Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
AlwaysAwesomeAdam		#2681	[-]
Posts: 2952 (06/05/09 12:38 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: Basically the scene is like. Shea - We have to find Madison. Henry (puts knife in pocket) - Yes. . . .good idea. Sully - I say fuck that biiiiiiiiitttttttttttttcch! Beth - yeah. Trish - She's my niece I have to find her. Henry - Shea, Trish, Cal, Chloe, Sully, Danny, Mrs Wellington, Nikki, Jimmy, and Maggie. . .you guys check the motel. . . .Beth you check the woodshed out back. . . alone Beth - What's the name of this episode again? Henry - I'll inspect the woods. . . .everyone got it? Trish - Yeah. Beth - I'd rather---- Henry - Kay. . .break! (everyone leaves Beth alone) Beth - Fuck this shit. I'm swimming home.
GoHomeAndEatYoRice		#2682	[-]
Posts: 787 (06/05/09 12:45 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: Basically the scene is like. Shea - We have to find Madison. Henry (puts knife in pocket) - Yes. . . .good idea. Sully - I say fuck that biiiiiiiiitttttttttttttcch! Beth - yeah. Trish - She's my niece I have to find her. Henry - Shea, Trish, Cal, Chloe, Sully, Danny, Mrs Wellington, Nikki, Jimmy, and Maggie. . .you guys check the motel. . . .Beth you check the woodshed out back. . . alone Beth - What's the name of this episode again? Henry - I'll inspect the woods. . . .everyone got it? Trish - Yeah. Beth - I'd rather---- Henry - Kay. . .break! (everyone leaves Beth alone) Beth - Fuck this shit. I'm swimming home. Ok, Thanks AAA. <3
mundo446		#2683	[-]
Posts: 1364 (06/05/09 1:25 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	That was by far the best episode yet. Spoiler [+] Shit, I really have no idea who it could be. I was thinking Jimmy, but then I relaized theres no way he could have killed Cole and then show up with Abby five seconds later. Unless the editors completley disregard placing during the killings, or if Abby and Jimmy are working to together, then it can't be him. Unless they are making it painfully obvious considering the end of the episode, it can't be Henry. For anyone thinking its a superpowered Madison, it was confirmed in an interview a while ago that she would die off camera to prevent controversy. I'm really starting to think its either Abby with multiple personality disorder like a lot of us thought after episode 1, or some random ass charcter. I guess Henry could be revealed as the killer next episode, but that would really suck. Two other things. First, where the fuck did Shane go once Jimmy and Abby let him out of jail? I figured he would have stayed with them, unless they really are working together and just killed him. And second, I think Danny survives for a while or might even survive the whole thing. He is one of the only people constantly portrayed in a positive light. He did a bunch of good things this episode, most importantly being the only non-Wellington, asides from Henry, Abby, and the islanders, to not try and escape.
GoHomeAndEatYoRice		#2684	[-]
Posts: 788 (06/05/09 1:35 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	mundo446 wrote: That was by far the best episode yet. Spoiler [+] Shit, I really have no idea who it could be. I was thinking Jimmy, but then I relaized theres no way he could have killed Cole and then show up with Abby five seconds later. Unless the editors completley disregard placing during the killings, or if Abby and Jimmy are working to together, then it can't be him. Unless they are making it painfully obvious considering the end of the episode, it can't be Henry. For anyone thinking its a superpowered Madison, it was confirmed in an interview a while ago that she would die off camera to prevent controversy. I'm really starting to think its either Abby with multiple personality disorder like a lot of us thought after episode 1, or some random ass charcter. I guess Henry could be revealed as the killer next episode, but that would really suck. Two other things. First, where the fuck did Shane go once Jimmy and Abby let him out of jail? I figured he would have stayed with them, unless they really are working together and just killed him. And second, I think Danny survives for a while or might even survive the whole thing. He is one of the only people constantly portrayed in a positive light. He did a bunch of good things this episode, most importantly being the only non-Wellington, asides from Henry, Abby, and the islanders, to not try and escape. Spoiler [+] X to the Danny being the positive light in this depressing show. And, Did anyone notice that Maggie suddenly leaves while Mrs. W, Shea, and Trish were in the kitchen, and Beth<3, Sully, Cal, and Chloe are leaving. And I think Nikki or Maggie are the killer for having no alibi. But, Maggie makes more sense to me.
Kenneth		#2685	[-]
Posts: 1928 (06/05/09 2:58 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	GoHomeAndEatYoRice wrote: Spoiler [+] X to the Danny being the positive light in this depressing show. And, Did anyone notice that Maggie suddenly leaves while Mrs. W, Shea, and Trish were in the kitchen, and Beth<3, Sully, Cal, and Chloe are leaving. Spoiler [+] Yeah that's what I was saying before. She's one of the only ones left who has had the opportunity to do all the killings. She knows the island probably better than anyone left and her whole character as the wedding planner is about her ability to keep a good schedule. It would also fit with her making sure the priest left for at a specific time so she would have the opportunity to kill him, and the weird shaped M's from the note that matched the M's on the wedding rehearsal layout. (right? or am I misremembering?) It's Maggie. It's gotta be. Maybe she Wakefield's jilted lover and she's getting revenge on Abby for her mother taking Wakefield away?
kennethp21		#2686	[-]
Posts: 4137 (06/05/09 7:20 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I think the killer is Gigi, Madison's secret friend
tullfan2		#2687	[-]
Posts: 3465 (06/05/09 7:52 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] I don't have any reason to rule out Danny as the killer. We don't know much about him.
