone only shows your ignorance.
|
|||
GrenadeJumper85 |
|||
|
What does she have to backup her good gameplay with when expressing it to the jury? She is one of the top three players this season, but next to Parvati she
pales in comparison, then both are lower tier then Cirie.
Up until last episode all she did was ride on Ozzy's back, then tagged along with the femalliance. |
|||
ProbstFan123 |
|||
|
Exactly. When Amanda is sitting next to Parvati or Cirie, she will crumble again in front of the jury like she did last season.
Batting her eyelashes and making pouty faces isn't going to work on anyone except Ozzy. Let's see her try that with Eliza or Alexis or Natalie and see how far it gets her. |
|||
platinumtlc |
|||
assface killah wrote: Actually, I don't like her...
|
|||
SurvivorArctic |
|||
|
She can't game worth shit and if she wins, she will rank with Amber in my least favourite winner ever pile.
One game move does not a good gamer make. |
|||
maxmartin33 |
|||
|
She won't win, but if she did, I'd be cool.
|
|||
yosimtesam |
|||
|
One thing i did notice at the last tribal council with amanda is that when she pulled out the idol she said that she didnt lie... while saying that during this
tribal council seemed appropriate; i dont think it would be appropriate theme for her at final tribal council. . i hope she does not pull the same "i am
honest and didnt lie and innocent" routine she did at china in the final tribal as this could backfire. In reality, if you really think about what amanda
has done so far she has really played a very similar game to what she did in china allowing other people like parv and cirie do the dirty work while she sits
back; though it seems she might be in a better place this time because she formed better relationships.. it will be interesting final tribal especially if its
cirie, amanda, and parv
|
|||
Relynn |
|||
yosimtesam wrote: Last time though Amanda voted exactly the same as Todd. This time she hasn't stabbed anyone in the back... So there is a difference there. Hopefully
Amanda will make a jury speech like this.
Last Edited By: Relynn
05/04/08 9:29 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
platinumtlc |
|||
|
How would I feel if Amanda won?
|
|||
AllMenAreIslands |
|||
|
The season has been awesome regardless of who wins. Having said that, it would be most worth it to me if Parvati wins since I got her in the office pool. If
she loses I have to throw in $10. If she wins, I get $190.
If Parvati can't win, then Cirie would be my next choice. Other than those two, while I like all who remain, anyone else winning poses problems ranging from difficult to catastrophic for Edgic. But it would still have been a very entertaining season. |
|||
Katy Carney |
|||
|
An Amanda win would leave me underwhelmed. At least an Erik or Natalie win would leave me shocked shitless with an Eliza-esque eyes bulging hand over my heart
reaction.
|
|||
hippo2002 |
|||
I'll be happy as Eliza & Jason
|
|||
mtj1282 |
|||
|
Posts: 1081 (05/05/08 5:44 AM) |
GrenadeJumper85 wrote: Many of the past winners road coat-tails atleast for some part of the game. Riding coat-tails isnt neccesarily a bad thing. If you are there to win the million, the manner in which you win shouldnt matter as long as you do in fact win. There is no right or wrong way to play or to win so im not sure how you can say taht shes pales in comparison to parvati. Amanda may have the winning stratedgy or she may not, but if she wins, it doesnt really matter. |
||
Relynn |
|||
mtj1282 wrote: Thank You! There is nothing wrong with making a strong alliance in the beginning of the game and sticking with it for most of the game. Jonathon Penner said that's the way you get to merge and get near the end. Towards the end, you definetly need to make a move..But thats' towards the ned. Besides, the show has shown millions of times that if you flip flop and backstabb most of the jury, You won't win. Making promises to all may get you to the end of the show but it's hard to get you to the end. |
|||
Zesty66 |
|||
|
^X. I think Joel proves what can happen when you make big moves in the beginning.
|
|||
Relynn |
|||
Zesty66 wrote: Exactly, I remember the look on the Favorite's faces when Mary was voted out, they were like Mary? And they even said we couldn't understand why they were voting out they way they were voting. Mikey B was clearly a bad social player but he was right about the moves Joel was making. |
|||
XXWildcat |
|||
|
If Amanda can make it to F3 this game is hers regardless of her Jury performance. This jury is not going to look at it the same way the China jury did, this is
going to be an emotional jury.
The only way Amanda doesn't win is if she takes Cirie to the F3. Then it's a toss up, but I give a slight edge to Amanda even then. I think Parv is out she is viewed to much of a schemer even though the only real person she's outted is Ozzie. As for Amanda riding coat tails, read/listen to the James interviews, it was Amanda and Parv doing all the scheming regardless of what was shown on TV. His and Ozzie's jobs were to get food and the girls did the "socializing". We saw Ozzie nominating who should be going, but Amanda was at his side the whole time, they wanted his edit to show him as the leader that got blindsided. Amanda deserves some credit, here and in China. For the record I'll take any of the 3 women Favorites as a winner, Parv, Amanda or Cirie, or as I like to call them The PAC. |
|||