| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
OXY |
|||
|
Kathy is really overrated and needs to be gone. She got outwitted by Rob, Amber, and Vecepia in her time and basically just lucked into a good spot in
Marquesas.
|
|||
craig |
|||
Also, why were so many people complaining about Crystal making it so high when CI Parvati and Sandra were still in?Sandra is the much better version of Crystal, who despite being a bitch and sucking in challenges, actually WON. But even if Crystal won Gabon, she still would be a crappier winner than Sandra. Crystal = Candace S18 with more luck. Like Alicia in ASS, a bitch who was first out of her own alliance. Horrible social player, Horrible at challenges. Benefitted from TWO switches. Rode Kenny's coattail's strategically. Arguably the WORST player in the Gabon F10. Yes, even Mattyboy managed to flip Sugar against her. |
|||
Thailandsurvivor |
|||
|
How about an answer from someone whose not as delusional or irrational as craig.
|
|||
SwineForkbeard |
|||
|
I'm not sure if I watched all of Pearl Islands or not at the time, but one thing I remember that nobody ever brings up that I feel disqualifies Sandra from
the top echelon of winners is the way she, Rupert, and Christa abused their power when they had an obvious 3 to 2 advantage over Shawn and Fairplay, and tried
to humiliate them for their own amusement. Once they decided which one was going, they should at least have guaranteed the other one a final 4 spot. Telling
them they couldn't decide which one to vote out and making them beg to stay was one of the stupidest and most arrogant things I think anybody's ever
done. After telling Fairplay to his face that he was expendable to them, how did they expect to keep him loyal later on? They richly deserved his betrayal.
|
|||
craig |
|||
|
You know Thai, I gladly admit that several Survivors I rooted against with a passion were great players - Fairplay, Terry, etc. One of the biggest Raro fans in
S13, and by the Finale I was convinced Yul was practically the best ever.
But Crystal fandom is something that's always seemed an ironic Vote for the Worst joke that spun out of control. Like Sucks trying to boost Sekou to the top of the CBS popularity poll, or rooting for Cloris Leichman to win DWTS. At that level the whole Massive Crystal cult is amusing. But some Sucksters actually seem to take it seriously. |
|||
SwineForkbeard |
|||
|
Weren't you predicting that Crystal would win after Corinne was voted out? That wasn't altogether implausible at the time, now that Charlie has said
that his impression was that Crystal was more of an active decision maker than the show made it appear and would have voted for her over Ken or Sugar.
It's also hypocritical to hold Sugar's betrayal against her, because Sugar betrayed everybody at one time or another.
|
|||
kishuu |
|||
|
craig is just jealous that Crystal played a better game that ubermajorjealouscunt Corinne. Crystal had set herself up well for FTC in the Sugar/Kenny/Crystal
scenario especially since Charcus hated Kenny more than her, Bob started to hate Ken/get irritated by him and Sugar was a goat everyone wanted at the end. She
also would've won over Sugar/Susie in the all female F3 scenario once again.
Last Edited By: kishuu
03/26/09 2:10 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
SwineForkbeard |
|||
|
Even Corinne managed to be sporting for once and admit that Crystal's edit was misleading and that she was shy and soft-spoken most of the time. That
means alot coming from her, considering how stingy she was with compliments for anybody who didn't do what she wanted.
|
|||
craig |
|||
|
I thought ANYONE could win against Sugar\Susie because they were perceived as traitors by Kota.
|
|||
kishuu |
|||
craig wrote: More like Matty wanted to flip and Susie went along because she had a F2 Pact with Matty. Plus, they should have expected a swap around that episode (hello? Ep3-5 are usually swap eps anyway). |
|||
SwineForkbeard |
|||
craig wrote:You and the rest of the edgic oracles left Bob for dead and picked either Ken or Crystal to win after they voted out Corinne. Despite this, you've hypocritically bashed them for failing to anticipate that Sugar would betray them, as if that's somehow obvious in hindsight even though you didn't anticipate it either. That's one example of why most of your criticisms appear emotionally driven and every Gabon discussion becomes a desperate search for excuses to bash the people who voted out your favorites. If Kota are supposed to be bad social players because Susie and Sugar flipped on them - well, the same goes for Crystal.Looks like we may have found some common ground here, even if it's a straw man argument. I didn't say Kota were bad social players, I was making the same point you're making now in reverse. |
|||
5urvivor |
|||
|
We're finally at the final 25.
|
|||
dragoondaniel78 |
|||
|
Results:
#25 - Kathy Vavrick-O'Brien Survivor: Marquesas; 3rd place Average: 6.56
#24 - Jenna Morasca *WINNER* Survivor: The Amazon; Winner Average: 6.62
#23 - Danni Boatwright *WINNER* Survivor: Guatemala; Winner Average: 6.64
#22 - Natalie Bolton Survivor: Micronesia; 4th place Average: 6.66
#21 - Jonathan Penner Survivor: Cook Islands; 7th place Average: 6.69 |
|||
Kaizer |
|||
|
Jonathan just missed the top 20. How unfortunate.
|
|||
Balibari |
|||
|
Posts: 64 (03/26/09 5:51 AM) |
dragoondaniel78 wrote: |
||
Micronesia Princess |
|||
|
Jenna out before Rob C?! How does that make sense? Rob C. better be showing up in the next batch. People must still be mad at her for being part of the
pretty girls in the Amazon.
|
|||
JackSparrowBauer |
|||
|
Danni and Natalie out before Amber? |
|||
kishuu |
|||
|
Wait, Jenna/Danni before NATALIE?
But I loved Catalie's number. LMAO 6.66. SHE IS THE DEVIL SPAWN I SAY. Penner being this high is ridiculous. |
|||
Buccaneer |
|||
|
No Penner not making top 20 behind weaker players like Ami, Cesternino, and Chris is ridiculous. Fairplay or Sandra must win this for this list to not be a
joke.
|
|||
ImANewUser |
|||
|
Amber & Ken in the Top 20 =
CI Jonathan beating Danni = No one cracking the 7's yet = |
|||