The Purple Parrot		#2688	[-]
Posts: 10432 (06/05/09 8:14 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] I still suspect Cal. He's the first one that wanted to stay and look for Madison among the wedding guests, THEN he was the one that made everybody stay when they were gonna leave on the motorboat. He disappears a lot, too. It wouldn't surprise me if he was like... the son of Wakefield or something... Maybe Wakefield and Abby's mom's lovechild (instead of Abby being Wakefield's daughter). It also wouldn't surprise me if Cal is faking the accent. Overall though, it did seem like the killer was alllllllllll over the island this episode. He was at the sheriff's station and killed the deputy, then he cut the phones, then he cut the power at the Candlewick, then he was at Cole's cabin and killed Cole, then he was at the docks and killed JD. Suspect list: 1. Henry 2. Jimmy 3. Cal I think this episode counts the sheriff out as far as suspects go... and I definitely think the original Wakefield is dead. I'm not ruling out the possibility of a "non-murdering" accomplice, too. I still suspect Katherine (if Henry is the murderer) and Shane (if Jimmy is the murderer). ALSO, I sooooo thought Beth was dying when she went into that freezer! BETH MUST LIVE! <333 I think we all know that she's fodder along with Danny and Sully though... ALSO ALSO, where the hell is Nikki!?!? Why is she even included in the suspect list if she's never gonna be on the show!?!? She either dies or is involved in the murdering (maybe Jimmy's new girlfriend! :O)
Annoying Tool Fanboy		#2689	[-]
Posts: 2111 (06/05/09 8:50 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] If it's Maggie the whole fucking show is pointless and I hope the writing staff dies a slow and painful death for making me waste my time on this shit. Still think it's Henry, though that last scene makes him less likely to be the killer. Still makes more sense than anyone else, though.
JoshCflyring		#2690	[-]
Posts: 661 (06/05/09 9:12 AM) "Jay Leno is funny" Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] I am 100% certain that Henry is the killer. He for some reason wants everyone to stay on the island so thats why he kidnapped Madison so that no one would leave. J.D. didn't want to say Henry is the killer because they are siblings, or maybe his death was an accident. They are bringing up stuff that Henry has done in sneaky ways to remind us and give off hints he is the killer, like when he was with Danny. Henry also looked very little surprised that Richard was dead, he set him up there so he could look pretend and so that he would look less suspicious...Henry is the killer I know it.
Que		#2691	[-]
Posts: 1391 (06/05/09 9:58 AM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	^ I'm with you. Spoiler [+] Henry has set himself up so well that no-one on the Island will suspect him. I bet he is covered in his own blood...JD wounded him and he will say he fought in self defense. He was ADAMENT that everyone stay to search for Madison. He and Danny went to start the generator... he knew it was safe, he knew to jump start it again deflecting the blame, he comes out a hero. Then he went off by himself. He knew to pick up the rope at the lake and follow it... He shows shock and disgust etc... Remember in the begining the skeet shoot with Mr W? Henry lost on purpose, you could tell he was an expert marksman... He was Oh so Happy to get the gun from Sully, nothing like arming the bad guy. Oh and Madison being psychic.... LOL creepy little kid who wants attention yes, psychic killer? no.
Cuauhtemoc Gilmore		#2692	[-]
Posts: 18781 (06/05/09 10:00 AM) OMEDETO, CATHY!! Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Nikki <3
FermatsLastThm		#2693	[-]
Posts: 395 (06/05/09 11:12 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] I'm kind of surprised that the writers are already writing themselves into a corner when it comes to the killer (Henry or some secondary character that we don't give a shit about and will be enraged if it turns out is the killer). There are 25 supposed suspects, 10 or so of which are now dead. Of the remaining suspects, most have been shown to have been completely incapable of being the killer without horrible editing/writing. The sheriff, for instance, was in the cabin when the killer shot Cole, and thus couldn't logistically be the killer. Jimmy was with Abby on the way to the Cabin, and thus, unless she's in on it (a complete copout in writing), he couldn't be the killer. They've killed off the majority of other lead male suspects, and thus the suspicion falls pretty much solely on Henry. Sure, they try little things like a text message from uncle Marty or a phone call from Madison in Henry's presence, but unlike virtually every other character, the killer never kills anyone when he is around and he's always finding excuses to go running off or keeping people on the island. I'm kind of disappointed in it, really.
pushingjate		#2694	[-]
Posts: 3098 (06/05/09 11:47 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	BtvsVamp wrote: http://www.wisevid.com/gateway.php?viewkey=04dbc5274014bf357524 Ep 8! Thank you sooooooooo much.
