S-24 Edgic (Editing & Logic) in Survivor Speculation Forum

0 Points

S-24 Edgic (Editing & Logic)

Started By	Comment
RedCoffee		#7441	[-]
Posts: 2857 06/02/12 06:00 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I was hoping the RickLobsta avatar would be something like Zoidberg with Rick's mustache photoshopped on. Oh well. ------ RW: I don't know how all of you did it for so long. One season of being a watchdog was PLENTY for me to realize I don't belong in upper management around here. Put me in the R&D wing and I'll come up to the meetings if it seems important
	Remove this ad
RickLobsta		#7442	[-]
Posts: 8 06/02/12 06:05 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	RedCoffee wrote: I was hoping the RickLobsta avatar would be something like Zoidberg with Rick's mustache photoshopped on. Oh well. why would I do that. I don't get the reference.
evans992		#7443	[-]
Posts: 1 06/02/12 06:14 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Axie wrote: Phoenix1269 wrote: Alicia - CPN I think she was MORN. She has only 5 CPs and only the first two were actually big episodes for her. People giving CPN to Alicia and MOR to Jay is weird. I'd agree that Jay is a low-visibility CP, but I'm pretty determined on Alicia being complex as well. She was complex in the premiere, swap episode AND Colton's medevac eppy (the OTT for that episode is still wrong imo), then went a little quiet for a couple of episodes (even though her merge confessional explained her entire upcoming strategy and I'd have maybe rated her a CP2 there too), resurfaced at Leif's boot episode where she weighed her options and then was consistently insightful from the family visit episode until the finale, where I also found her complex. That's 7 complex episodes and enough for a CP imo. The only rating I disagree with is Nina's MORM, since UTR+CP/OTT does not equal MOR, but w/e.
fat little fingers		#7444	[-]
Posts: 7738 06/02/12 09:57 PM Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	RoLo: then just quit already. gosh gosh?
georgiaknight33		#7445	[-]
Posts: 1865 06/03/12 08:38 AM Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I'm shocked that Monica got UTRP and not MORP...
RockLobsta		#7446	[-]
Posts: 5632 06/03/12 08:47 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	fat little fingers wrote: RoLo: then just quit already. gosh gosh? that wasn't even me :retard:
Phoenix1269		#7447	[-]
Posts: 2067 06/03/12 09:57 PM Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	9RedWing19 wrote: RedCoffee wrote: The amount of commitment these things take seems underestimated by a lot of people. Even just being a watchdog for one thing made for pretty much mandatory Edgic participation in making a hotly debated call every single week. If you just sort of flippantly vote whatever you voted for originally without giving it any due thought, sure it's speedy... until you have to explain yourself to all of the people you just pissed off with your vote. Same with something like Warrior's job. Lots of time spent and it has to be quality work, lest you incite the masses. Unless you get off on the idea of being "the boss" or some sort of "Edgic bigwig," many of these jobs are high-demand, zero-reward positions. There's a reason most Edgic overseers eventually pass the torch to someone else. As someone involved in charts & ratings back in the Edgic dark ages, there is no big red X big enough to second this comment. nice to see you RW! and i agree with this... there is no x red enough or big enough for this. Thanks RC, nicely summed up. BTW @ the ZING! lol
Phoenix1269		#7448	[-]
Posts: 2067 06/03/12 10:06 PM Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Axie wrote: Phoenix1269 wrote: Alicia - CPN I think she was MORN. She has only 5 CPs and only the first two were actually big episodes for her. People giving CPN to Alicia and MOR to Jay is weird. Alicia has 11/12 overall votes for CP, 1 vote for OTT, zero votes for MOR. In addition, in her chart, she has 6 CP episodes for the season (including the finale). Only Chelsea & Kim have more CPs than Alicia (7 and 9 respectively). Jay, OTOH, ended up with only 3 official CPs and some MORs that were so-so CPish. Jay starts MOR... has a total of 3 MOR, 3 CP and 2 UTR episodes, and has a cummulative VF of 2.6 and no tone... i think MOR is appropriate for Jay. For comparison... Troy (who no one has complained about being overall CP) has only 4 CP episodes, 4 MOR episodes, a UTR and a couple of OTTs. I think Alicia is just fine as an overall CPN.
