Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
Utopian		#3681	[-]
Posts: 5870 (06/16/09 8:08 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I'd be pretty pissed off if the killer turned out to be Maggie or Nikki or anyone NOT on the bingo card. Get ready to be pissed off. The card and the word "suspects" is just a bunch of misdirection regarding the identity of the killer.
myopics		#3682	[-]
Posts: 778 (06/16/09 8:16 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	tullfan2 wrote: Beth was killed when she went off looking for Madison by herself. I am strongly ambivalent about this. On the one hand, it does explain that whole the whole blood trail / the killer didn't have time to kill Beth thing. If Beth followed the trail herself or wandered down the tunnels before the killer spotted her, it means that the killer needed a much smaller window to off her. Not everyone has an airtight alibi anymore. On the flip side, it was an extremely stupid and out of character thing for Beth to do.
cabanachat		#3683	[-]
Posts: 3101 (06/16/09 8:17 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	it's so addictive. that it's not getting better ratings is a testament to its shoddy production values. imagine how much we'd all care if it was actually well-written, -edited, and/or -acted.
Joaqenix		#3684	[-]
Posts: 4224 (06/16/09 8:29 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	About the "Beth was killed when she went off by herself thing"...cool. Why couldn't we have seen that though? Its ridic that there have been 9 episodes and we still haven't had any stereotypical horror death chase scenes. I guess they don't want to reveal who the killer is, but surely they can just film around that. I'm REALLY tired of all these deaths where people just find bodies way after they've died. That is my one complaint with the show.
Katy Carney		#3685	[-]
Posts: 6441 (06/16/09 8:29 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Where is all this info in the show? I hope they release Director's Cut DVDs or some shit.
Gregoire		#3686	[-]
Posts: 33261 (06/16/09 8:37 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I feel like I'm watching Friday the 13th stretched out to the epic length of The Winds of War. Do you know how much force you would have to have to drive a pear of garden shears through a piece of furniture and deep into a human body? From that angle, it would be near impossible.
pjadedd		#3687	[-]
Posts: 9648 (06/16/09 8:56 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I don't buy the Beth went looking for Madison on her own stuff because that wasn't in Beth's personality (from what we saw). And, when they found her lantern, it was laying on the ground. I don't see her just dropping it to go off and search.
AlwaysAwesomeAdam		#3688	[-]
Posts: 3189 (06/16/09 9:01 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I also doubt that the actressses would knwo if Booth were alive or not since none of the boots know what happens in the Finale. Once an actor/actress was gone they didn't get anymore issues of the script. They were there for the extended cut of Malcom's death therefore its a sure thing.
Joaqenix		#3689	[-]
Posts: 4226 (06/16/09 10:11 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: I also doubt that the actressses would knwo if Booth were alive or not since none of the boots know what happens in the Finale. Once an actor/actress was gone they didn't get anymore issues of the script. They were there for the extended cut of Malcom's death therefore its a sure thing. Unless they're all included in the final episode to show you how the killer killed everyone, which I really hope happens. But on that note, maybe THATs how we see Booth again. And then everyone here can finally stfu about him.
pjadedd		#3690	[-]
Posts: 9649 (06/16/09 10:58 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Yeah, I would imagine that there are going to be flashbacks (I hope), showing how the likes of Kelly, Beth, and Katherine were killed.
JoshCflyring		#3691	[-]
Posts: 768 (06/16/09 11:14 AM) "Jay Leno is funny" Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Kelly committed suicide.
AmightyRo		#3692	[-]
Posts: 944 (06/16/09 11:19 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	JoshCflyring wrote: Kelly committed suicide. Yup, after she injected red ink into her eyes.
WallJ		#3693	[-]
Posts: 609 (06/16/09 11:47 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	pjadedd wrote: Yeah, I would imagine that there are going to be flashbacks (I hope), showing how the likes of Kelly, Beth, and Katherine were killed. I'm not holding my breath on this. I don't think we'll get a big Scooby Doo/Murder She Wrote rundown of how the killer did everything. I hope I am wrong.
