Jason Castro received a number of weird critique's from the judges suddenly wanting him to fight to win, to the infamous double judging thing, to Andrew Loyd Webber sort of trashing him on stage.
Syesha received a number of back handed compliments all season and her final three week garnered cries of sabotage.
David Cook just had a number of weird statements from Simon from comments of his smugness to the word nerd stuff to the final performance where he was knocked out.
Carley personally I found the criticisms of Carley's performances to way off from her actual performance. When she performed well she was compared to Kelly Clarkson which is both odd and immediately causes people to knock her for not being Kelly. In the following weeks she had a few bad performances but even her good ones where filled with off topic critiques.
Other - I think those are the four biggies but maybe you have a different opinion.
Who do you got screwed over the most this season by the judging, production, etc.