Phoenix1269		#7449	[-]
Posts: 2067 06/03/12 10:08 PM Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	RedCoffee wrote: I was hoping the RickLobsta avatar would be something like Zoidberg with Rick's mustache photoshopped on. Oh well. LOVE <3 <3 RickLo... you can use this for your avi if you want... to hilarious to pass up chopping. ;)
Phoenix1269		#7450	[-]
Posts: 2067 06/03/12 10:13 PM Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	georgiaknight33 wrote: I'm shocked that Monica got UTRP and not MORP... i think that is realistic... Monica had 3 UTR and 2 CP with a cumulative VF of 2.6 and 3 of 5 epis were P. She never drew a MOR and none of her episodes were a close call. One of her CPs was on her boot episode. I do not subscribe to the CP + UTR = MOR equation... so i think that a UTRP for her is appropriate.
	Remove this ad
troynuncdicit		#7451	[-]
Posts: 3337 06/04/12 01:49 AM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Phoenix1269 wrote: Axie wrote: Phoenix1269 wrote: Alicia - CPN I think she was MORN. She has only 5 CPs and only the first two were actually big episodes for her. People giving CPN to Alicia and MOR to Jay is weird. For comparison... Troy (who no one has complained about being overall CP) has only 4 CP episodes, 4 MOR episodes, a UTR and a couple of OTTs. I complained ^_^
fat little fingers		#7452	[-]
Posts: 7738 06/04/12 10:50 AM Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	RiLo: that wasn't even me :retard: jiminy cricket!
alometry45		#7453	[-]
Posts: 1 06/04/12 04:03 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Christina being such a UTRM goddess <3
Survivorfan0		#7454	[-]
Posts: 308 06/05/12 01:01 AM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I can't belive Christina got UTRM. Her UTR3 and OTTP5 in episodes 5 and 6 are ridiculous.
Not		#7455	[-]
Posts: 338 06/05/12 02:06 AM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	The fact the people are still bitching about this and that after the season is done tells how much of a pain being "management" must be. I was going to ask about the futures board, because i also like knowing about the cast before it is announced, but i guess that's answered already :/ Alica MOR? I think whoever came up with this idea is mistaking Alicia for her sister, Leticia is MOR i agree.
RickLobsta		#7456	[-]
Posts: 8 06/05/12 11:51 AM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Phoenix1269 wrote: RedCoffee wrote: I was hoping the RickLobsta avatar would be something like Zoidberg with Rick's mustache photoshopped on. Oh well. LOVE <3 <3 RickLo... you can use this for your avi if you want... to hilarious to pass up chopping. ;) pass
evans992		#7457	[-]
Posts: 1 06/05/12 04:15 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Nina's MORM makes no sense. If Monica is UTRP (which she should be since UTR+CP does not equal MOR), Nina should then be either UTR or CP, with the latter being clearly more logical.
RedCoffee		#7458	[-]
Posts: 2857 06/05/12 04:46 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	If Nina is anything, it should be WTFBBQ. Episode 1 = Almost nothing. Episode 2 = Legitimate case to be made for MOR, OTT, and CP. Arguments for P, N, and M. I propose a nice reddish-brown color to demonstrate this. Shoot for something in the smoky/spicy range.
Lexxan		#7459	[-]
Posts: 16141 06/05/12 05:37 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Maybe we should just have a separate rating for CPP/OTT stuff?
Not		#7460	[-]
Posts: 338 06/06/12 03:22 AM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	When someone who was INV or UTR goes CP in their boot episode i see it as a clear case of saving your ass OTTness.
	Remove this ad

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

S-24 Edgic (Editing & Logic)