Yuku free message boards

I'd say she's M, just because while the editors may have intended a P, she's a very N person.

I think you're missing the point of the edit. Was Sugar really an OTTP person during the game? No, she was a vile whiny bitch princess bitch. Edgic is supposed to look at what the editors intend for an edit, hence why we look for which character is "crafted" a certain way in order to figure out the winner. I hate to de-humanize the show, but it goes for all of television and reality tv: you're looking at characters, not who they are 24/7 in real life.

Yes, Sierra was miserable and didn't shut up when she was supposed to and wasn't the smartest cookie ever when it comes to strategy, but the editors crafter her to be an underdog that would stand up for her morals and self. And I think she did exactly that.

They didn't have to make her look like an idiot, but they did so to ease the fact that she was going home the very next episode.

See, I don't see a point in arguing with you, because I think we see her edit fundamentally different. In my opinion, she wasn't shown as an idiot, that was just what she was out there. There's a difference. She was shown sour about her position and willing to fight for her life. The viewers ate up the raw emotion she showed during her conversation with Coach and his response to her. The following episode was no different when she sought to expose Coach.

This is probably the hardest part of "Edgic", because there are no guidelines on how to decide overall ratings. I'd go by how the editors want the viewers to feel on a final impression basis. And if I were to guess how viewers felt about Sierra at 11PM on that Sunday night, they'd give her CPP. If only al viewers submitted Edgic ratings! ^_^'