S-24 Edgic (Editing & Logic) in Survivor Speculation Forum

0 Points

S-24 Edgic (Editing & Logic)

Started By	Comment
dotsdfe		#281	[-]
Posts: 2533 02/15/12 08:45 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	A woman winner seems too obvious right now. They're way more P and way more complex. I'm not buying it.
	Remove this ad
RedCoffee		#282	[-]
Posts: 2864 02/15/12 08:46 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	They had to be pissed about this. "Fucking Pagongings! I bet if they lived together there would be all sorts of cross-tribe craziness!" One World contains a bunch of bitchy people who refuse to cooperate except for one guy who apparently will need immunity every round to survive "Motherfuckers!" Although I think both tribes are playing this wrong, I agree that the flow seems to be going toward the females to some small extent.
et91		#283	[-]
Posts: 2856 02/15/12 08:46 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Women got a better, more P edit in Vanuatu too. So be careful here
Cfc		#284	[-]
Posts: 1737 02/15/12 08:46 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Christina and Sabrina CPs <3
et91		#285	[-]
Posts: 2856 02/15/12 08:50 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Christina isn't super CP. She's a CP-lite MOR, which I will put as MOR. I think. I don't know.
Taterman		#286	[-]
Posts: 1695 02/15/12 08:53 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Yeah, we hardly know half of the men. The women have been way more characterized as a tribe and as individuals. To be fair, it could be partly because they're going to tribal.
et91		#287	[-]
Posts: 2856 02/15/12 08:57 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Kourtney got, what, a MORP exit episode at best? Horrible
dotsdfe		#288	[-]
Posts: 2533 02/15/12 09:00 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	First impressions votes. This will be way off but I'll re-watch later in the week. Matt – CPN4 Mike – UTRN1 Leif – MORP2 Colton – CPP5 Jay – CP3 Greg – OTTM3 Bill – INV1 Troyzan – MOR3 Jonas – MOR3 Kourtney – UTRP2 Monica – MOR2 Sabrina – CP5 Chelsea – CP3 Kat – UTR1 Kim – MOR3 Alicia – CPM5 Nina – UTR2 Christina – OTTN4
Redsox5975		#289	[-]
Posts: 906 02/15/12 09:08 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I didn't see anyone on the men get that good of an edit besides Colton. I think Kim, Sabrina and Chelsea are ones to look out for. Alicia is being set up as a character/distraction. Matt didn't seem to complex to me. He was more OTT, but I could be wrong. I'll have to rewatch before doing any raitings.
Taterman		#290	[-]
Posts: 1695 02/15/12 09:08 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Well, I lurked all of last season, so I'm going to give this a try this season too. I don't think I'm actually going to post any ratings till my second watch though (which should be tommorrow) so I can give descriptions and so they'll be more accurate.
	Remove this ad
Raydawggie		#291	[-]
Posts: 970 02/15/12 09:09 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Sabrina obviously looks like the slam-dunk winner pick right now, but first episodes are often misleading.
drowsy12		#292	[-]
Posts: 14288 02/15/12 09:11 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Sabrina, Kim, Chelsea for the Women Jay seems to be the only male that got a good winner edit
Taterman		#293	[-]
Posts: 1695 02/15/12 09:11 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Also, it kind of pewtered out during the second half of the episode, but I definitely felt like Jonas got a surprisingly good edit (I was kind of leaning CP for him, but on a rewatch I could be willing to go for MOR.) Of course, I agree that the women as a whole look much better, with Chelsea and Sabrina (and Kim and Monica to lesser extents) being the standouts.
Zesty66		#294	[-]
Posts: 6050 02/15/12 09:11 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	ALICIA - CPN4 CHELSEA - UTR4 CHRISTINA - MORN3 KAT - UTRM2 KIM - NAR3 KOURTNEY - NARP3 NINA - UTR1 MONICA - MOR2 SABRINA - CP5 BILL - UTR1 COLTON - CPP5 JAY - NARN3 JONAS - MOR3 LEIF - OTTP2 MATT - CPN3 MICHAEL - UTRN3 TARZAN - OTT3 TROYZAN - OTTM4
