Rank the Winners

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
SurvivorGuy91		#1281	[-]
Posts: 26 (09/26/09 5:02 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	He hardly outflanked Terry, because Terry had to get immunity week in and week out, which he did, and there was nothing Aras could do to get him out. Aras didn't get rid of Terry, Danielle did, because she thought people would have more ill will towards Aras than Terry. Terry's tribe got Pagongned, too. And I honestly don't think that Aras could beat Terry anyway, even if he apparently "threw" challenges. And the only way Aras would beat Cirie would be a lesser of two evils situation, not because of his game.
Blatantly Oblivious		#1282	[-]
Posts: 944 (09/26/09 5:04 PM) I don't get most of the jokes Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1 - Rich 2 - JT <3<3<3 3 - Ethan<3<3 4 - Todd 5 - Tom 6 - Todd 7 - Brian 8- Tina 9 - Sandra 10 - Danni 11 - Yul 12- Jenna 13 - Earl 14 - Bob 15 - Aras 16 - Chris 17 - Vee 18 - Amber 9
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#1283	[-]
Posts: 9147 (09/26/09 5:30 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	SurvivorGuy91 wrote: He hardly outflanked Terry, because Terry had to get immunity week in and week out, which he did, and there was nothing Aras could do to get him out. Aras didn't get rid of Terry, Danielle did, because she thought people would have more ill will towards Aras than Terry. Terry's tribe got Pagongned, too. And I honestly don't think that Aras could beat Terry anyway, even if he apparently "threw" challenges. And the only way Aras would beat Cirie would be a lesser of two evils situation, not because of his game. No, it played into Ara's strategy for Terry to win the challenges, because Aras' forced his tribe to keep him so he could beat Terry. Whether or not he did is irrelevent until the final 3. Of course Aras was lucky that Danielle won the final challenge and not Terry, but after all, it is impossible to win Survivor and NOT be lucky. It doesn't matter why you win, it just matters that you win. Nobility and honor is for losers. Last Edited By: Dr Will Hatch two point oh 09/26/09 5:41 PM. Edited 1 times.
SwineForkbeard		#1284	[-]
Posts: 2463 (09/26/09 5:40 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	"I got my butt kicked out here by the elements. I got my butt kicked by Terry Deitz a lot of the time. I got my butt kicked by my own shortsightedness, falling down on the rocks. Despite the fact that I made it 39 days, I feel like my ego has been crushed." Still tossing Aras's salad after all this time I see. Watch the show again and quit making up these fanfics. His comments at the end wouldn't have made any sense if he had been losing on purpose.
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#1285	[-]
Posts: 9149 (09/26/09 5:44 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Sure it does. He's training to become a Yogi. Yogi's are supposed to be modest and not self serving. He's not the only winner to deny the fact that he's strategical. And even if he wasn't consciously strategical, he was still a better player than Terry by getting to the final 2.
SwineForkbeard		#1286	[-]
Posts: 2464 (09/26/09 6:03 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	If it's some big secret how strategic he was, why is it that only you know about it, and never point to any actual evidence? If he was being modest, he wouldn't have admitted to having an ego in the first place. Is there any evidence to support this "argument," or is this just more fanfic bullshit? If he was lying in that confessional, prove it.
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#1287	[-]
Posts: 9151 (09/26/09 6:23 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	We don't have solid evidance for anything other than the edited material we're given and the hearsay of contestants. Based on Aras' attitude at the FTC and in interviews, he obviously isn't going to give himself credit. I don't know about you, but I'm calling all of this apocrypha. Besides, who gives a shit if Terry kicked his ass in challenges? Terry didn't make it to the final two, too bad for him.
SwineForkbeard		#1288	[-]
Posts: 2465 (09/26/09 6:33 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Dr Will Hatch two point oh wrote: We don't have solid evidance for anything other than the edited material we're given and the hearsay of contestants. That's right, and you don't even have that going for you. Arguments must be supported with evidence. So I would suggest that you either get some evidence or stop trying to argue.
Dr Will Hatch two point oh		#1289	[-]
Posts: 9152 (09/26/09 6:40 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	It's circumstantial evidence.
