Drew B wrote:
At no time did she show any indication of being a favorite of the judges or the fans.
Does never being bottom 3/2 despite sucking most of the time ring a bell? How about this: she was near the top of dial idol that season, in which nearly
every elimination was accurate.
Carrie's victory had absolutely nothing to do with why Kellie didn't win-- no more than Fantasia's win had anything to do with why Janay didn't win the following year. Neither Kellie nor Janay was ever a real factor in the competition...
Yeah because Janay was SUCH a fantasia colone and the only black diva on the season. How about Nadia who was top 10? Or better yet, the 2nd runner up
Vonzell?
Doesn't America vote on this show? Or did they change the rules and I missed that somewhere?I think you are a more experienced watcher than that. You know damn well that Nigel manipulates his shows more than any other producer. The reason I know you know this because you were bitching right along with me all season about the Davids being pimped













