Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
A Lying Down		#3961	[-]
Posts: 171 (06/19/09 2:06 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Based on the actors who are doing DVD commentaries, I'd assume it means the killer is... Spoiler [+] Henry. Since the only others doing one are not-very-suspicious Chloe & Sully, and the late JD
enjoyresponsbly		#3962	[-]
Posts: 3 (06/19/09 2:06 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] I think we can rule out Nikki and Jimmy as Wakefield's child with Sarah Mills because, as we know from the flashbacks, they're both the same age as Abby and, assuming Abby is Sarah's child, I doubt Sarah would have given birth to twins and only given one up for adoption. Two seperate births from the same woman so close to each other in date is physically impossible. And the whole incest thing with Jimmy I think is too much. Really. I don't want to believe that Abby is Wakefield's child, it's too easy. Also, did you see the look on her face when the Sheriff told her "You're my child! Mine! And don't you ever forget that!" It was like she was thinking Well if I'm not, then who is? although the Sheriff may have been going for the whole He may be your biological father, but I raised you. Last Edited By: enjoyresponsbly 06/19/09 2:13 PM. Edited 1 times.
JoshCflyring		#3963	[-]
Posts: 779 (06/19/09 2:10 PM) "Jay Leno is funny" Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Nikki and Shea will NOT die.
SurvivorNinja		#3964	[-]
Posts: 875 (06/19/09 2:12 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	The killers are all of the blondes! It's so very obvious. Cal, Chloe, Nikki and Sully teamed up to take down the wedding. They invited Lucy to join them but she refused so they had to have her killed. The blonde foursome then had a debate on whether or not to include Beth. When Beth turned out to be much like her hair (completely indecisive on what colour it is) in personality..the Blonde quartet had to dispose of her too. The blondes will continue to survive until the end where we will find out that Wakefield and Sarah had tripets (Sully, Chloe and Nikki) and then Chloe met up with Cal who fell in love with her murderous family and they all decided they were mad Abby wasn't a blonde like them..so they killed EVERYONE! Blondeownage!! ETA: All four blondes will die in the next episode at the hands of a telekinetic Madison and her devious new puppy Gigi. Last Edited By: SurvivorNinja 06/19/09 2:14 PM. Edited 1 times.
swim4life227		#3965	[-]
Posts: 7275 (06/19/09 2:14 PM) OMEDETO, CATHY!! Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I can't see Shea dying unless Madison dies too. They aren't cruel enough to leave Madison without parents. I'm wondering if they'll end the series with Madison being foreshadowed as the next Wakefield.
SEGScapegoat		#3966	[-]
Posts: 103 (06/19/09 2:25 PM) I don't get most of the jokes Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	christy1018 wrote: SEGScapegoat wrote: Is the show on twice a week? It's on Sat night here. We haven't seen that episode. I'm ok with being spoiled (or I wouldn't be reading this thread), but I'm confused and jealous that you already got to see it! it airs early in Canada (on Thursday nights) and sometimes they graciously upload it early for us. You can watch it here: http://www.wisevid.com/view_video.php?viewkey=9bc3b1a208cfaacc4b2d ETA: link was previously posted by Kenneth <-- Thanks! Thank you Christy and Kenneth!
GoHomeAndEatYoRice		#3967	[-]
Posts: 869 (06/19/09 2:37 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I know who the killer is! Spoiler [+] Who was the only person missing during the Cannery Hideout? GiGi! She was too busy setting up Doggy-Usable Guns and tying up hanging ropes. Then, after Maggie left she used Julia Mitchell G.oddess to kill Maggie. Then, spared Julia's life because she does not attack locals. Unless they get out of their UTR streak. So, GiGi was feeling bored and hanged Maggie in from the window for the lulz. But, Maggie was so fat. It took a long time to get her there. And Maggie was so fat she broke the rope. Then, GiGi decided to become BFFz with John Wakefeild. And blamed him for the killings, that she has been doing.
