Yuku free message boards

AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote:

---

My top 5 guesses for the killer are

1.) Trish - She might be a little insane in the membrane. Everyone that was taken out has been closer to the bride than the groom with the exception of Uncle Marty and now Malcom. In the book And Then There Were None, the killer was taking out people who's crimes were less offensive so the more vicious of criminals didn't have to suffer through the torment of knowing they'd go soon. Perhaps Trish is taking people out that's she's close too so they don't have to go through the torment later on. She only has Beth and Shea left on her side.

2.) Sully - I have this strange feeling that Sully is going to pull a Rebecca Gayhardt via Urban Legends and be related to Wakefield or possibly his son and is getting revenge by killing people, tormenting Abby, making the Sheriff look stupid, and etc. Kelly kept commenting on seeing Wakefield. . maybe Sully reminded her of a younger Wakefield. The early deaths were people he knew he could get away with (Uncle Marty, Lucy, and Kelly) and that nobody would question them missing. He's now building his way up. I know we saw him in the woods at the time of Lucy's death but we're not sure of the timeframe. He could have released Cal. . .walked through the woods to Lucy's pit and lit the G.oddess on fire.

3.) Shea - Refer to Trish's reasoning only she's snapped b/c of the affair that Richard is/was having and being the neglected one. Trish's profile points out she's Daddy's little girl. Trish is also getting a husband that loves and cares for her. Something Shea doesn't have. Maybe she's killing out of jealousy and its released a different side of her.

4.) Cal - Always suspect the random who the hell is that guy in horror movies. If the cast doesn't know them except the slutty girl and deaths begin to happen than all outcomes usually point to him. Maybe Cal is a copycat killer a fan of Wakefields, maybe a son, or maybe he's just a crazy SOB. Chloe is into the psychos and he did try to drown her.

5.) Henry - It was between him and Abby for the last spot. Abby seems to be to much of the main character to be her so it went to Henry. Henry might have had something to do with Wakefield this entire time which I find unlikely but its a better theory than what I have on Abby.

BillGuido wrote:

---

I think the killer is Abby for several reasons. And I think she was the original murderer 7 years ago and Wakefield is a cover-up by the "father." Abby is, of course, insane.

First, the "father" has news reports after the massacre 7 years ago that tracks murders all down the west coast. Notice who was sent off to the west coast after the murders? Abby. She is still killing. The "father" is keeping tabs on his daughter's murders. He also sent her away from the island because he knew she was the murderess and still wanted to protect her, but also needed to protect the people on the island. He framed Wakefield (shot him) and declared him the murderer to the public. He then hastily buried him.

Second, in the scene where Abby is in her house and notices the doors are unlocked, etc. and calls out for her mother, she turns away at one point and then you hear the scream of her mother. This is when Abby runs up and kills her own mother. There was no reason for the mother to be screaming from inside her own house - she would have been outside the house at that point at the hands of Wakefield.

Third, the scene with Jimmy in the truck and her crouching in the bushes was just odd. As if it were a retelling of the event in the mind of an insane person (Abby). Perhaps Abby herself was the one dragging the body and Jimmy saw this and is covering up for her? This one is a bit of a stretch, but not unlikely.

Fourth, this would explain the close nature of Jimmy and the Dad. Before, they hated each other. Now, they both are trying to protect Abby the crazy murderess - one because she is his flesh and blood and the other because he loves her.