| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
 CSCin3D |
|||
|
Posts: 9149 (09/21/08 9:33 PM) Registered user |
Eliza has said that the jury would have given her the win.Eliza also idolized John Edwards. Actually, Brianna was one of the breakout stars of Guatemala. If her team hadn't been a bunch of assholes just because they were looking for excuses and her basketball knowledge was one of them, Brianna would have won Guatemala, guaranteed.<3 Fuck you, Gayfe and Stepheme and all the other meanies involved with her ouster. |
||
|
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
Posts: 5569 (09/21/08 9:52 PM) |
A known supporter of anyone young, white, and with a vagina between her legs, and a known troll, both thinking that a useless third boot was one of the best
players of her season. Wonderful.
|
||
|
SPunKeeMonKee |
|||
|
Posts: 10683 (09/21/08 10:42 PM) Registered User |
Dictatorship wrote:The only way Brianna could've won anything is if every other contestant died on the spot. |
||
|
Knoxville Jackass |
|||
|
Posts: 53 (09/22/08 12:20 AM) Registered user |
Dr Will Hatch two point oh wrote: She was a way better player than Cirie, do you people actually think Parvati was going to let Cirie make it to the end if Parvati wasn't sure she could beat her? Especially after she voted out Ozzy and James for that very reason as she knew she would lose to them. Parvati knew what she was doing and was there to win, there was no way she was going to screw her game over keeping Cirie if she was such a threat. Cirie was carried to the end by Parvati, Cirie was odd man out in the alliance with Parvati & Amanda. Cirie couldn't win a challenge to save herself, this happened twice, in Panama in the fire starting challenge & the final immunity against Amanda in a challenge that was made for Cirie to win. Plain and simple, Amanda wanted the win a little more as she would have most likely been voted out if Cirie had won the final immunity. They were both in danger of going, Amanda fought harder for it. kmill, I don't think it's delusional of me to say Amanda played better than Cirie, Amanda made it to the end twice, Cirie was just short of making it to the end twice. Cirie was a better strategist, but Amanda was a physical threat that still made it to the end twice. Winning crucial immunities is still a part of playing the game. Amanda made it to the end twice, which automatically makes her a better overall player. Shame on Cirie for not realizing that Amanda was a threat in the challenges, if Cirie was so great she would not have fucked up in letting her get that far. Also, her social skills helped her mostly in Panama after Melinda's boot, Joel mentioned going after her after Chet was gone after the tribe switch, but she wasn't really in any real danger of going at that point, other than that she was never in any real danger other than at the end of the game. I find it very odd that with her supposedly great social skills, that at the beginning of the game, both four person alliances seemed to be more concerned in getting Fairplay's vote than Cirie's, who seemed to be the outsider. Once Fairplay quit, all she had to do was pick a side, which Parvati was able to convince her to coming to their side. Cirie was never in any real danger at all in Micronesia, so her social skills were never a factor in getting herself out of trouble in Micronesia. Platinumtlc, I stated my opinion on things, you obviously don't agree with my opinion. So instead of resorting to calling me names, why not make a case in proving me wrong, at least kmill tried to intelligently make a point in why he believes Cirie as a better player, whether I agree with him or not, I at least respect his opinion. If you can't come up with anything intelligent to say other than name calling, then maybe it's you who are the dumbass. |
||
|
Mister Plum |
|||
|
Posts: 3682 (09/22/08 12:24 AM) |
For me, Ashlee Ashby is one of the worst. Jessie too even though she's hawt.
|
||
|
Knoxville Jackass |
|||
|
Posts: 54 (09/22/08 12:42 AM) Registered user |
I agree that Ashlee was one of the worst, to me any body who quits is one of the worst, Jessie unfortunately never really had a chance to play as she was sick
the whole time. Your right, Jessie is very hot.
|
||
|
Thailandsurvivor |
|||
|
Posts: 1680 (09/22/08 12:46 AM) |
Knoxville Jackass wrote:I agree with part of that. I still don't think that Cirie would have won Micronesia if it was a final three (which is another reason why I loved the final two twist there). Alexis admitted to wanting Cirie to win through Ponderosa. Eliza and Alexis would vote for her. Natalie still votes for Parvati no questions asked. And Ozzy and James are still sure votes for Amanda. (I'm also guessing that Erik would vote for her as well, but I'm not 100% sure.) This leaves a 3-2-1 vote with the last vote resting in Jason's hands, and I don't think he'd be willing to vote for Cirie just because his whole game was based off of challenges. We'd have one of the worst winners ever if it was an actual final three if Jason votes for Parvati. The rest of it is garbage. I do think that Amanda played a good strategic game in China, even though, we found out at the end that her social game sucked, but she played emotionally and lost her backbone in Micronesia. There's no way in hell that she's a better player just because she won a challenge. |
||
|
Thailandsurvivor |
|||
|
Posts: 1681 (09/22/08 12:49 AM) |
Oh, and neither of those should have ever been mentioned in the worst survivor ever thread. That award has to go to someone with zero entertainment value. Even
if you hated someone like Lex or Lisi, at least you had an opinion. You can't say that about the Rebecca Boreman's and the Nick Stanbury's.
