| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 charcas |
|||
|
Posts: 1259 (03/31/09 7:48 PM) Registered User |
Terrible night, this is hard:
1. Adam 2. Kris 3. Allison 4. Anoop 5. Danny 6. Lil 7. Matt 8. Scott 9. Megan Btm 3: Megan, Scott, Matt with Matt going home |
||
|
OhioJohnFan |
|||
|
Posts: 444 (03/31/09 7:48 PM) |
1. Kris- Not my overall favorite Idol, but I will give him props for a great performance
2. Adam- Puts everyone else to shame 3. Allison - Not her best, but still good enough 4. Matt- Ok, I liked it. Thought the judges were too harsh 5. Anoop- Didn't love it, didn't hate it. Like Matt, I also thought the critiques were a bit harsh 6. Danny- I like the tone of his voice, but had some rough patches he should have been called out for 7. Lil- I mean, WTF is up with her song choices?! 8. Megan- Hate her voice, but like her 
9. Scott- He could have been big in the 70s |
||
|
8trackmind |
|||
|
Posts: 1198 (03/31/09 7:54 PM) I demand attention! |
I disagree with the negative comments. I thought it was a pretty good night overall. But my computer is having a bad night and won't space this properly.
Sorry.
1. Kris - second really good performance. He is the dark horse this season. 2. Allison Flintstone - not as good as I hoped, but still a standout. 3. Scott - his first good performance. 4. Adam - back on track after his horrible country night and so-so Smokey. 5. Lil - she's got the volume and holds notes well, but her voice is just too thin to be great. She has gone from copying Jennifer's look to copying Tamyra's. 6. Anoop - not great, not bad. In trouble this week, with the judges dissing him and in the suicide spot besides. 7. Danny - his first okay performance since the semis. (GAP) 8. Matt - trying (and failing) to be Chris Daughtry. His voice is so weak that he has to shove the mike into his mouth to be heard. (BIGGER GAP) 9. Megan - channeling Caaaarmen? Each week she finds new ways to be terrible. B3- Megan; B2- Anoop; Gone- Matt |
||
|
Lotion In Basket |
|||
|
Posts: 17 (03/31/09 7:59 PM) |
1. Kris- hopefully this kid can take down Gokey and Adam. he's been flawless every week.
2. Allison- wow judges totally gave her the shaft 3. Lil- not a fan at all but she did really well. shes got a very large ass tho. 4. Scott- I wanted to hate it but didn't. his best so far 5. Adam- back to screaming, ugh. Not a bad vocal but I was expecting more after last week 6. Matt- started off rough but ended ok, meh 7. Anoop- pretty good vocals but I was BORED out of my mind 8. Danny- are you kidding me? the first half of that song was completely off. Second half he shouted. 9. Megan- ugh I hope she goes home, just so I don't have to hear them shoutout Adele/Duffy/Winehouse anymore. B3: Allison B2: Anoop Out: Megan |
||
|
TheEasyOne |
|||
|
Posts: 1473 (03/31/09 7:59 PM) Registered user |
1. Adam
2. Allison 3. Megan <3 underrated 4. Kris 5. Scott 6. Gokey 7. Matt G 8. Anoop 9. smug bitch LIL B: Allison, Megan, Matt H: Lil, Anoop, Scott G: Lil, Megan, Matt |
||
 fffingybyach |
|||
|
Posts: 828 (03/31/09 8:09 PM) |
1. Allison
2. The Chosen One 3. Kris 4. Bird Flu *hubby's favorite, I do not know why 5. KD Lang aka Chosen One part 2 The rest sucked so very much assness that I can not rank them.... should go: Matt, Anoop, Blind folds will go: Anoop, Megan, Allison |
||
|
BarbH918 |
|||
|
Posts: 1082 (03/31/09 8:11 PM) Registered user |
1. Kris - I'd buy it
2. Adam - I wouldn't buy it 3. Alison - My kids would buy it 4. Danny - My mom would buy it 5. Lil - I'd listen to it 6. Megan - I'd watch her 7. Matt - I'd buy the original 8. Anoop - I've heard it 9. Scott - I bought it in the 80's... Brain: Scott/Anoop/Megan - Scott Heart: Scott - just Scott, please Gut: Matt |
||
|
mtj1282 |
|||
|
Posts: 2776 (03/31/09 8:21 PM) |
1.Kris
Brain: Megan/Scott/Matt
|
||
|
Charming Nemesis |
|||
|
Posts: 3793 (03/31/09 8:23 PM) |
1. Kris - Boring, but the most talented
2. Danny - Don't like him, but he can sing 3. Lil - Not bad, not great 4. Megan - Boring, awkward, but still better then the following 5. Scott - Don't go singing, to try and please me 6. Matt - Was off through the whole song 7. Anoop - poop 8. Alison - Don't sing, that just what I am thinking 9. Adam - Sam Harris, but without the subtlety B: Scott H: Adam G: Matt |
||
|
Houster |
|||
|
Posts: 397 (03/31/09 8:28 PM) Registered User |
1. Glamberace
2. Krispy Kreme 3. Deadwife Ghostkey 4. Allison irocHeta 5. Mehtt 6. Noop Dogg 7. Shrill 8. The Greatest American Idol 9. The Birdwoman of Idoltraz Brain: Lil, Scott, Megan Heart: Anoop, Lil, Megan Gut: Allison, Anoop, Megan Boot: Birdwoman |
||
|
Taniwha Is Waiting |
|||
|
Posts: 2538 (03/31/09 8:28 PM) Registered User |
1. Kris - confident and effortless
2. Adam - first time out of first place, but still a rollicking good time 3. Allison - liked the first part of the song better, it was more vulnerable and emotional (Dream Final Three) Huge gap 4. Matt - seemed forced and rushed. I still like his voice, though, and I hope he makes it through to another week 5. Goeky - ugh, this pains me greatly, but he wasn't half bad 6. Anoop - I don't know the song, that didn't help. He needs to stand out, fast 7. Lil - um, don't know why I don't like her, but I don't 8. Scott - I hate the tone of his voice, but it was better than any other songs he's done. Not saying much there. 9. Megan - she's in waaay over her head, and her chirping about "her fans" is getting super annoying |