YemaGrl1988		#3968	[-]
Posts: 6294 (06/19/09 2:56 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	^ Bravo. Best.Post.Ever.
allymw		#3969	[-]
Posts: 162 (06/19/09 3:16 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] I think some people are making this out to be a little more complicated than it actually is... Mrs. Wellington has barely been mentioned in the show, so I really don't see her being Wakefield's OTHER mistress. This isn't really a soap opera.... The journal clearly said Abby's mom had Wakefield's kid. You guys have some creative imaginations though. I also don't think that Jimmy and Abby are siblings.... no, they didn't have sex, but they clearly made out many times and Abby's mom let her daughter go off camping with him knowing what would happen... pretty sure she wouldn't do that if she gave birth to him and Abby. I'm thinking it's gotta be Henry now. He's not the same age as Abby right? Although Nikki is a definite possibility. Henry would be the most obvious choice for a shocking twist, yet all the signs pointed to him the whole time. Nikki fits the producer's 1/3, 1/3, 1/3 prediction though. Actually so does Booth.... The whole time I watched the episode, until Wakefield was shown, I was convinced that Booth was alive. Oh, and to those who brought it up...Maggie is definitely dead. They showed her body hanging during at least one shot of the Cannery after she was hung....
SurvivorNinja		#3970	[-]
Posts: 876 (06/19/09 3:22 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	allymw wrote: Spoiler [+] I think some people are making this out to be a little more complicated than it actually is... Mrs. Wellington has barely been mentioned in the show, so I really don't see her being Wakefield's OTHER mistress. This isn't really a soap opera.... The journal clearly said Abby's mom had Wakefield's kid. You guys have some creative imaginations though. I also don't think that Jimmy and Abby are siblings.... no, they didn't have sex, but they clearly made out many times and Abby's mom let her daughter go off camping with him knowing what would happen... pretty sure she wouldn't do that if she gave birth to him and Abby. I'm thinking it's gotta be Henry now. He's not the same age as Abby right? Although Nikki is a definite possibility. Henry would be the most obvious choice for a shocking twist, yet all the signs pointed to him the whole time. Nikki fits the producer's 1/3, 1/3, 1/3 prediction though. Actually so does Booth.... The whole time I watched the episode, until Wakefield was shown, I was convinced that Booth was alive. Oh, and to those who brought it up...Maggie is definitely dead. They showed her body hanging during at least one shot of the Cannery after she was hung.... ETA: I care not to add spoiler tags since i'm Canadian and this isn't a spoiler to me anymore.. stupid.fucking.spoiler.tags.for.non.spoilers. Last Edited By: SurvivorNinja 06/19/09 3:24 PM. Edited 1 times.
tullfan2		#3971	[-]
Posts: 3502 (06/19/09 3:42 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] We have seen who the killer is in the flashback episode. The man who killed the harbor master with the head spade has a narrow waist. John Wakefield was about 40 years old at that time and seems to be powerfully built and not thin. The killer we see in the flashback could be a 17 or 18 year old boy because he has a small waist. I think that John Wakefield did not kill the harbor master, Abby's mom and Kelly's mom but that his son killed them. John Wakefield has a vendetta against people in law enforcement because he was convicted of a crime that he did not commit and spent 17 years in jail. I think that he is responsible for kidnapping Madison, killing the deputy in the jail, killing Cole Harkin, killing the 2 state police, the marina explosions and killing the sheriff. I don't think that he killed anyone else other than perhaps Kelly. Coincidentally, I noticed that in the recaps for the past 2 episodes, Cole Harkin and the deputy were not included in the body counts. I think that is because they were killed by John Wakefield and not the main killer. I think that the main killer is Wakefield's son and that he and John Wakefield are acting independently. I don't think that Wakefield knows who his son is, so he shot at everyone to keep them from leaving. With the sheriff now dead, Wakefield's motive may actually be to avenge his former lover Sarah's death and not to kill Abby. He may have kidnapped Madison and the sheriff to get Abby to come to him. Wakefield may want to use Abby as bait for Sarah's killer so that he can avenge Sarah's death. Somehow, Uncle Marty and his cash should have a role in this and this will be answered in the final 3 episodes. Bottom line - the killer is either Henry or Booth.
