People Whose Game I See As Pretty Much Flawless:
Richard (was the first to play, cut him some slack), Brian (the ultimate robot), Earl (can't argue with perfection, 9-0), Parvati (maybe the best game I've ever seen played)
People With A Few Minor Nitpicks (from my end):
Tina (voted out Jerri too soon, giving the opposition ample opportunity to get back into the game), Sandra (navigated the post-merge chaos incredibly well but is incredibly lucky that Lil didn't take the easy route, moreso, she lost hold of the power at one point but that's forgiven slightly because of the way the season worked out), Tom (until Jenn did a number on him, he was set on taking the only person that could beat him in a final immunity to the F3), Todd (strong-arming tactics were too much but he got by with it because of a really moronic group of players. I mean, Denise is more threatening than the guy that orchestrated the entire game? Come on!)
Major Gripes From Me:
Vecepia (voted for Neleh at F4. If Neleh goes home, Vecepia can't win. Also made various pre-merge blunders that cost her the numbers.), Ethan (went along for the ride with Lex in stupid decision after stupid decision), Jenna (great player until she bequeathed power to Rob, had to immunity her way through the last stages of the game, and wanted to quit at one point), Chris (gave up the numbers before the merge, willingly), Yul (was allowed to use the idol in a threatening manner that wouldn't work in modern seasons, was allowed to coast on the idol to the very end of the game, was allowed to win because the endgame also happened to change for his benefit)
Argh!:
Amber (not a remotely fair season), Aras (Cirie is one firestarting challenge from causing Aras to lose in the F2 no matter who he's up against)
Undoubtedly The Worst:
Danni (made moves pre-merge that cost her the numbers, made it to the end thanks to one player's high-and-mighty approach to the game rather than anything of her own doing, faces up against the biggest goat of all time that any brain dead player could have defeated and she argues in favor of Stephenie at the final tribal council. The biggest offense of all is that she cites God as the reason for her win and turnaround in the game.)
Richard (was the first to play, cut him some slack), Brian (the ultimate robot), Earl (can't argue with perfection, 9-0), Parvati (maybe the best game I've ever seen played)
People With A Few Minor Nitpicks (from my end):
Tina (voted out Jerri too soon, giving the opposition ample opportunity to get back into the game), Sandra (navigated the post-merge chaos incredibly well but is incredibly lucky that Lil didn't take the easy route, moreso, she lost hold of the power at one point but that's forgiven slightly because of the way the season worked out), Tom (until Jenn did a number on him, he was set on taking the only person that could beat him in a final immunity to the F3), Todd (strong-arming tactics were too much but he got by with it because of a really moronic group of players. I mean, Denise is more threatening than the guy that orchestrated the entire game? Come on!)
Major Gripes From Me:
Vecepia (voted for Neleh at F4. If Neleh goes home, Vecepia can't win. Also made various pre-merge blunders that cost her the numbers.), Ethan (went along for the ride with Lex in stupid decision after stupid decision), Jenna (great player until she bequeathed power to Rob, had to immunity her way through the last stages of the game, and wanted to quit at one point), Chris (gave up the numbers before the merge, willingly), Yul (was allowed to use the idol in a threatening manner that wouldn't work in modern seasons, was allowed to coast on the idol to the very end of the game, was allowed to win because the endgame also happened to change for his benefit)
Argh!:
Amber (not a remotely fair season), Aras (Cirie is one firestarting challenge from causing Aras to lose in the F2 no matter who he's up against)
Undoubtedly The Worst:
Danni (made moves pre-merge that cost her the numbers, made it to the end thanks to one player's high-and-mighty approach to the game rather than anything of her own doing, faces up against the biggest goat of all time that any brain dead player could have defeated and she argues in favor of Stephenie at the final tribal council. The biggest offense of all is that she cites God as the reason for her win and turnaround in the game.)
