Performance Comparison Thread (cause you know someone else did it better) in American Idol/X-Factor Forum

0 Points

Performance Comparison Thread (cause you know someone else did it better)

Started By	Comment
suckshardcore		#721	[-]
Posts: 38235 04/12/12 02:11 PM Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I liked Elise's and thought her voice sounded great, BUT add me to the list of people who thinks Haley's was much better. The judges can all choke on Nigel's cock.
	Remove this ad
27ravens		#722	[-]
Posts: 915 04/19/12 01:04 AM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I love Joshie but Queen Syesha owns that song! She even did research and related it to her own life!!! (Also worth watching to see Randy look like an idiot)
glitterbabies		#723	[-]
Posts: 14359 04/19/12 06:27 AM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	So randy's been proving since�at least Season 7 what a fucking idiot�he is.....Syesha's performance�was amazing...... � shit quality video but the vocals are impeccable
HardEdge1980		#724	[-]
Posts: 517 04/19/12 03:19 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	27ravens wrote: I love Joshie but Queen Syesha owns that song! She even did research and related it to her own life!!! (Also worth watching to see Randy look like an idiot) I hated Screamesha, but that was one of her best performances on the show. Definitely better than Joshua's. Also, Gedeon > Josh. While I'm at it: Gay Stripper's ITMH� >>> P2's
Wildcat612		#725	[-]
Posts: 2801 04/20/12 12:28 AM Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Gedeon > Syesha > Joshua. Joshua's was too toned down for me. Of all the songs to sing, this was one where OTT is acceptable. In Syesha's, I hated the way she sang the "I'm afraid to die" line. Gedeon's had an amazing tone.
sandradanni		#726	[-]
Posts: 849 04/21/12 04:27 AM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	haley reinhart catalog: fallin- jessica i'm your babay tonight- elise you really got a hold on me- jen hirsh rolling in the deep- hollie you and i - elise
ImANewUser		#727	[-]
Posts: 11804 04/21/12 05:05 AM Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I still can't believe so many people are going with Haley's song choices last season I now half-expect people to choose "House Of The Rising Sun", "Bennie and the Jets", "Earth Song" or something.
suckshardcore		#728	[-]
Posts: 38235 04/21/12 10:07 AM Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Proof that no one gives a shit about what the judges say. They hated Haley and trashed her song choices more often than not.
sandradanni		#729	[-]
Posts: 849 04/21/12 07:17 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	ImANewUser wrote: I still can't believe so many people are going with Haley's song choices last season I now half-expect people to choose "House Of The Rising Sun", "Bennie and the Jets", "Earth Song" or something. Possible would be You Oughta Know, Rhiannon and What Is and What Should Never Be by Elise
Merely		#730	[-]
Posts: 13853 04/25/12 04:16 PM Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	pre-empting for tonight NO ONE WILL TOP CARLY'S PERFORMANCE
	Remove this ad
suckshardcore		#731	[-]
Posts: 38235 04/26/12 05:01 PM Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	"Ready for Love" Theresa vs Joshua. I was going to do "Bold as Love" Elise vs Brian Melo, but Brian's CI performance of it isn't on Youtube. IMO both in both cases were great. I'd give Theresa the edge on "Ready for Love" though, her voice and her soul on that song are too beautiful.�
8trackmind		#732	[-]
Posts: 3625 04/26/12 05:16 PM Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I like the season 11 contestants, but it's no battle for me as far as last night's remakes go: Re "The Show Must Go On:" Paris & Carly (I actually like Paris' version a bit better) > Skylar Re "Bohemian Rhapsody:" Constantine > Kellie > Jessica
Miraclemax		#733	[-]
Posts: 3937 04/26/12 09:49 PM Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts
27ravens		#734	[-]
Posts: 915 04/27/12 01:57 AM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Timmy Urban's "Crazy Little Thing Called Love" is still the best ever. <3 <3 <3
suckshardcore		#735	[-]
Posts: 38235 04/27/12 02:22 PM Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Ewww Max why would you post that? The Manatee loses no matter what.
Frankie G Morris		#736	[-]
Posts: 19592 04/29/12 08:10 AM All your ghosts are belong to us Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Wow - the judges (or whatevia they are) are wordy fucks on Canadian Idol.
pigbenis		#737	[-]
Posts: 584 04/29/12 12:54 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	27ravens wrote: Timmy Urban's "Crazy Little Thing Called Love" is still the best ever. <3 <3 <3 <333 his sliding <33333
R Nucleus		#738	[-]
Posts: 40 04/29/12 01:26 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Jessica's BoRhap was just average, but much superior to Constantine's. His voice is just so technically flawed and weak.
glitterbabies		#739	[-]
Posts: 14359 04/29/12 01:48 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Adam's 30 second of BoRhap in his audition is 100x better than anyone else's ~truth [/fantard]
suckshardcore		#740	[-]
Posts: 38235 04/29/12 03:16 PM Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Everyone knows Cher Maendel's BoHo Rhap is the best, she finally showed them she can sing.�
	Remove this ad

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Performance Comparison Thread (cause you know someone else did it better)