Coachocd		#3694	[-]
Posts: 7720 (06/16/09 11:50 AM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	tullfan2 wrote: Here are some rumors that I have seen on other boards. I don't believe them but I'm posting them here in the event that one of them turns out to be true. 1. The killer is Abby's fraternal twin. Abby is really Sheriff Mills daughter but her twin is John Wakefield's child. 2. The murders and the wedding are not real. Everything is a product of Abby's imagination. After she saw her Mom hanging from the Tree of Woe, Abby went mad and the sheriff sent her away to a mental institution. Some info from the CBS web chat with the actresses that played Katherine and Beth: Thomas Wellington married Katherine because the Wellington family had large debts and these were eliminated with Katherine's help. Beth was killed when she went off looking for Madison by herself. When asked if Malcolm was still alive, both actresses said that Malcolm is definitely dead. When asked if Booth was still alive, both actresses said that it was possible. I cannot see Beth going off by herself to look for Madison, unless Madison lured her into the tunnel herself. A lot of these "exit interviews" are coached, just like on Survivor. On Survivor: Pearl Islands, Trish denied knowing anything about a twist that allowed returnees to come back and it happened the next episode. While I think Henry is the killer, I still think that Booth being alive is a plausible theory. Others don't. Fine. The fact that she says it was possible to me means the producers are reading the various boards, especially HG, and are playing along. It's pretty remarkable that the killer hasn't been spoiled yet.
Coachocd		#3695	[-]
Posts: 7721 (06/16/09 11:53 AM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Gregoire wrote: Do you know how much force you would have to have to drive a pear of garden shears through a piece of furniture and deep into a human body? From that angle, it would be near impossible. That's even more of any argument why the chair was booby trapped before hand. From that angle the force necessary would have knocked her out of the chair. Either Katherine was killed by sitting in the chair or she was drugged/drunk and placed there by the killer. The chair could have been booby trapped at any time and the killer was waiting for the ideal opportunity to use it.
Tiki Lou		#3696	[-]
Posts: 500 (06/16/09 12:09 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Coachocd wrote: Gregoire wrote: Do you know how much force you would have to have to drive a pear of garden shears through a piece of furniture and deep into a human body? From that angle, it would be near impossible. That's even more of any argument why the chair was booby trapped before hand. From that angle the force necessary would have knocked her out of the chair. Either Katherine was killed by sitting in the chair or she was drugged/drunk and placed there by the killer. The chair could have been booby trapped at any time and the killer was waiting for the ideal opportunity to use it. The chair may have been pushed against the wall with the shears already sticking out when the killer could have pushed Katherine into it, explaining the awkward sitting position. And add me to the camp that it's unlikely that Beth just wandered off without telling anyone. And the reason she doesn't scream is the old tried and true method of capturing someone... chloroform. Even Wonder Woman falls for that Last Edited By: Tiki Lou 06/16/09 12:14 PM. Edited 1 times.
Tiki Lou		#3697	[-]
Posts: 501 (06/16/09 12:46 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	something else to consider... on the way over to the isalnd, Chloe was talking about Wakefield with Lucy and Beth. She said he "chopped, hung and burned" anyone that got in his way... well, 2 out of 3 so far chopped - Beth hung - Chloe? burned - Lucy
pjadedd		#3698	[-]
Posts: 9651 (06/16/09 12:50 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Eh, Kelly was already hung. I know technically Uncle Marty and Beth were killed in the same way, but I don't see many repeat killings going on.
Tiki Lou		#3699	[-]
Posts: 502 (06/16/09 12:51 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	pjadedd wrote: Eh, Kelly was already hung. I know technically Uncle Marty and Beth were killed in the same way, but I don't see many repeat killings going on. I'm talking about amongst those three
pjadedd		#3700	[-]
Posts: 9652 (06/16/09 1:02 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Tiki Lou wrote: pjadedd wrote: Eh, Kelly was already hung. I know technically Uncle Marty and Beth were killed in the same way, but I don't see many repeat killings going on. I'm talking about amongst those three Yeah, I know. I'm saying that I don't know if they'd hang anyone else since Kelly was already killed that way (even though both Marty and Beth were chopped in half).

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

Quick Reply