Redsox5975		#295	[-]
Posts: 906 02/15/12 09:13 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Jonas wasn't that complex. He seemed more of a narrator than anything else
dotsdfe		#296	[-]
Posts: 2533 02/15/12 09:15 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Yeah, Jonas was basically a narrator. I considered giving him a NAR, but I really don't want to start more controversy right now.
RedCoffee		#297	[-]
Posts: 2864 02/15/12 09:16 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	First impressions! Salani Kourtney - Well at least my preshow favorite is out early so I can be mostly unbiased : / Nina - Pretty much irrelevant. She hurt her face. Monica - Don't remember much. She stole fire I think. Christina - The only goddamn diplomat in the game. Seems to be way more important than the rest of the on-the-outs women. Worth keeping an eye on if the theme ever shifts to "cooperation = good." Alicia - Alliance orchestrating, mean, nasty, rude. Looks to be in the wrong on firegate. Complex, but could easily go OTTN overall. Kat - "The dumb chick." Pretty bad start. Kim - Nice MOR/CPish presence. Comments on things, seems in tune, explains her overall game to start. Not bad. Sabrina - Very central character and a nice moderate CP contrast to people like Alicia. However, she pretty much had to get development here because of the idol. Chelsea - More OTT than strategic. She's a big outdoorsy country chick. I don't think the edit made her seem necessarily "right" on the chicken fiasco. Matt also makes good arguments that they had a deal she backed out on. We'll see how I feel on the rewatch. Manono Leif - He's a strong little dude. That's about it. Jonas - Lots of footage but sort of ehh. Maybe MORish but I don't remember much depth at all. Troyzan - Dick measuring comment about who gets to be tarzan. Some evaluations of the women but not much beyond that. Greg - He's also tarzan. Apparently it's hilarious that some of the women thought he was in charge. Colton - Key character early. Felt sort of CPOTT to me. "I'm fabulously devious and oh so complex!" seems to be the message. Jay - The official "anti women's team" voice - he wants to beat them. Little else I remember. Bill - The girls suspect he may be the leader but he's basically a faceless number in Matt's clique. Michael - Manono's official master thief. Not much there beyond that. Matt - Evil buff dude alliance overlord. Not nearly NN - just cocky. The women look more complex, but the tribe going to tribal council ALWAYS looks more complex. There's still time for the men, though some have a better start than others. Looking weak already: Nina, Monica, Kat, Bill, Greg Wouldn't be surprised if they fail but still reasonable: Alicia, Colton, Troyzan. Chelsea Strongest so far: Women - Christina, Kim, Sabrina Men - Matt (evil CP genius possible) Looooooong way to go.
Redsox5975		#298	[-]
Posts: 906 02/15/12 09:22 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Redcoffe, where does Kim fall into place in that?
SeveC		#299	[-]
Posts: 6600 02/15/12 09:23 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	I would say Sabrina could be a solid winner pick but her vis was so high.... This is much different from the first episode of SP where I seriously had like 6 winner contenders and this time I'm struggling for 3-4. Best wait till episode 2, but if I had to come up with 4 right now: 1. Kim 2. Jonas 3. Sabrina 4. Kat
mattd		#300	[-]
Posts: 319 02/15/12 09:24 PM Reply Quote More Recent Posts	Initial thoughts: Bill - INV Colton - CPP5 Greg - OTT2 Jay - MOR3 Jonas - CP3 Leif - UTRP1 Matt - CPN4 Michael - OTTN3 Troy - MORN3 Alicia - CP4 (thinking about giving her the N here) Chelsea - CPP3 Christina - MORN3 Kat - UTR2 Kim - MOR3 Kourtney - UTRP2 Monica - MORP2 Nina - UTR1 Sabrina - CP5 Winner: Monica Back-Ups: Sabrina Jonas Chelsea Not Eliminated: Colton Greg Jay Leif Troy Alicia Christina Kat Kim Nina Eliminated: Bill Matt Michael Kourtney
	Remove this ad

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

S-24 Edgic (Editing & Logic)