Level 5 wrote:
Christy was the only really likable player in the Amazon (apart from maybe Deena and crazy Matthew) and she totally deserved to be on top of that poll.
X
Glad there is discussion going on though. :P
Look, I probably root for guys on this show about 75% of the time, but that doesn't mean I'm going to rank Jeff Wilson above Cirie, or rank Nick from Exile Island ahead of Kathy Vavrick O'Brien.With all due respect, if you're upset with the votes, you should be making your voice heard by ... voting.
Chapera,
I agree that Misty was robbed, and we will never know what a great player she could have been, but for her to be top 3 over great characters like Shane, Courtney and especially Terry who was in last place here but came in first on the cbs popularity poll and even almost doubled Cirie's score there, Terry should have been at least top 5 here for sure.
The only problem with this is that sucks is a very different demographic than the average viewer (CBS poll). Shane, Courtney, and Terry do have fans
(Terry... not many on here), but they are also character that have a lot of haters, so they're going to end up in the middle range.
Sally was a sweet girl for sure and very likeable, but if I remember correctly, she didn't contribute much to the game but lose LaMina's spear and hide behind the LaMina men once the merge came because she was the least threatning. She only made the merge in the first place because Casaya protected her, she would have gone instead of Dan.
IMO, Sally was one of the more interesting (and likable) La Mina members, pre-merge. Episodes 2-3-4-6 largely had many parts about her, especially 3 and 4 in her fight for power/survival. After the merge, she really did try to jump ship to Casaya, but since they didn't take her and she eventually got voted out, they didn't show it at all.
I liked Trish, I was hoping that her and Fairplay would have been sucessful at booting Rupert, she was a good player as well, I am assuming the dumbass your referring to is either Sandra & Christa for telling Rupert about there plan, or is it Shawn for not voting with Fairplay and Trish. Even tho I liked her, she was not in my opinion someone who deserved a higher ranking than some of the others.
I meant Shawn was the dumbass. :) He had no reason to keep the Christa/Sandra/Rupert trifecta in tact.
Btw, Chapera is also one of my favorite tribes, to me Chapera only ranks below New Yaxha of my favorite tribes. I hate that the original Chapera ranks so far down on the list, and that the Mogo Chapera ranks as the highest of all of the Chapera tribes which I didn't like.Awesome!! <3 I agree though. But Original Chapera had a lot of unpopular people, unfortunately. Truth be told, I hated Sue/Rob C/Tom/Alicia on all stars by the end (liked Alicia and Tom until they became bitter twats)... but Rob and Amber made that season anyway.
I agree, even tho I completely hate Cirie, I understand her popularity and I feel she deseves her top spot rankings in either of her seasons, same for Kathy, altho I think Boston Rob was equally as deserving for the top spot for Marquesas. The ones I have problems with winning were:<33 Boston Rob, but again, i can understand why he's low because he has a lot of haters.
I love Kelly, but I agree that she shouldn't be #1 for Africa. I think it should have been either T-Bird or Ethan.
Kelly over Ethan, Tom or Teresa for Africa
Helen over Jake, Shii Ann & The Lord & Master Brian for ThailandThis one I disagree with; Helen was a very big character who I believe a lot of people loved during Thailand. Even though it's considered a bad season, there were quite a few likable characters, such as Helen, Jake, Shii-Ann, and you could even throw Brian in there.
Shii Ann was annoying in ASS and was not as deserving as she was in Thailand, again, Rupert is the most popular Survivor ever, but ASS was all about Boston Rob and Amber, either of those three should have been at the top, instead none of them made the top 5Again, because Romber are very polarizing. Typically they get a very low score or a very high score. With all the hate that follows them, I'm surprised they both ended up over 50%. Guess the haters are just more vocal.
Yau-Man should be dominating Fiji just as Cirie did with Exile, but instead he is only a point ahead of second place.X!!! And just ahead of a non-entity at that.
