2. David C.
3. Danny
4. Michael
5. David A.
6. David H.
7. Chikezie
8. Luke
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
curve31 |
|||
|
1. Jason
2. David C. 3. Danny 4. Michael 5. David A. 6. David H. 7. Chikezie 8. Luke |
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
Ewww why is everyone ranking Castro so high? There's so many superior versions of that song out there, hell there are multiple better versions by Idol
contestants alone for "Hallelujah." He was far from brilliant.
1. Cook 2. Michael 3. Hernandez 4. Archuleta 5. Danny 6. Chikeze 7. Jason (no bitch, I'm not impressed that you picked Hallelujah) Large Gap 8. Luke (wtf?) |
|||
8trackmind |
|||
|
I agree with Static Cling on the first 5 (the 3 Davids, Michael and Jason). David H is the marginal one of the five, so I'm voting for him in spite of
despising Celine Dion. #6 Chakezie-good, not great. But I think he belongs in the top 12, and I'm voting for him as well. #7 Luke-third so-so performance
in a row. Ought to be gone thursday, justifiably. #8 Danny-his second disaster in 3 weeks. I'm hoping he will be the shocking final boot like Sundance last
year.
|
|||
opendoor50 |
|||
|
The guys suck. Oh wait, they're the most talented ever. David A for the win with David Cook holding on for a while. Jason Castro will be this year's
Ace. The boots should be Luke and Chiceze with Danny getting the VFTW vote although he sucked and should leave tonight. People that were super meh - Aussie,
David H, Castro, super suck - Luke, Danny, Chiceze okay - Cook, David A.
As far as I know, there are 3 straight guys total in this crew. You figure it out. I refuse to believe this show hasn't jumped the shark. If people watch, it's out of habit and coz there's nothing else on.
Last Edited By: opendoor50
03/04/08 8:46 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
dirkismyhomeboy |
|||
|
1. David Cook
|
|||
James Barber |
|||
|
1. David Cook - not new, not original, not different, but still good
2. Jason 3. David H - plenty of flaws, but some good spots; the rest were worse 4. Michael - boring and he wasn't even trying 5. Chikeze 6. David A - awful song choice, weak performance 7. Danny - tired, boring, gimmicky, pissed all over what could have been a fine performance 8. Luke I think Luke and David H are gone this week. |
|||
CassandraRevisited |
|||
|
1. Cook
2. Castro 3. Hernandez 4. Johns 5. Noriega 6. Eze 7. Archie 8. Menard H: Archie/Menard B: Menard/Hernandez G: Menard/Noriega |
|||
LostInTheDelta |
|||
|
1. Jason
2. David C. 3. David A. 4. David H. 5. Chikezie 6. Danny 7. Michael 8. Luke |
|||
PhantomPlanetQueen |
|||
|
1. David Cook and Jason Castro
2. Danny 3. David A 4-8 - Everyone else Brain: Luke/Chikeze Heart: Luke/Chikeze Gut: Luke/David H |
|||
RobertBestBarbie |
|||
|
Sorry, wrong thread.
|
|||
cabanachat |
|||
|
1. David C.
2. Jason 3. David A. 4. David H. 5. Michael 6. Luke 7. Chikezie 8. Danny |
|||
Fcuk You ywia |
|||
|
1. Jason Castro
2. Danny 3-8. The rest of those chumps Brain: Chikezie and Luke Heart: David A. and H. Gut: Jason and Danny |
|||
Ginawantsme |
Good for them | ||
|
1. Jason
2. Michael 3. Luke 4. David C. 5. David H. 6. Daniel 7. Chikize 8. Danny N. - This guy makes Sanjaya seem like a sane choice. |
|||
Mai4 |
|||
|
1. David Cook - WOW. Amazing. I didn't even know what song it was at first. Brillant!!
2. Aussie - Much Much Much better than last week. Plus I loved his song choice! 3. Jason - Simple and beautiful performance. Good to know he can sing without a guitar. 4. David H. - Parts were great! Couple of bum notes and weird faces, but overall GREAT! 5. David A. - Vocals were flawless as always, but I really didn't like the song. 6. Chickeze - Great song choice. But I still don't like his voice nor do I think he's unique. Blah 7. Danny - Flaming <3, but his performance and vocals were just ok. 8. Luke - SEND DAWSON BACK TO HIS CREEK!!!! Horrible. BOTTOM 2: Luke (Please god let me be right this time!!) & Danny (Gut feeling...Jacuzzi will ROB him) |
|||
Starzburst05 |
|||
|
1. David Cook
2. David Harnandez 3. Jason Castro 4. Michael Johns 5. Danny Noriega 6. Chickezie Eze 7. David Archuleta 8. Luke Menard Brain: Chickezie/Luke Heart: David A/Luke Gut: Luke/Chickezie or David H |
|||
dcartist |
|||
|
David Cook - nice job. It sounded genuine, not WANNABE.
Jason Castro - One of my all-time favorite groups. One of my all time favorite versions. I wish somebody on the show would sing THE FUTURE or EVERYBODY KNOWS. Danny Noriega - "And then I turned as red as a little tomato... TMTH"... Gawd that was hilarious and awesome. I knew that "Tainted love" would be divisive. He really needs to sing some real soul or something. At least Danny has some modern taste. Most of these guys are really out of touch with today's music. I think Danny is really strong on his musical sense, but he's very high strung. Simon is cracking up, always has a HUGE grin on his face when Danny sasses him. It's awesome. Thanks for doing uptempo. Michael - He has bad taste. I don't think he's that musical. Simon hit the nail on the head: He's better doing soul than he is doing wannabe rock. The low end of his range sounds poor, not great. In his low register, he sounds like he's talking, not singing. David Archuleto - It's the usual. I don't really get him at all. But he was OK today. David Hernandez - technically OK. But his voice just sounds so damn affected. It's squeezed down & nasal, and I hate those kind of voices. Also, overall the different parts of the vocals didn't sound good together. The soft parts were thin and almost inaudible... When he belts, it sounds like he's pinching a loaf. Probably not fair, but I don't like DH's voice. Chikeze - Hate this guy's singing. Nice guy. No charisma on stage. Luke - by far the worst. Who told him that his falsetto sounds good? It's too damn thin sounding for a lead vocal. It sounds like he's poking fun when he sings falsetto like that... like he was on SNL or Mad TV or something. Terrible.
Last Edited By: dcartist
03/04/08 10:07 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
Beautiful Patsy |
|||
|
1 - 8/10 - Jason Castro - Wonderful vulnerability in this performance
2 - 8/10 - David Cook - Great showman and great spin on the song 3 - 7/10 - David Archuleta - Good dark piano performance 4 - 6/10 - Chikezie - Showed off his great singing voice 5 - 4/10 - Michael Johns - Nice lower notes 6 - 4/10 - David Hernandez - There was a great long note in the middle 7 - 3/10 - Danny Noriega - Very dramatic performance 8 - 3/10 - Luke Menard - High voice |
|||
MargoK.joshgroban |
|||
|
Just from tonight's performances (3-4-08) I'd rank them this way: 1. Chickeze 2. David H. 3. Jason 4. David A. 5. Michael 6.David C 7.Danny 8. Luke |
|||
Frankie G Morris |
|||
|
1. Aussie
2. David Cook. Can't remember what any of the rest of them did - so I will give them a meh. |
|||
curve31 |
|||
1. ChickezeThat made my eyebrows go crooked. |
|||