JohnnyK		#1290	[-]
Posts: 143 (09/26/09 8:11 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Hatch - 10/10 Tina - 9/10 Ethan - 8/10 V - 5/10 Brian - 7/10 Sandra - 5/10 Amber - 2/10 Chris - 7/10 Tom - 8/10 Yul - 10/10 Todd - 9/10 JT - 8/10 Those not listed I will rank in the future.
great personality		#1291	[-]
Posts: 2 (09/28/09 11:22 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	18. Bob 17. Tom 16. Earl 15. Yul 14. JT 13. Aras 12. Parvati 11. Danni 10. Ethan 09. Amber 08. Sandra 07. Brian 06. Chris 05. Todd 04. Jenna 03. Rich 02. Tina 01. Vee
SleepTight		#1292	[-]
Posts: 59 (09/29/09 5:21 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	JohnnyK wrote: Hatch - 10/10 Tina - 9/10 Ethan - 8/10 V - 5/10 Brian - 7/10 Sandra - 5/10 Amber - 2/10 Chris - 7/10 Tom - 8/10 Yul - 10/10 Todd - 9/10 JT - 8/10 Those not listed I will rank in the future. I like this except for poor Sandra.
sddorme.idolnoise	My Top-Bottom	#1293	[-]
Posts: 44 (09/29/09 3:19 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Ranked 1-18 Parvati - My favorite in Survivor: Micronesia. Liked her strategy, and liked how she played people to get further Jenna - My favorite in Survivor: The Amazon, thought she was underrated, and she was right, Christy was a terrible strategist Sandra - Loved her personality. Made the right alliances and being screwed over many times, she recovered and won Yul - Season was a little overrated but definitely the best male in Cook Islands, especially the overrated Ozzy Tom - Nice guy, really deserved the money. Just liked Steph a lot more Danni - Same thing with Tom, great girl, good at the game, but liked Steph more Ethan - Very nice guy, but a little boring J.T. - Good, but didn't care for the merged tribe in Tocantins so didn't like the end Bob - Cool guy, fun guy, great camper, but led by Corinne with strategy a little bit Tina - Nice woman, but did a little less strategy than most winners, and liked the Kucha tribe better Richard - Fun to watch, just more deserving people in the game Amber - I didn't think she rode any coattails and liked her better than Boston Rob (I'm a New Yorker), but didn't deserve to be an all-star Todd - A little annoying, but he was okay Earl - I found him having no personality, and no strategy Vecepia - Okay girl, deserved the money, but didn't stand out to me Aras - Liked Danielle better and didn't care for his strategy Chris - Worked hard for the million, but kinda deserved to leave at the first tribal Brian - Terrible season, terrible winner Last Edited By: sddorme 09/29/09 3:21 PM. Edited 1 times.
ghost poyozo		#1294	[-]
Posts: 95 (10/10/09 12:41 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	From favorite to least favorite. 1. Yul 2. Tina 3. Tom 4. Bob 5. Ethan 6. Amber 7. Sandra 8. Jenna 9. Parvati 10. Aras 11. Vecepia 12. Earl 13. Danni 14. Todd 15. J.T. 16. Brian 17. Richard 18. Chris
SleepTight		#1295	[-]
Posts: 112 (10/10/09 9:04 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Been rewatching earlier seasons and i'll rate them for personality and game-play. Richard: Personality - 7/10 Gameplay - 7/10 (he invented it, but he also had it easy) Tina: Personality - 5/10 Gameplay - 5/10 Brian: Personality - 0/10 Gameplay - 8/10 Jenna: Personality - 4/10 Gameplay - 5/10 Sandra: Personality - 8/10 Gameplay - 6/10 Amber: Personality - 3/10 Gameplay - 6/10 Chris: Personality - 2/10 Gameplay - 8/10 Tom: Personality - 5/10 Gameplay - 6/10 Danni: Personality - 9/10 Gameplay - 7/10 Aras: Personality - 7/10 Gameplay - 6/10 Yul: Personality - 9/10 Gameplay - 9/10 Earl: Personality - 6/10 Gameplay - 6/10 (Impressive for someone who never watched Survivor) Todd: Personality - 7/10 Gameplay - 8/10 Parvati: Personality - 5/10 Gameplay - 7/10 Bob: Personality - 7/10 Gameplay - 6/10 J.T.: Personality - 5/10 Gameplay - 6/10
troynuncdicit		#1296	[-]
Posts: 467 (10/10/09 1:54 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	SleepTight wrote: Yul: Personality - 9/10 Gameplay - 9/10
LKMOSCAR		#1297	[-]
Posts: 7990 (10/10/09 2:37 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Based on how much I like them: 1. Sandra 2. Parvati 3. Richard 4. Danni 5. Ethan 6. Jenna 7. Aras 8. Vecepia 9. Tina 10. JT 11. Todd 12. Brian 13. Earl 14. Chris 15. Bob 16. Amber 17. Tom 18. Yul
agent2424		#1298	[-]
