Yuku free message boards

1. Bo (I liked him and Carrie equally, didn't care which one won. But his first CD got Clive'd and is a disappointment)
2. Katherine (hottest woman EVER on Idol. Over The Rainbow is my favorite Idol performance ever. Her CD, not so much)
3. Adam (great voice, annoying personality, inconsistent performances. I didn't care if he or Kris won. Could move up or down in the standings based on his post Idol career, or lack therof)
4. Diana (like most people on idol, she is a vastly better singer than Mantasia. Her CD is underrated too)
5. Clay (like Reuben he was great during his season but drops a few slots because his CDs are so consistently bad)
6. Justin (meh. We wouldn't be here if he won)
7. Archie (good in the semis and at the end, but also has longest streak in Idol history without a good performance, from top 12 night right through top 4: that's 9 weeks and 11 songs)
7. Blake (good stage presence, but has one of the worst voices of anybody to make the top 4. And spitting into the mike does NOT translate well to CD)