JoshCflyring		#2695	[-]
Posts: 664 (06/05/09 11:48 AM) "Jay Leno is funny" Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] and Henry is also trying to play innocent so no one will suspect him especially when he's like I have nothing to do with this, my friend Uncle Marty died or whatever. I think there was a reason that he killed him (maybe he knew that he killed Ben). I am 100% sure it is Henry. I don't think Abby, Shea, Nikki, Madison, Trish and The Sheriff have anything to worry about. I think those people are the most safe to live.
Mateui		#2696	[-]
Posts: 2516 (06/05/09 12:34 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] Yeah, Henry's been at the top of my suspect list for weeks now and every episode continues to support my feelings about him. He conveniently discovers murders and acts shocked/surprised/sad, JD was beginning to be onto him so that's why Henry had him killed, etc. The motivation behind him being the killer is not clear to me though. It's obvious he still has a thing for Abby - and like JD said, all these killings are about her, so there must be more to it than just simple infatuation, but I haven't picked up on anything. At this point I'd be very surprised if it isn't Henry (though I do think that he's working with somebody else - potentially Wakefield.)
pushingjate		#2697	[-]
Posts: 3099 (06/05/09 12:44 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Spoiler [+] Definitely sounds like Henry too after this latest episode. I have a feeling they'll rip a page from the "Scream" handbook and have it relate to their parents. Someone was having an affair with Abby's mom, and it caused Henry to become a fucked up person.
SEGScapegoat		#2698	[-]
Posts: 100 (06/05/09 1:06 PM) I don't get most of the jokes Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I'm impressed that you know the characters' names!
Simdog11		#2699	[-]
Posts: 248 (06/05/09 1:06 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	pushingjate wrote: Spoiler [+] Definitely sounds like Henry too after this latest episode. I have a feeling they'll rip a page from the "Scream" handbook and have it relate to their parents. Someone was having an affair with Abby's mom, and it caused Henry to become a fucked up person. Spoiler [+] That's what I'm thinking too. Henry was set up to be a red herring at the end of the episode, only so they can show he's "innocent" next episode and people will not suspect him, and he'll turn out to be the killer (much like how they made Sydney's boyfriend look suspicious in the first Scream...then made him look innocent...ultimately to have him be the killer). According to my estimation, as long as the women/Danny in the kitchen didn't split up....the only people without a solid alibi throughout the series are Henry & Maggie....
UrbanSprawl		#2700	[-]
Posts: 1745 (06/05/09 2:38 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	The Holy Shea Bible Chapter 3: Hunting Disaster Shea and Beth marvel over Trish's wedding dress. Beth picks up the phone and alerts the sisters that Hunter Jennings is trying to reach Trish. "You told me he was leaving," says Shea, stern yet surprised. Beth asks if Trish has informed Henry about Hunter's presence (something Shea told her to do in episode one). Of course Trish hasn't. Beth goads on Trish, in her wedding dress- white cut in half with a sash of red, about Trish's college experiences with Hunter. "What happened in college?" Shea asks. "Well, let's say her mouth said no, but her body said..." Beth continues. Trish apparently has a history of sending mixed messages to men, stringing them along. Shea looks on with surprise and dismay. Hunter is a bad man, treacherous and deeply-covetous, seeking to take another man's wife on the eve of her wedding to satiate his own greedy desires. This is enough reason to kill Hunter immediately. But Shea keeps him alive (for the time being) because he serves as an obvious moral test to her sister's, Trish, fidelity. Hunter also becomes a foil of Shea's father's deceitfulness and open desire to undermine his daughter's wedding over a matter of pride. Hunter confronts Mr. Wellington, upset that the "deal" to take Trish away has been "taken off the table," Hunter presents a "new deal": he'll take 50,000 dollars in return of not informing Trish of her father's deceit. Meanwhile, Trish is given one last Hunter test- a "let's make this work" card supposedly from Hunter. Seeing her engagement ring, Trish decides to ignore Hunter's entreaties altogether, passing the moral test and saving her skin for the time being. Hunter isn't so lucky. By successfully taking fifty grand from Trish's father for the promise of never seeing her again, Hunter exposes how shallow his love for Trish is and how deep his love for money remains. Hunter's death is a poetic judgment of his life. His decision to leave with the money has set off a deathly course meant to encapsulate his own misdeeds. Shea has stashed a bag of money and a gun on Hunter's 'get-away' boat. Openning the bag, Hunter is delighted by money, ignoring the gun, ignoring all the violence his greed has on the lives of others. But in his avaricious bliss, the boat sputters to a stop. Hunter wanders to the back, seeking the engine. He finds instead a larger manifestation of that gun which shoots his head off. Hunter's greed has shot him in the face, an immoral act which returns with a vegence to hold the perpetrator and exact its judgment. Last Edited By: UrbanSprawl 06/05/09 2:41 PM. Edited 2 times.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

Quick Reply