Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
dennydoylelives		#1861	[-]
Posts: 2865 (05/15/09 8:39 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Why would he kill his own wedding guests, or his bride-to-be's father? Psycho Killer What kinda wedding would that be? Quest que cest
pjadedd		#1862	[-]
Posts: 9383 (05/15/09 9:16 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	If the bride or groom is a psychotic killer, is it bad form to then keep the wedding gifts?
MaxMouse10		#1863	[-]
Posts: 891 (05/15/09 9:58 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I mean, it's just speculation, but if the writer of this show was going in the direction of Henry being the killer...it works out perfectly so far. He hates the ex-boyfriend, kills him early on...and gets to relish in the death of Mr. Wellington because he is right there at the scene. I'm sticking with that for now, or the sheriff. But I think it's Henry mostly because of the foreshadowing of Mr. Wellington. It will play out...that trust issue.
NiceToAnimals		#1864	[-]
Posts: 11934 (05/15/09 10:07 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Henry could have rigged up the chandelier head splitty-open thing, but Maggie was the one to dictate when the lights were turned on. They could have been turned on at any point in the ceremony or prior, but they just happened to be turned on when Mr. Wellington was under it. So either it's bad writing, or the chandelier head splitty-open thing was meant for anyone there and not Mr. Wellington specifically, or Maggie had something to do with it.
dennydoylelives		#1865	[-]
Posts: 2866 (05/15/09 10:19 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	A Henry & Maggie Bonnie & Clyde instead of Chloe & Cal? That would be an interesting twist. Abby as misdirection for Henry leaving Trish, when he wanted Maggie all along.
AlwaysAwesomeAdam		#1866	[-]
Posts: 2762 (05/15/09 10:22 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I still think its Trish. She's PMSing over the stress of the wedding, pissed at the bad Bachelorette party, and angry that Henry wanted to have their wedding bash on the very island multiple people were killed and then she has Abby walking around reminding everyone. She's killing everyone close to her i.e. (Cousin Ben, Lucy, her father, I'm sure she killed her mom).
colleenlover		#1867	[-]
Posts: 9291 (05/15/09 10:34 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I'd rather it be Trish too. It's Henry. The practicalities of Mr. Wellington being under the blade when the lights were turned off won't be addressed ever. we're not supposed to ask that -"hey, what if no one turned off the lights or stood under the chandelier?" And don't think that skeet shooting scene isn't going to come back into play near the final act. You know the one that Henry missed -on purpose that is.
NiceToAnimals		#1868	[-]
Posts: 11935 (05/15/09 10:38 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	"I should probably think about moving to the si..."
Simdog11		#1869	[-]
Posts: 229 (05/15/09 11:03 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	colleenlover wrote: I'd rather it be Trish too. It's Henry. The practicalities of Mr. Wellington being under the blade when the lights were turned off won't be addressed ever. we're not supposed to ask that -"hey, what if no one turned off the lights or stood under the chandelier?" And don't think that skeet shooting scene isn't going to come back into play near the final act. You know the one that Henry missed -on purpose that is. As will Mr. Wellington's warning of not trusting henry, the close up of Henry gutting the fish, and JD's comment that Henry "tries so hard to be liked". Also: regarding the positioning of the chandelier. For all we know, Maggie had an exact time to hit the light switch, and perhaps had it documented in her notes. Who spent the day with her and would have access to this? HENRY! Last Edited By: Simdog11 05/15/09 11:27 AM. Edited 1 times.
April R		#1870	[-]
Posts: 7303 (05/15/09 11:17 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I just caught up on this show last night... very interesting . I can't believe they killed the dad!!
Understandermant		#1871	[-]
Posts: 42 (05/15/09 11:42 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	AlwaysAwesomeAdam wrote: I still think its Trish. She's PMSing over the stress of the wedding, pissed at the bad Bachelorette party, and angry that Henry wanted to have their wedding bash on the very island multiple people were killed and then she has Abby walking around reminding everyone. She's killing everyone close to her i.e. (Cousin Ben, Lucy, her father, I'm sure she killed her mom). Youre kidding right? Why would she kill her parents?
