ForgotPassword?
Sign Up
Search this Topic:
Forum Jump
Posts: 17138
12/30/08 05:46 PM
Registered User
Mikester wrote: Kitty Pryde1 wrote: But what about Helen or Tammy or Teresa? Why did it HAVE to be Amber and Jenna? Maybe it didn't? You don't necessarily know what went into casting. They could have very well asked certain other women before Amber or Jenna or someone else. Jenna and Amber could have been two of only a certain amount of girls willing to do it again.
Kitty Pryde1 wrote: But what about Helen or Tammy or Teresa? Why did it HAVE to be Amber and Jenna?
Posts: 234
12/30/08 06:17 PM
Posts: 29187
12/30/08 06:20 PM
Registered user
Posts: 14620
12/30/08 06:37 PM
Posts: 12791
12/30/08 06:41 PM
Kitty Pryde1 wrote: Mikester wrote: Kitty Pryde1 wrote: But what about Helen or Tammy or Teresa? Why did it HAVE to be Amber and Jenna? Maybe it didn't? You don't necessarily know what went into casting. They could have very well asked certain other women before Amber or Jenna or someone else. Jenna and Amber could have been two of only a certain amount of girls willing to do it again. According to Mario, T-Bird and Helen both WANTED to play but weren't asked.
12/30/08 06:45 PM
Posts: 11423
Posts: 4251
12/30/08 10:35 PM
WylDawg wrote: Holy mother of hell!!!! Are we SERIOUSLY still arguing the All-Stars cast 5 years later??? And it's done and over with, move the fuck on, people!
Posts: 122
12/31/08 04:13 AM
Posts: 1737
12/31/08 01:05 PM
Posts: 4274
12/31/08 01:28 PM
12/31/08 01:38 PM
roxbury123 wrote: You people are insane about All Star casting. You can not replace anyone who wasn't cast. Its a known fact everyone was asked, anyone who says they were not asked if they were able to do all stars is a liar. Elisabeth and Colleen turned it down at this first phone call, they were never cast, they were never replaced. And FYI Elisabeth and Colleen were virtually they same character there is NO WAY both would have made the show. And think about it they also would have never placed Alicia and Elisabeth on the same team, so Elisabeth did not replace Amber, if anyone she replaced Alicia. Amber was prob. put on for the Jerri connection[similar to the Ethan-Tom-Lex, and Tina-Colby Connection] to see how they would react. Amber/Jerri v. Tina/Colby would have been a incredible rematch to watch take place, but it never happened [we did get Jerri v. Colby though]. Elisabeth brought nothing game wise to Australia she would have been a waste of space. Colleen over Jenna would have been interesting though. AGAIN YOU CAN NOT REPLACE SOMEONE WHO WAS NEVER CAST. Its all spec that if Colleen and Elisabeth said yes they would have been cast. and again I'm sorry but use your brains Elisabeth and Colleen would have not both been cast. And you all bitch about only Amber and Jenna L the dominat girls of All Stars, Shii Ann and Alicia both should have been replaced, Kathy and Tina and Sue was a huge disapointment, and Jenna M should have never went. The only girl who lived up was Jerri all other 8 girls were duds, and ironically the two you all said should not have been casted became the dominat girls of the season.
Posts: 68
12/31/08 02:43 PM
roxbury123 wrote: and again I'm sorry but use your brains Elisabeth and Colleen would have not both been cast.
Colleen Haskell, the first show's resident cutie pie, also turned down the offer. "[She] had moved on with her life and just genuinely didn't want to go through that again," Burnett says." If Burnett had his way, Colleen & Elisabeth both would have been on ASS. End of story.
Posts: 3597
12/31/08 11:40 PM
muskger99 wrote: Also regarding Amber, Jeff Varner once upon a time said that she was the last second replacement for Kelly Goldsmith, and not the replacement for Elisabeth, because the producers found out about her and Rob and decided they wanted a romance storyline so they added her to the cast at the last minute
Posts: 103
01/01/09 12:15 AM
Posts: 2679
01/01/09 03:45 AM
Kirblar wrote: T-Bird wouldn't be asked because they had Tina. Helen wouldn't be asked because they had Kathy. Kelly G was cut because they had Shii Ann. All 3 were very similar personality-wise to another player already on the cast.
01/01/09 03:48 AM
survivorjordancontestant wrote: muskger99 wrote: Also regarding Amber, Jeff Varner once upon a time said that she was the last second replacement for Kelly Goldsmith, and not the replacement for Elisabeth, because the producers found out about her and Rob and decided they wanted a romance storyline so they added her to the cast at the last minute FUCK, kelly G. would've been awesome.
Posts: 3321
01/01/09 12:38 PM
01/01/09 01:15 PM
Oowatanite wrote: muskger99 wrote: Also regarding Amber, Jeff Varner once upon a time said that she was the last second replacement for Kelly Goldsmith, and not the replacement for Elisabeth, because the producers found out about her and Rob and decided they wanted a romance storyline so they added her to the cast at the last minute You are an idiot if you think there was anything going on between Rob and Amber before ASS.
Share This Link