I liked Diana in that season too, but she needed more work to really BE a star. Fantasia's lisp is amusing, but it's just part of the package. I just want her on my side in the fight. She looks like she could bitchslap you into next season.
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
AllMenAreIslands |
|||
|
Fantasia has charisma coming out her ass. She meant to be scary, I think. I loved Simon's dazed&confused face. The song IS catchy and the performance
is unforgettable.
I liked Diana in that season too, but she needed more work to really BE a star. Fantasia's lisp is amusing, but it's just part of the package. I just want her on my side in the fight. She looks like she could bitchslap you into next season. |
|||
BobbyBrown06 |
|||
Fafulous wrote: Is this for real????? Every single person's face is perfect.
|
|||
abrahammy |
|||
|
That performance by Fantasia was worthy of the great Sanjaya. Truly exceptionally awful. Among the most deliciously horrific things I've ever seen.
Best. Idol. Evah.
|
|||
kennethp21 |
|||
|
yeah Diana sucked, very pageanty, and that miss piggy voice.
yeah fantasia supposedly has the worse voice but she exploited it to the max and not ashamed of it. |
|||
Claymazement |
|||
BobbyBrown06 wrote: It's for real, but it was from last year. |
|||
AeRo 21 |
|||
|
That was fucking EPIC
|
|||
8trackmind |
"How the hell did she win?" | ||
|
Dagny1331's question deserves a thoughtful answer, since he didn't watch the 3rd season. And the answer is that the 3rd season was incredibly bad.
Multiple trainwreck performances every week, moose brained voter choices, idiotic producer decisions, virtually nonexistant male talent, 7 singers in the top
12 that had absolutely no business being there (Mantasia, Jasmine, Snotra, Just Please Leave, Camile, Fatt & Leah), semifinalists that would have been
dumped in the early rounds any other season--season 3 had had it all. All it lacked was any significant number of decent singers. Sucks was a delight back
then, because there was so damn much to make fun of. It was because of all this that a singer who sounds like Donald Duck (and now looks like him, too!) was
able to win American Idol.
|
|||
dustbunny |
|||
Jimbo610 wrote: Ok, she looks like Nell Carter here. |
|||
suckshardcore |
|||
|
It also helped that TPTB fucked with the other competitors performances on F2 night. That and the song like in many other years was suited to Fantasia way more
so than it was to Diana.
|
|||
dagny1331 |
|||
|
Shudder.
Thanks for the history 8track--sounds like good times at the Sucks AI forum. I'm sure I was hanging at Survivor MESS at that time. |
|||
Claymazement |
|||
<---------------------------------- Best. Avitard. Evah.
|
|||
Fcuk You ywia |
|||
|
Ok, really? People who still think that Fantasia > Diana are truly delusional. There is no other explaination.
|
|||
JumpinJackBauer |
|||
dustbunny wrote: President Nell Carter?
|
|||
lemonhead1 |
Oh I don't care | ||
|
I freaking love Fantasia, and while I think that was sort of a hot mess(the vocals and look she has going on) I give her mad props for being so fearless and
never giving a rats ass what anyone thinks about her. I think she is awesome.
|
|||
HumanFund |
|||
dustbunny wrote: Is that the lady that hosts American Gladiators? |
|||
Morrison Street |
|||
|
In the picture that is posted above, what performance are Melinda, Phil Stacey and others watching in shock? Is it also Fantasia?
That is a priceless screencap. |
|||
Claymazement |
|||
|
|||
Fafulous |
|||
Morrison Street wrote: They were watching Jordin |
|||
davidg10 |
|||
MakePaulaCry wrote: OK. Thats just nasty. |
|||
dagny1331 |
|||
|
Melinda, Lakisha and Chris should be cropped and preserved for use during a 3xWhatevia moment. Someone with some skills, please? The definitive wtf picture.
|
|||