S-24 Edgic (Editing & Logic) in Survivor Speculation Forum

0 Points

S-24 Edgic (Editing & Logic)

Started By	Comment
jonnyfairplay		#1241	[-]
Posts: 2180 02/23/12 08:27 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	evans992 wrote: jonnyfairplay wrote: Wait, why are there so many people who have Sabrina eliminated or "barely hanging on?" What did I miss? Her being the most visible player 2 episodes in a row (and being female at the same time)? What are you not getting? I don't understand why logicially a high-vis complex neutral-positive female can't win, but you're right that that has been a pattern.
	Remove this ad
Bulletin Bored		#1242	[-]
Posts: 27920 02/23/12 08:32 PM Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	evans992 wrote: there is a difference between having high visibility and being THE most visible person in both of the first two episodes. There's a difference. But is there a RULE?
Phoenix1269		#1243	[-]
Posts: 2066 02/23/12 08:40 PM Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	it's not a rule, but in 23 previous seasons, we have 0 winners with this VF pattern (ie most visible in both E1 & E2)
Bulletin Bored		#1244	[-]
Posts: 27920 02/23/12 08:42 PM Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	You agree that there's always the possibility, right?
CirieSurvivor		#1245	[-]
Posts: 1209 02/23/12 08:43 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	evans992 wrote: Why are people comparing Jonas' edit to Sophie anyway? Sophie is FEMALE. Males never gets edits like that. Yes but she's the most recent winner we have. With huge similarities like this along with a brilliant winner's quote and an obvious power alliance set up, along with being on the tribe that obviously holds the winner due to the Female Craziness, Jonas is the winner choice. His comparisons with Sophie along with all of the other information make it obvious. He's the leader right now.
Bulletin Bored		#1246	[-]
Posts: 27920 02/23/12 08:46 PM Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	So um...remember the last time people made their Sole Survivor pick based on huge similarities to the most recent winner?
drowsy12		#1247	[-]
Posts: 14279 02/23/12 08:47 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Bulletin Bored wrote: So um...remember the last time people made their Sole Survivor pick based on huge similarities to the most recent winner? yeah I couldn't tell if she was being sarcastic or not.
astroline		#1248	[-]
Posts: 5676 02/23/12 08:57 PM Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Oh my god if Sabrina was a guy she would be the #1 pick by a mile in here. Not surprised though.
CirieSurvivor		#1249	[-]
Posts: 1209 02/23/12 08:59 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Bulletin Bored wrote: So um...remember the last time people made their Sole Survivor pick based on huge similarities to the most recent winner? If it was just that then I wouldn't be on board. There are contributing factors which you seemed to ignore. So yeah. Look again, jackass.
evans992		#1250	[-]
Posts: 1 02/23/12 09:03 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	CirieSurvivor wrote: evans992 wrote: Why are people comparing Jonas' edit to Sophie anyway? Sophie is FEMALE. Males never gets edits like that. Yes but she's the most recent winner we have. With huge similarities like this along with a brilliant winner's quote and an obvious power alliance set up, along with being on the tribe that obviously holds the winner due to the Female Craziness, Jonas is the winner choice. His comparisons with Sophie along with all of the other information make it obvious. He's the leader right now. Yeah, I wouldn't be so sure about that this early.
	Remove this ad
evans992		#1251	[-]
Posts: 1 02/23/12 09:04 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	astroline wrote: Oh my god if Sabrina was a guy she would be the #1 pick by a mile in here. Not surprised though. Exactly. but she's not, so why are we even having this discussion? Sabrina defines the word distraction.
fat little fingers		#1252	[-]
Posts: 7738 02/23/12 09:05 PM Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Zesty, you're being way outta line. Warrior's been quietly and consistently posting a clear and accurate Vis chart for many seasons. He doesn't brag or make demands or show off. It takes a lot of commitment to maintain a chart like that week after week and we all benefit from his unselfish work. If you want to maintain a different visibility charting formula, great! I look forward to seeing the results. Last Edited By: fat little fingers 02/24/12 12:13 PM. Edited 1 times.
Bulletin Bored		#1253	[-]
Posts: 27920 02/23/12 09:07 PM Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I looked just fine the first time. My point is, a Sophie comparison alone is enough to make me question him in the first place. Add in the fact that his "brilliant winner's quote" is only brilliant if he wins and that neither tribe "obviously" contains the winner at this point and him being the leader becomes less of a certainty.
frosty88		#1254	[-]
Posts: 19 02/23/12 10:03 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	He's getting unnecessary focus - the guys haven't even gone to tribal council yet, but they still make sure we know who this guy is. That alone is enough to make him a contender.
Bulletin Bored		#1255	[-]
Posts: 27920 02/23/12 10:11 PM Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I never said he wasn't a contender.
frosty88		#1256	[-]
Posts: 19 02/23/12 10:13 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I'm still firmly convinced that edgic can't pick a definitive winner. It can only tell you the group of 5 or 6 players who have a shot at winning. After that it's a total crapshoot. Right now Jonas, Kim and Chelsea are definitely in that group. Maybe Troyzan too.
Jedijake		#1257	[-]
Posts: 7557 02/23/12 10:16 PM MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Sophie was tied to an alliance from the very beginning and even made a comment regarding the alliance or at least part of it (her comments about Coach). There was a tinge of complexity in Sophie's edit from the getgo. Jonas didn't have that. Still a decent contender and the most likeable member of Menano (that we've seen at least), but no complexity. If anything, Kim is more like Sophie with a touch more visibility...not a bad thing. Btw...looks like Chelsea will have another decent episode next week in terms of air time, but will have a major struggle with the elements. Wonder how that will play out with her sustained winning chances.
Soladrian		#1258	[-]
Posts: 899 02/23/12 10:18 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Most of my ratings are the usual except the glaring exception of Colton. Colton was CP this episode, more specifically CPOVERDRAMATIC. He was still CP though, analyzing his position in the game and the OTT, again come from him being an OTT personality. Alicia - OTTN3 Bill - UTR2 Chelsea - MOR3 Christina - UTR2 Colton - CPN5 Greg - OTT1 Jay - UTR1 Jonas - MOR2 Kat - OTTN5 Kim - MOR3 Leif - UTR1 Matt - INV Michael - MOR3 Monica - CPP3 Nina - CPN5 Sabrina - MOR5 Troyzan - MOR2 Top Contender (5 points): Kim Looking Good (4 points): Chelsea, Jonas Has Potential (3 points): Troyzan, Sabrina, Monica, Michael Edit has some flaws, but not eliminated yet (2 points): Jay Barely hanging on (1 point): Colton, Leif, Christina Eliminated (0 points): Nina, Greg, Kat, Alicia, Bill, Matt, Kourtney No changes in my top tier but Sabrina gets a hit for being too visible and will probably stay there for the rest of the season. Troyzan, Monica and Michael move up for being somewhat more visible in this episode. Jay gets a hit for being barely visible this episode. Colton's too unstable and would be more sympathetic being the outcast if he was the winner, while Leif and Christina lack any real story in their edit. Nina gets eliminated for being voted out while Greg and Kat are eliminated for being too OTT.
evans992		#1259	[-]
Posts: 1 02/23/12 10:18 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Both Chelsea & Kim seem to be getting decent eppys next time. Like I said, by episode 4 we should have a clear idea who the definite main contenders are.
drowsy12		#1260	[-]
Posts: 14279 02/23/12 10:20 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	what are you guys basing that on? the preview?
	Remove this ad

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

S-24 Edgic (Editing & Logic)