tullfan2		#3972	[-]
Posts: 3503 (06/19/09 3:50 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] There are still 3 scenes left in the season preview from the end of episode 2 that haven't come up yet. 1. Danny lights a candle in the church ("I think that we need a prayer") 2. A woman drops a glass of wine. 3. Abby hits someone with the back side of a gun
Simdog11		#3973	[-]
Posts: 262 (06/19/09 3:51 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	tullfan2 wrote: Spoiler [+] We have seen who the killer is in the flashback episode. The man who killed the harbor master with the head spade has a narrow waist. John Wakefield was about 40 years old at that time and seems to be powerfully built and not thin. The killer we see in the flashback could be a 17 or 18 year old boy because he has a small waist. I think that John Wakefield did not kill the harbor master, Abby's mom and Kelly's mom but that his son killed them. John Wakefield has a vendetta against people in law enforcement because he was convicted of a crime that he did not commit and spent 17 years in jail. I think that he is responsible for kidnapping Madison, killing the deputy in the jail, killing Cole Harkin, killing the 2 state police, the marina explosions and killing the sheriff. I don't think that he killed anyone else other than perhaps Kelly. Coincidentally, I noticed that in the recaps for the past 2 episodes, Cole Harkin and the deputy were not included in the body counts. I think that is because they were killed by John Wakefield and not the main killer. I think that the main killer is Wakefield's son and that he and John Wakefield are acting independently. I don't think that Wakefield knows who his son is, so he shot at everyone to keep them from leaving. With the sheriff now dead, Wakefield's motive may actually be to avenge his former lover Sarah's death and not to kill Abby. He may have kidnapped Madison and the sheriff to get Abby to come to him. Wakefield may want to use Abby as bait for Sarah's killer so that he can avenge Sarah's death. Somehow, Uncle Marty and his cash should have a role in this and this will be answered in the final 3 episodes. Bottom line - the killer is either Henry or Booth. Spoiler [+] I'm not sure I agree with all of your logic leading up to the last statement, but I will agree with your last sentence. With Maggie dead and Wakefield alive, I really think it's got to be Henry. Boring. Although, does anybody else wonder why Cole Harkin unleashed his attack dog on Trish and Mr. Wellington? Maybe Trish is the daughter of Wakefield after all. I dunno. I'm grasping at straws because I don't want to believe in the obvous answer of Henry as the killer/accomplice to Wakefield. Last Edited By: Simdog11 06/19/09 3:59 PM. Edited 2 times.
AlwaysAwesomeAdam		#3974	[-]
Posts: 3241 (06/19/09 3:57 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Simdog11 wrote: tullfan2 wrote: Spoiler [+] We have seen who the killer is in the flashback episode. The man who killed the harbor master with the head spade has a narrow waist. John Wakefield was about 40 years old at that time and seems to be powerfully built and not thin. The killer we see in the flashback could be a 17 or 18 year old boy because he has a small waist. I think that John Wakefield did not kill the harbor master, Abby's mom and Kelly's mom but that his son killed them. John Wakefield has a vendetta against people in law enforcement because he was convicted of a crime that he did not commit and spent 17 years in jail. I think that he is responsible for kidnapping Madison, killing the deputy in the jail, killing Cole Harkin, killing the 2 state police, the marina explosions and killing the sheriff. I don't think that he killed anyone else other than perhaps Kelly. Coincidentally, I noticed that in the recaps for the past 2 episodes, Cole Harkin and the deputy were not included in the body counts. I think that is because they were killed by John Wakefield and not the main killer. I think that the main killer is Wakefield's son and that he and John Wakefield are acting independently. I don't think that Wakefield knows who his son is, so he shot at everyone to keep them from leaving. With the sheriff now dead, Wakefield's motive may actually be to avenge his former lover Sarah's death and not to kill Abby. He may have kidnapped Madison and the sheriff to get Abby to come to him. Wakefield may want to use Abby as bait for Sarah's killer so that he can avenge Sarah's death. Somehow, Uncle Marty and his cash should have a role in this and this will be answered in the final 3 episodes. Bottom line - the killer is either Henry or Booth. Spoiler [+] I'm not sure I agree with all of your logic leading up to the last statement, but I will agree with your last sentence. With Maggie dead and Wakefield alive, I really think it's got to be Henry. Boring. Although, does anybody else wonder why Cole Harkin unleashed his attack dog on Trish and Mr. Wellington? Maybe Trish is the daughter of Wakefield after all. I dunno. I'm grasping at straws because I don't want to believe in the obvous answer of Henry as the killer/accomplice to Wakefield. Spoiler [+] YEah I've been bringing that up since Day 1. Cole knew or suspected who the murderer was. The only person that he ever try to harm was Trish and Mr. W. Plus the bullett Henry got could have been intended for Trish.
