You're probably basing 99% of his ranking on his performance in Treasure Island Superstars, the season he didn't win, but you have to note that the producers really wanted to play up the whole Australia vs. New Zealand rivalry. That's the only way to explain why Sally, Emma, and Cassie were brought back despite Cassie and Emma not going that far on their season and Sally being boring as dirt. They really NEEDED James and probably gave him extra incentive to go on. Even when he was out there James didn't want to be there and like Johnny Fairplay, he wanted to quit to be with his girlfriend on the outside world. He just proved that love conquers all and its a shame you can't appreciate him for all of that louie.
















