Eugene Schwindlemyer wrote:
StephaME she ruined two seasons. downhill from there.
she only ruined ONE season. let the records show this
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
dontkilloffcharlie |
|||
Eugene Schwindlemyer wrote: she only ruined ONE season. let the records show this |
|||
Quiddity |
|||
|
Giving Rupert $1 million for losing it twice is certainly a contender.
Although with me, I'd probably go with Cook Islands with the insanely overboard amount of twists and horrific cast. That season was truly the first one were I really felt the show was on a permanent decline that it couldn't recover from. |
|||
dettigersnw22 |
|||
|
For me, its not necessarily always defined moments, but trends:
1.) The poorly executed all-stars season 2.) Expansion beyond 16 castaways/2 tribes and dividing the tribes up by age/race/gender/etc. It made sense in the Amazon and Vanuatu when there was a men vs women aspect to the culture, but not with Panama and Cook Islands. 3a.) Focusing 80% of the show on the challenges and tribal councils (really seemed over-the-top noticeable around S12 or S13) and not developing all the castaways and their stories. 3b.) Probst taking over the show by narrating too much and talking through challenges 4.) Recycling locations 5.) Shoving certain characters down our throats (Rupert, Stephenie, Terry, James, and now Coach) 6.) Gimmick castaways like a former-NFL quarterback, Astronaut, Fighter Pilot, WWE Diva, 90's music star, etc.....and made up castaways/cliche castaways like "Model", "Fitness Trainer" and Mechanical Bull Operator 7.) Hidden Immunity Idols and Tribe Switches ruining the game for otherwise well-positioned players, just for the sake of unpredictability......yet editing in such a way that it isnt hard for regular viewers to easily figure out who the major players will be in the game. |
|||
JaniTholeMyDolly |
|||
Quiddity wrote:Yeah that made me fucking mad. And to top it off he spent it all in like 3 days on alligators and shit. |
|||
Mypoody2 |
|||
|
I'm kinda horny
|
|||
JamesM |
|||
Mypoody2 wrote: |
|||
WTFscissoring8 |
|||
dettigersnw22 wrote:i'm excited for survivor season 19 when they divide the tribes up by blood-type... just wait until the tribes reshuffle, when the cast is forced to keep the annoying fat ass who sucks at challenges only because she has type-O blood, and when the other tribe experiences a catastrophe when type-B jisella trips and cuts herself but she stupidly voted out all the type-B and type-O players. |
|||
jumpingbum |
vindication | ||
|
:)
Last Edited By: jumpingbum
03/11/09 12:53 AM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
BortBort |
|||
|
^ Insightful post, well done!
Please note: this post may contain traces of sarcasm... |
|||
gretchensucks |
|||
|
When Scunt flipped Season 9.
|
|||
tomersde |
|||
|
The awfulness of Exile-Island pre-merge.
|
|||
gervasemyman |
|||
|
Posts: 562 (03/11/09 4:35 AM) I'm with STUPID! |
chaos wrote: |
||