allymw		#3975	[-]
Posts: 163 (06/19/09 4:02 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Simdog11 wrote: Spoiler [+] I'm not sure I agree with all of your logic leading up to the last statement, but I will agree with your last sentence. With Maggie dead and Wakefield alive, I really think it's got to be Henry. Boring. Although, does anybody else wonder why Cole Harkin unleashed his attack dog on Trish and Mr. Wellington? Maybe Trish is the daughter of Wakefield after all. I dunno. I'm grasping at straws because I don't want to believe in the obvous answer of Henry as the killer/accomplice to Wakefield. Spoiler [+] Probably the same reason he set up the log trap and the trap that got the Sheriff--he doesn't like trespassers and he knows there's a killer out there/knows Wakefield is alive. I'm thinking about the Uncle Marty/money situation.... maybe Uncle Marty knew that Henry killed people in the Seattle area and was paying someone off to keep their mouth shut. It seems like the money was just part of the boat trap anyway... so maybe the Booth "death" really was an elaborate plan.
superkyle		#3976	[-]
Posts: 896 (06/19/09 4:22 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] If John Wakefield is alive and has been the accomplice all along, then doesn't that mean that Booth really is dead? We've already got a super secret accomplice, so why have multiple accomplices? Before Maggie's corpse turned up, I thought she was just walking to the Harbor to sink the other boat, but I guess that's not the case... I wouldn't be surprised if it was Jimmy or Nikki now.
Zeep		#3977	[-]
Posts: 9336 (06/19/09 4:25 PM) Psycho Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Fuck this show. I can't imagine any reveal that would make up for the lameitude thus far. GAH.
micknrc		#3978	[-]
Posts: 485 (06/19/09 4:27 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I'm waiting for the Sat. night viewing, but lol at the half-a-dozen pages of spoiler tags. You guys slay me. so tempted
LPMA		#3979	[-]
Posts: 4307 (06/19/09 4:28 PM) OMEDETO, CATHY!! Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	That's not a spoiler so I won't be using spoiler tags. They made a point of showing us a "No Tresspassing" sign before the dog unleashing scene. I just wrote it off as him getting rid of tresspassers before we even found out who he was.
Que		#3980	[-]
Posts: 1414 (06/19/09 4:42 PM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	now repeat after me..... BOOTH IS DEAD...D.E.A.D. BOOTH IS DEAD. EVERYONE is trying so hgard to make this so convoulted and complex and it's not. I don't think we will ever find out all those nagging danglers like WHY DID UNCLE MARTY HAVE CASH AND A GUN? Who broke all the china? etc... Why was the reverend killed? Was JD dying of cancer? Why was red ink in Kelly's eyes? Why did Jimmy yell and drive off in the flashback scene when he saw a deranged looney dragging a body. Why was cousin Ben killed in the first place? WHERE are ALL the people that actually live on the Island? Why allude that Madison speaks to ghosts...Why show her torturing the snail? Spoiler [+] I think Abby is Wakefield kid, but will acept if it turns out to be Henry. Wakefield is out killer

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

Quick Reply