NiceToAnimals		#1872	[-]
Posts: 11936 (05/15/09 11:46 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	"I always wondered how I'd look with a middle part."
dennydoylelives		#1873	[-]
Posts: 2867 (05/15/09 12:16 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Understandermant wrote: Youre kidding right? Why would she kill her parents? Her Dad did bring Hunter to ruin her wedding.
The Annoying Hater		#1874	[-]
Posts: 1515 (05/15/09 1:01 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I'm still rolling with Cal and/or Chloe as my main suspects. I think one of them is Madison's "new friend".
colleenlover		#1875	[-]
Posts: 9295 (05/15/09 1:44 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I think they are her "new friend." But new friend is a red herring to being the killer. Unrelated.
Simdog11		#1876	[-]
Posts: 230 (05/15/09 2:09 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	colleenlover wrote: I think they are her "new friend." But new friend is a red herring to being the killer. Unrelated. While I agree with your theory on Henry being the killer colleenlover, why do you think Madison said that she wouldn't get to be a flower girl, because her friend told her? You really think Cal told her that??
GameShowMyAss		#1877	[-]
Posts: 4487 (05/15/09 2:45 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I thought the whole 'looking for the missing priest' scene defo meant that Henry wasn't the killer, but that would have been a perfect opportunity for him to rig the choppy device to the light switch. Now I think it's him again. IT'S SO TOTALLY HIM I wonder if ratings will go up once widespread panic hits Boringsofar's Island. They were retarded not to save this show for the summer.
colleenlover		#1878	[-]
Posts: 9296 (05/15/09 2:49 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Simdog11 wrote: colleenlover wrote: I think they are her "new friend." But new friend is a red herring to being the killer. Unrelated. While I agree with your theory on Henry being the killer colleenlover, why do you think Madison said that she wouldn't get to be a flower girl, because her friend told her? You really think Cal told her that?? I don't know. But I can see the Madison friend thing being a fake-out. Maybe Cal and Chloe or whoever has ulterior motives, and it just coincidentally crosses paths with the killing. I think the "friend" is some sort of red herring.
Simdog11		#1879	[-]
Posts: 231 (05/15/09 3:05 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	GameShowMyAss wrote: I thought the whole 'looking for the missing priest' scene defo meant that Henry wasn't the killer, but that would have been a perfect opportunity for him to rig the choppy device to the light switch. Now I think it's him again. IT'S SO TOTALLY HIM I wonder if ratings will go up once widespread panic hits Boringsofar's Island. They were retarded not to save this show for the summer. Agreed. They were retarded to not wait til summer. Why start a series and then interrupt it after 5 episodes? Poor planning. Also, why wait to make it GOOD til episode 5 and beyond? Did anybody actually LISTEN to the writing on episode 1? They could've hooked more people if they had actually put more effort into episode 1, no? colleenlover wrote: I don't know. But I can see the Madison friend thing being a fake-out. Maybe Cal and Chloe or whoever has ulterior motives, and it just coincidentally crosses paths with the killing. I think the "friend" is some sort of red herring. STuff like this and the calling for the priest thing give me a slight hope that it's not the obvious answer of Henry. And would mean that it was Beth, Maggie, Jimmy, or a not-really-dead Booth. Probably not....but hey....I enjoyed the ending of Scream 2 way better than Scream 1!! Last Edited By: Simdog11 05/15/09 3:10 PM. Edited 2 times.
Crowlass		#1880	[-]
Posts: 3274 (05/15/09 3:36 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Also: regarding the positioning of the chandelier. For all we know, Maggie had an exact time to hit the light switch, and perhaps had it documented in her notes. Who spent the day with her and would have access to this? HENRY! Yea the whole wedding ceremony was following a plan, which they all seemed somewhat familiar with. I know in my sister's wedding, the wedding planner had gone over all the details of the wedding ceremony with the bride and groom well before the actual rehearsal. (Such as where everyone stands, what is happening in the ceremony, who does what readings, etc.) If you rewatch, the plan was to turn off the lights at the exact moment when Mr. Wellington was up there (right before he lit the candle.) They weren't just randomly hitting a light switch whenever.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Harper's Island--Decent Summer Slasher

Quick Reply