|
||
|
Knoxville Jackass |
|||
|
Posts: 56 (09/22/08 1:08 AM) Registered user |
Thailandsurvivor wrote: Going by your predictions, Amanda would have won in a final three, in your opinion she would have been one of the worst winners, but none the less a winner that beat Cirie, who even with her great social skills could not beat Amanda who gave a horrible final tribal council. Again, just my opinion, but wouldn't that make her a better player? I do agree that neither should be listed in this thread, the people with zero impact in the game should be listed. |
||
|
Thailandsurvivor |
|||
|
Posts: 1683 (09/22/08 1:38 AM) |
Going by your predictions, Amanda would have won in a final three, in your opinion she would have been one of the worst winners, but none the less a winner that beat Cirie, who even with her great social skills could not beat Amanda who gave a horrible final tribal council. Again, just my opinion, but wouldn't that make her a better player?No. Anyone who wins in a final three scenario loses alot of credibility with me no matter what. Amanda couldn't have beaten Cirie or Parvati one on one, yet she would have won because of that freaking twist. If that makes Amanda the better player, then Amber played better than Rob. |
||
|
Knoxville Jackass |
|||
|
Posts: 57 (09/22/08 8:01 AM) Registered user |
Thailandsurvivor wrote: How do you know that Cirie would have beaten Amanda one on one?, by your predictions, Amanda has Ozzy, James & Erik's votes, Cirie has Alexis & Eliza's, you also felt that Jason would never vote for Cirie, which I agree with, I can't see him voting for an older player. That is 4 votes Amanda, 2 votes Cirie. then there is Natalie and Parvati. I can see Natalie voting Cirie, but Parvati had a tighter friendship with Amanda. Which would mean that Amanda would win 5-3, even if Cirie got Parvati's vote, it would be a tie. If a tie is the best that Cirie can do against Amanda, then Cirie is getting way to much credit around here. If Courtney can beat Amanda in a season where Amanda played a better game than what she did in Micronesia, what does that make Cirie? A very highly over rated player. Cirie in my opinion was very entertaining and memorable, and an above average strategist, just not the top notch player that most people give her credit for. As for Rob and Amber, I think Rob played a more outgoing game than Amber, he made all the decisions within his alliance. But he also had a prick attitude that cost him the game, so in that sense Amber did play a better game. Rob was playing for second place given his attitude, Amber didn't have to do anything but let Rob keep sabotaging his own game, which was smart on Amber's part. I give Rob a lot of credit for how he played the game, he had the game won until he decided to be an asshole to some of the people that he put on the jury. |
||
|
Dr Will Hatch two point oh |
|||
|
Posts: 4998 (09/22/08 8:32 AM) Registered user |
Lex and Tom and Alicia were self righteous assholes who never would of voted for Rob even if he was a nice guy
|
||
|
Kitty Pryde1 |
|||
|
Posts: 5570 (09/22/08 8:56 AM) |
If it was a final 3, Eliza would've voted for Cirie, Alexis would've voted for Cirie, Erik would've voted for Cirie (She wasn't a bitch to him
when he screwed up at the end), and thus, Jason's vote wouldn't have mattered because he wouldn't vote for Amanda. Thus at the very least, it
would've been 3-2-2 for Cirie. Plus, any of those other four votes could've changed because she was a mother who needed it more than two young girls
with ties to L.A.
|
||
|
SurvivorFan1989 |
|||
|
Posts: 52 (09/22/08 9:55 AM) |
Lex was a complete idiot, I don't see how he expected Rob to change his entire game just for him, and then call Rob selfish and etc. Whiner! And Alicia
had no reason to be in the Final 7, she did nothing strategically in Australia or All-Stars.
|
||
|
Thailandsurvivor |
|||
|
Posts: 1685 (09/22/08 9:56 AM) |
Knoxville Jackass wrote:I meant that Jason would most likely vote for Parvati over Cirie, but he said somewhere that he wouldn't vote for Amanda because she never gave him the time of day. Amanda would still lose 5-3 against Cirie. |
||
|
kmill |
|||
|
Posts: 1689 (09/22/08 11:43 AM) Registered user |
Knoxville Jackass wrote: Yes, you are delusional. Neither of these women won the game, so getting one I'm not bringing Parvati into this because frankly, she had the edge on Cirie simply because she was tighter with Amanda/not a mother. |
||
|
TRAINROBBER |
|||
|
Posts: 2 (09/23/08 6:11 PM) |
Scout gets my vote...
|
||
|
Nogales |
|||
|
Posts: 29 (09/23/08 6:17 PM) |
SPunKeeMonKee wrote: She brought nothing to the table |
||
|
platinumtlc |
|||
|
Posts: 4371 (09/23/08 6:25 PM) Registered User |
After thinking about this long and hard and debating my options.. oh hell, the first person that came to mind was ELIZA! hahaha dumb bitch.
|
||
|
Us Kids Know |
|||
|
Posts: 8148 (09/23/08 10:10 PM) Registered user
|
JP Calderon |
||
