| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
fffingybyach |
|||
|
wow, love the Cook song spoiler - therefore it must not be true, lol. Usually his song spoilers are more WTF was he thinking.
|
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
I love U2 too, and "With or Without You" is one of my favos, I wish Cook was doing that one. Also there's lots of U2's older stuff Cook could
do great on and that would fit his vibe more. However if he's going to go U2 it's of course wise to do something off The Joshua Tree, it's very
obviously their most popular and recognizable album and the teens and tweens might actually know something like ISHFWILF instead of say something off of War.
|
|||
Lost Survivor Heroes |
|||
|
Some news that latingrl posted, but I think there may be a little more added.
http://mjsbigblog.com/american-idol-final-2-spoilers-recap-cookie-sings-u2-archie-reprises-imagine.htm Song Spoilers:
Wednesday Finale:
|
|||
Claymazement |
|||
dagny1331 wrote: Nah, it just made me laugh. Clay has sung that song 4 times on Idol ,three times his season and once in S5 at the Finale, and there's no freaking way Archie can improve on it. Bo Bice did a nice job on it in S4, but still not better than Clay by a long shot. I think it was Camille that butchered it in S3. |
|||
fffingybyach |
|||
|
Well, suckshardcore, I do love me some U2 but I can't say I've bought any of their stuff since the Joshua tree, with - With or Without you being my fav
song of theirs. I think my 11 yr old is familiar with their song One but that would be about it. She did know IDWMAT& loves DYTM and loved loved loved
IWMAT last week. Hope this spoiler for Cook is right. His camp usually has sealed lips until Tuesday night, which I find infuriating but actually enjoy in
the long run.
|
|||
Joelle96 |
|||
Claymazement wrote: Justin Guarini also sang it during season 1.
|
|||
Claymazement |
|||
|
I missed S1, so I didn't know that.� I think he sang it on S2 as a guest, though, come to think of it, and I didn't
care for it at. all.� Here's Clay's performance from the Wild Card Show in S2.
|
|||
roachc420 |
|||
|
Thank God it's not "With or Without You"! I can somewhat handle a cover of "I Still Haven't Found What I'm Looking For", but I will be forced to buy a meet and greet pass that I can't afford and steal gas from small town gas stations with my license plate covered to get to a nearby tour location to cut a bitch if he fucks it up. |
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
Well, suckshardcore, I do love me some U2 but I can't say I've bought any of their stuff since the Joshua treeI'm in the process of collecting all of their albums still. I have Boy (1980) , October (1981), War (1983), The Unforgettable Fire (1984) , The Joshua Tree (1987) , Rattle and Hum (1989), Achtung Baby (1991) and How To Dismantle an Atomic Bomb (2004), plus The Best of 1980-1990 and The Best of 1990-2000. So I'm missing Zooropa, Pop and All That You Can't Leave Behind and their live album Under a Blood Red Sky which I must get whenever I have some money to complete my collection. BEST.BAND.EVER So needless to say the thought of David C doing one of their songs excites me to no end. |
|||
Sardonically Irreverent |
|||
RobertBestBarbie wrote: X |
|||
Joelle96 |
|||
Claymazement wrote: No he sang in for the Top 3 show I believe: He sang Unchained Melody on one of the results shows during season 2 though. |
|||
Claymazement |
|||
|
Thanks, Joelle, but I didn't like it any better this time. Yikes, he sounded really off to me. I need to go listen to Clay's again to get that out of
my ear drums.
|
|||
Sardonically Irreverent |
|||
|
Crap. I forgot just how bad Guarini was. And freakishly ugly too.
|
|||
dagny1331 |
|||
|
I am absolutely squeely if it is true Cook is doing a U2 song. I love, love, love U2 long time $10 bucks. And if they cleared the song for him for the first
time, that is a very nice kudo for Cookie. Don't eff it up, David, with a badly truncated arrangement. You've been warned. :)
|
|||
alligator pear |
|||
|
Wow, that dude has some big hair. I missed season 1 as that was the summer I had no tv because my house burned down.
When do we find out the song spoilers "officially"? I am really trying to not get too excited about U2, but it is getting ever so difficult |
|||
Joelle96 |
|||
Claymazement wrote: No problem. Justin is my favorite contestant ever from the show and after I hear Clay sing the song I have to listen to Justin's a million times. So I
can relate in the opposite sense |
|||
Lobsters |
|||
|
Why is Clay winking at me?? *nervously moves away*
|
|||
grumpypuppy |
|||
Joelle96 wrote: A million times, huh? I guess that means you must be listening to it right now. That's kind of sad. |
|||
dagny1331 |
|||
|
From AI forums: Some Fox local somewhere confirmed DC & ISHFWILF. Yay! I hope. Also, DC is more nervous about singing with his idol on Wed. Would that be
Raine Maida?
|
|||
Mrs John Frusciante |
|||
|
"The "biggest star" in the world will be there, says Nigel. Robert Downey Jr. perhaps? He'll be there according to the FOX report.
Nigel is probably high enough to think Robert Downey Jr. is a big star."
I'd be willing to bet a C-Note that this is Madonna. |
|||