My pick would be Natalie Tenerelli. I have a good friend who is a Boston Blob fan (as you call tell I am not a fan, but he sure is) and he doesnt even remember Natalie Tenerelli being on the season when I mentioned her a few months ago despite her being Rob's best friend/closest ally of that season and being a finalist who was was the best friend/closest ally of 2 of the final 5- Rob and Ashley. That is how utterly forgettable, meh, and irrelevant she is.Plus isnt the ultimate of an irrelevant finalist a dead stick or piece of road kill who had no chance of winning vs anyone or no matter what. Yep that was Natalie T more than any other finalist in the shows history. She is the only one who before FTC I couldnt imagine having even a tiny sliver of shot of winning, and who I cant think of a hypothetical Final 3 or Final 2 in the seasons of a Final 2) where I cant imagine her having even a sliver of hope of winning. In fact you run through most of the hypothetical Final 3s that you can invent involving her and 2 others from the merge, and the vast majority she gets 0 votes in, which is incredibly rare even for the biggest goats. There is a reason Rob was so dead set on protecting her as if she was his life insurance, and it wasnt their big brother/little sister relationship. It was because he knew she was useless shit who was never winning, the same reason he took Phillip as well but unlike Phillip, Natalie was not a fascinating character who contributed a great deal to the season as a finalist despite being a huge goat who couldnt win vs anyone. Remember the choice shouldnt just be based on being a huge goat.