||
|
Skwert78 |
|||
|
Posts: 387 (03/31/09 8:54 PM) |
1. Kris - Brilliant like Adam only better.
2. Adam - Brilliant. I hate that song, and he made me like it. 3. Danny - Good choice, good vocals. I don't think it was as original as the judges thought, but good 4. Alison - Girl can blow...I had to hate the hair & costume though too...haven't liked her candy apple hair from the start. 5. Matt - Has been my favorite from day one, and this is my favorite song, but just didn't wow me. 6. Scott - Better than usual, but still just the same old, same old. 7. Anoop - he's no Usher 8. Lil - most overrated singer in quite a few seaons 9. Megan - I was pulling for her to turn it around, but she absolutely didn't.
Last Edited By: Skwert78
03/31/09 8:57 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
||
|
Ann Margret Thatcher |
|||
|
Posts: 7377 (03/31/09 9:04 PM) Registered user |
Charming Nemesis wrote:  One of the better Adam descriptions I've seen.
I can't summon up the nerve to rank them tonight. It was just that bad overall. I can see anyone outside of Danny, Kris, or Adam in the bottom three. B: Megan/Anoop/Matt H: Lil/Matt/Anoop G: Matt/Megan/Scott, with Matt going, although I think this week is really hard to call. |
||
|
kathyk1024 |
|||
|
Posts: 26 (03/31/09 9:17 PM) |
1. Kris
2. Lil 3. Alison 4. Danny 5. Adam 6. Scott 7. Anoop 8. Matt 9. Megan |
||
|
BobbyBrown06 |
|||
|
Posts: 11164 (03/31/09 9:44 PM) Registered user |
1. Kris
2. Lil 3. Alison 4. Matt 5. Danny 6. Scott 7. Adam 8. Anoop 9. Megan |
||
|
Us Kids Know |
|||
|
Posts: 10166 (03/31/09 9:54 PM) Registered user
|
1. Kris
2. Megan 3. Allison 4. Adam 5. Anoop 6. Lil 7. Gokey 8. Matt 9. Scott |
||
|
nes5 |
|||
|
Posts: 26 (03/31/09 10:12 PM) |
1. allison
2. kris 3. matt 4. adam 5. danny 6. anoop 7. megan 8. lil 9. scott b: scott h: scott g: allison |
||
|
Wills4everEH |
|||
|
Posts: 478 (03/31/09 10:15 PM) Registered User |
1. Kris ...by far the best of the night.
2. Allison (better be top 2) 3. Danny ( I do not get the hate) 4. Adam (they just pimp him to the end...like this is a surprise Oh..and he's thanking the band for brownie points! 5. Megan (because I want her to break the barrier..I know she can do better) 6. Matt (regardless..he's good) 7. Anoop (hated it) 8. Lil' Dion (don't ever sing Celine and I could see your underwear...pity points for crying) 9. GET HIM OFF THE STAGE SCOTT..omg, it's painful. B: Scott H: Scott G: Megan :*(
Last Edited By: Wills4everEH
03/31/09 10:23 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
||
|
AlexDSSF |
|||
|
Posts: 810 (03/31/09 10:32 PM) Registered User |
01) Adam Lambert (bitch killed it)
02) Kris Allen (pretty good, but not Earth-shatteringly good... still, his best so far) 03) Allison Iraheta (I actually LIKED what she was wearing) 04) Scott MacIntyre (good job, but it reminded me of the first season's semifinals, when it was just a piano and a pianist and a singer... ah, the good old days) 05) Anoop Desai (not his best, but not his worst) 06) Matt Giraud (I hate the fucking Fray, and Matt was way out of his depth) 07) Lil Rounds (Kelly Clarkson sang it so much better; Lil has had too many chances and has blown too many chances) 08) Megan Joy (I always thought that she had a reggae twang in her singing voice, but that was terrible) 09) Danny Gokey (boring as shit) Brain: Matt, Lil, and Megan Heart: Lil, Danny, and Megan Gut: Matt, Lil, and Megan Should and Will Go: Megan |
||
|
pemmiekim |
|||
|
Posts: 565 (03/31/09 10:58 PM) |
Awesome:
|
||