Posts: 4640 (10/10/09 3:16 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	SleepTight wrote: Been rewatching earlier seasons and i'll rate them for personality and game-play. Richard: Personality - 7/10 Gameplay - 7/10 (he invented it, but he also had it easy) Tina: Personality - 5/10 Gameplay - 5/10 Brian: Personality - 0/10 Gameplay - 8/10 Jenna: Personality - 4/10 Gameplay - 5/10 Sandra: Personality - 8/10 Gameplay - 6/10 Amber: Personality - 3/10 Gameplay - 6/10 Chris: Personality - 2/10 Gameplay - 8/10 Tom: Personality - 5/10 Gameplay - 6/10 Danni: Personality - 9/10 Gameplay - 7/10 Aras: Personality - 7/10 Gameplay - 6/10 Yul: Personality - 9/10 Gameplay - 9/10 Earl: Personality - 6/10 Gameplay - 6/10 (Impressive for someone who never watched Survivor) Todd: Personality - 7/10 Gameplay - 8/10 Parvati: Personality - 5/10 Gameplay - 7/10 Bob: Personality - 7/10 Gameplay - 6/10 J.T.: Personality - 5/10 Gameplay - 6/10 So your saying.... Aras and Bob have the same personality as Hatch? and that Amber has more strategy than Tina
SkyDreamer		#1299	[-]
Posts: 266 (10/10/09 5:03 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	SleepTight wrote: Been rewatching earlier seasons and i'll rate them for personality and game-play. Richard: Personality - 7/10 Gameplay - 7/10 (he invented it, but he also had it easy) Tina: Personality - 5/10 Gameplay - 5/10 Brian: Personality - 0/10 Gameplay - 8/10 Jenna: Personality - 4/10 Gameplay - 5/10 Sandra: Personality - 8/10 Gameplay - 6/10 Amber: Personality - 3/10 Gameplay - 6/10 Chris: Personality - 2/10 Gameplay - 8/10 Tom: Personality - 5/10 Gameplay - 6/10 Danni: Personality - 9/10 Gameplay - 7/10 Aras: Personality - 7/10 Gameplay - 6/10 Yul: Personality - 9/10 Gameplay - 9/10 Earl: Personality - 6/10 Gameplay - 6/10 (Impressive for someone who never watched Survivor) Todd: Personality - 7/10 Gameplay - 8/10 Parvati: Personality - 5/10 Gameplay - 7/10 Bob: Personality - 7/10 Gameplay - 6/10 J.T.: Personality - 5/10 Gameplay - 6/10 Chris played a better game than Danni and Parvati? Yul had more strategy than Todd? Todd and Richard were equally entertaining as Aras? JT was more strategic than Tina?
OrsNaz		#1300	[-]
Posts: 206 (10/10/09 5:15 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Richard [Controlled the game from beginning to end.] 2. Brian [Hated the guy but he pretty much had the game from day 1] 3. Tina [Her and Colby pretty much decided who went when without any objections. No one even opposed them] 4. Todd [His biggest threat was Courtney. Enough said. Dominated the strategy aspect of the game.] 5. Parvati [Stupid cast aside, she had the perfect game. Flawless in my eyes. I rate her low because she obviously had a stupid cast, and the amount of quitters and evacuations really fucked up the game] 6. Tom [I hate him but he dominated both physically and mentally.] 7. J.T. [He managed to convince the entire opposing tribe to just throw the game away just with his personality. He booted the loose cannons, kept his cool and played a damn good game.] 8. Yul [The idol was too powerful at that time and Jonathan was an idiot. Yul was clearly the smartest and best social player of the season but that really doesn't say much.] 9. Ethan [Well liked, decently played] 10. Sandra [I really liked her, but some of her decisions made absolutely no sense. Laid low and managed to finally start playing a good game at final 5. Not bad otherwise.] 11. Earl [Heh.] 12. Jenna [Isolated tribe members, very shallow etc. Took her too long to start playing the game but when she did she did it flawlessly] 13. Aras [Loyal alliance & ok player. Way to vocal and obnoxious though] 14. Danni [Steph and Rafe were idiots. Sure she was likable but that doesn't make her a good player, it just makes Steph and Rafe terrible players. They literally knocked off all their alliance members and their best chances of winning the game. Plus, not keeping lydia? Retarded] 15. Chris [Twila was the mastermind, this douchebag just got lucky. She literally need to spell out E-L-I-Z-A for him, without that he never would have even approached her. Sure he played it good from then on but it was that one move that changed the game and thus Twila should have won] 16. Vecepia [Im still shaking my head] 17. Amber [Boston Rob, thats all I need to say. She did absolutely nothing] 18. Bob [Great at challenges, but the only reason he made it past the final 8 is because of Sugar playing it up for the cameras. Terrible winner. Sugar dominated the entire game and only lost because of a bitter jury. Susie deserved it more than Bob]

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Rank the Winners

Quick Reply