Remember, when doing the B/H/G tonight, that two are going home tomorrow night.
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
SurvivorLDog93 |
AI8 Top 13: Rate 1-13 and Brain/Heart/Gut |
Lead | |
|
Thread reopens after the show airs on the east coast.
Remember, when doing the B/H/G tonight, that two are going home tomorrow night.
Last Edited By: SurvivorLDog93 03/10/09 8:03 PM.
Edited 1 time.
|
|||
Heliox |
|||
|
Brain: Jorge/Anoop
Heart: Scott/Jasmine Gut: Anoop/Megan |
|||
aspects13 |
|||
|
I just hope Jasmine and Anoop go home and with my track record both of them will be safe.
|
|||
charcas |
|||
|
1. Allison
2. Adam 3. Lil 4. Alexis 5. Kris 6. Matt 7. Jasmine 8. Michael 9. Anoop 10. Gokey 11. Scott 12. Jorge 13. Megan Going Home: Michael and Megan |
|||
Raydawggie |
|||
|
Any two of Kris, Jasmine, and Megan are gone.
|
|||
loveski |
|||
|
Brain: Jorge/Anoop
Heart: Jorge/Matt Gut: Jorge/Anoop I think being boring is a worse crime on this show which is why I hope it's not Anoop. But it will be. |
|||
GrenadeJumper85 |
|||
|
No question, the girls (with the exception of Megan) tonight were infinitely better then the men.
1. Alexis 2. Jasmine 3. Allison 4. Lil 5. Matt G. 6. Danny 7. Michael 8. Anoop 9. Kris 10. Jorge 11. Scott 12. Adam 13. Megan Brain: Megan/Jorge/Jasmine - Boot: Jasmine/Jorge Heart: Megan/Adm/Scott - Boot: Megan/Adam Gut: Jasmine/Jorge/Anoop - Boot: Jasmine/Jorge |
|||
ElisabethNelehHeidiRok |
|||
|
1.alexis
2.allison 3.scott 4.megan 5.matt 6.danny 7.lil 8.michael 9.kris 10.jasmine 11.jorge 12.anoop 13.adam-over the top, i dont know why but i hate him Brain: Jorge/Anoop Heart: Adam/Jasmine Gut: Anoop/Jasmine |
|||
mtj1282 |
|||
|
Brain: Kris/Micheal
Heart:Michael/Jasmine Gut: Kris/Michael |
|||
sadllama |
|||
|
1. Allison - underpimped darkhorse g.odess <3
2. Alexis 3. Adam 4. Kris 5. Jasmine 6. Danny 7. Megan 8. Matt 9. Lil 10. Michael 11. Scott 12. Anoop 13. Jorge B: Matt/Jasmine H: Jorge/Scott G: Jorge/Michael |
|||
I LUV TIJUANA |
|||
|
The judges really need to stop creaming over Adam. I hate him.
|
|||
roachc420 |
|||
|
1. Allison
Last Edited By: roachc420
03/10/09 8:14 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
Jedijake |
|||
|
A little difficult to actually rate these people. If you really look at it, you have Adam and then the rest.
But here's a try: 1. Adam: completely off the hook-possibly the best male performer ever on Idol or one of the best 3 at least <HUGE GAP> 2. Allison: yeah, I put her at #2. For a 16 year old she was amazing. 3. Michael: I actually thought his vocals were better than Danny's tonight. 4. Danny: He's good, don't get me wrong. But he doesn't seem as good as they are making him out to be. Not yet at least. I'm not sure where he would fit on the charts. <Gap> 5. Lil: She struggled tonight but it was decent. 6. Alexis: A little overdone, but somewhat strong. 7. Jasmine: She held her own. That's about it. 8. Kris: It pains me to put him this high. I don't think he or his wife understood what Simon was talking about when he said his wife should have been hidden. They looked like they took it as an insult. Since he didn't get it, he won't last long. He just lost some of his girlie voters. 9. Scott: It hurt to see that he really didn't shine. He didn't screw up but once again he chose a song nobody would know or remember and didn't kick it with the vocals. That is actually going to end up hurting him. 10. Matt: Meh-I was bored with his performance and heard only screaming. I've never been impressed with him. He's not emulating the Mraz style he looks like he should be doing. 11. Megan: I am VERY disappointed. She is NOT holding her own. She looks terribly awkward on stage and the lack of experience is showing in a big way. 12. Jorge: What a mess! I fell asleep. Whiny whiny whiny! 13. Anoop: Oh good heavens! He looked like an awkward cartoon character. Such high hopes and he does this? Gimme a break! B: Megan, Jasmine, Jorge: H: Kris, Jorge, Matt: G: Megan, Jasmine, Anoop: Megan & Jorge leave However, things are going to be odd with the judges being the ones to determine who leaves. |
|||
GoodNeighborgirl |
|||
|
Brain: Jorge and Megan
|
|||
SurvivorLDog93 |
|||
|
1. Adam. Memorable musical theatre, technically excellent.
2. Allison. Love the timbre of her voice 3. Alexis. Stylish, strong. 4. Lil. Not quite at the top tonight. 5. Jasmine. Creditable performance. 6 (pick'em) Scott/Matt, both slightly above mediocre on the piano tonight. 8. Danny. Overdone and shouty/pitchy, but won't be forgotten. 9. Michael. Nice, but probably got lost in the shuffle. 10. Kris. Had better hope his looks get him through. 11. Anoop. Had better hope Jorge sucked bad enough to deflect attention from his crapfest. 12. Megan. She's here for looks only, so why am I surprised that she sucked? 13. Jorge. Dreadful. Brain: Jorge's gone. The other 'out' is a tossup between Kris, Michael, Matt and Anoop. Heart: Megan/Jorge (with Anoop getting saved in another cliffhanger). Gut: Matt/Michael/Jorge |
|||
The Purple Parrot |
|||
|
1. Danny (Ugh, I'm ashamed to admit this)
2. Alexis 3. Lil 4. Jasmine 5. Adam 6. Allison 7. Matt 8. Megan 9. Kris 10. Jorge 11. Scott 12. Anoop 13. Michael Brain: Megan/Anoop + Jorge Heart: Michael/Kris + Scott Gut: Jorge/Megan *sobs* + Jasmine |
|||
fffingybyach |
|||
|
1. Allison ( really distinctive sound and I almost want to go to you tube to re-listen, that is a big deal this year)
|
|||
LostInTheDelta |
|||
|
01. Alexis
02. Kris 03. Jasmine 04. Allison 05. Lil 06. Matt 07. Danny 08. Scott 09. Michael 10. Adam 11. Anoop 12. Megan 13. Jorge B: Megan and Jorge H: Adam and Anoop G: Michael and Jorge Fear: Kris and Allison |
|||
Riff |
|||
|
1. Alexual - I guess I'm a sucker for the pimp spot.
B: Gitard, Corkscrewed
|
|||
Us Kids Know |
|||
|
Brain: Megan/Kris
Heart: Anoop/Jorge Gut: Megan/Jorge |
|||
E Moch |
|||
|
1. Lil
2. Alexis 3. Gokey...as much as it pains me. 4. Kris 5. Jasmine 6. Allison - Meh 7. Megan - I thought it featured her voice, just a random choice. 8. Sarver - I thought he sounded pretty horrific 9. Matt - Snooze 10. Jorge 11. Anoop 12. Scott 13. Adam ... I'm sorry, I hated it. It's all just histrionics and theatre performances. Brain - Scott/Adam Heart - Scott/Adam Gut - Megan/Jorge |
|||