Dumbest Survivor for Seasons

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
Survivorboy2005	Dumbest Survivor for Seasons	Lead	[-]
Posts: 10 (05/09/08 2:19 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Borneo: Sean Keaniff:Stupid alphabet strategy. Richard Hatch:Failed to pay taxes for his million. Australia:Jerri Manthley:Got to comfortable with her position. Africa: Silas:Backstabbed his elders alliance too early. Marquesas:Rotu Four: Showed the pecking order at the IC. Thailand: Shain- Huang: Jumped alliance too early when the merge had not happened. Amazon: Alex Bell: This dumb jock only wanted to get in Jenna and Heidi's pants. He failed to get Matthew voted out, not once but twice. Im sure hes back on drugs now. Pearl Islands:Burton Roberts:The only person to be voted out twice for not learning his mistakes on how he was voted out the 1st time. All Stars:Twaffle: Voted out all the strong people, agreed to keeping Amber. Vanuatu: Leanne: For allowing Chris to stay a few more days which lead to Yasur's downfall. Palau: Gregg Carey: He failed to execute his coup de dat which would have overthrown Tom. Guatemala:Stephanie Lagrossa: Should not had let Danni won her over on the overnight reward. Exhile Island: Terry Deitz: failed to use the immunity idol to cause choas with Casaya. Cook Islands:Jonothan: Allowed Yul to threaten the use of ii. Fiji: Alex Angarita and Edgardo: Those 2 allowed Dreamz into the alliance and he backstabbed them. China: James Clement: Failed to use the 2 HIIs. Micronesia: Eric Rauderbach: Giving away immunity. There you have it, the dumbest Survivors for each season.
Jenny du Jour		#1	[-]
Posts: 895 (05/09/08 2:55 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Borneo: all of Pagong because 1) they didn't form an alliance against Tagi until it was too late and 2) they didn't convince Sean what he was doing needed to stop until it was too late. Think about Marquesas except replace the rotu 4 with the tagi 4. Australia: Colby duh Africa: Are you kidding me? Brandon Marquesas: Neleh and Paschal before day 24, Rotu4 minus Zoe after day 24 at least Zoe tried to distance herself from the failing alliance before it crashed Thailand: Ghandia. She should have sued CBS for sexual harassment. Wasn't she a lawyer? Amazon: Christy, could have sided with someone to get to final 3. Pearl Islands: Lil, could have won $1 million, also burton for getting voted out twice haha All-Stars: Lex for not voting out Amber, Jenna for settling for third place by not taking Rupert, Tom for thinking people would take him to the finals by not doing anything Vanuatu: the girls for not voting out Rory, the guys for voting out John Palau: Ian quitting (since you didn't put this I'm assuming you're a troll) Guatemala: Rafe for giving away a million to Danni, Steph for making her allies hate her Exile Island: Terry for getting rid of all his allies so glad he didn't win CI: Jonathan/Candice: could have won Fiji: Mark Burnett for the haves/havenots twist China: James but kudos to denise for thinking people would bring her to the final 3 Micronesia: Erik
agent2424		#2	[-]
Posts: 2800 (05/09/08 3:09 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	well I won't do the whole list, but I just finished watching an episode of Survivor Africa where Kelly gets voted out. Pretty much Brandon was the stupidest one there, he handed the game over to Lex's alliance, I really liked Lex in Africa but still, if I was Brandon it would be an easy vote to get him out. In Brandon's confessional he said that he wanted to get at least to the final 4? Wtf, he could have been a guaranteed final 3 and possibly in the finals. The way I see what would have happened is Brandon, Kim P, Kelly, Frank, T-bird vs Lex, Ethan, Big Tom, Kim J Once Lex goes, the others can be picked off one by one. Final 5 would have been Brandon, Kim P, Kelly, Frank, T-bird. Brandon, Kim P, and Kelly could pick off Frank and T-bird having them believe they would get rid of Kelly and then have a final 3 of Brandon, Kelly and Kim P. So pretty much that was an extremely stupid vote for Brandon.
Quiddity		#3	[-]
Posts: 2462 (05/09/08 9:40 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Borneo: Sean. "Alphabet Strategy", Super Pole 2000, the sand bowling alley, all easily net him the prize. Australia: Elisabeth. Ruined Kucha's chances to take back control of the game, when they had the chance to do it twice after Jerri's exit. Africa: Kim Powers. Her refusal to not vote for Brandon at F8 cost all of Samburu the game. Marquesas: Zoe. Showed no loyalty to anyone, guaranteeing herself a quick exit after John's demise. Thailand: Whoever decided it was a good idea to throw the episode 6 immunity challenge. Amazon: Wow, this is a toughie. Heidi, Roger, Dave, Christy, Matt, Alex and Butch probably all deserve induction. From a game standpoint, Butch was probably the most clueless, so I'll go with him. Pearl Islands: Burton. Convinces tribe to throw challenge, only for them to vote him out! And then trying to vote out Lill at F5?! Taking Jon on reward?! All Stars: The Twatwaffle. That one's easy. Voting out all the strong guys on the tribe AND voting out Jerri over Amber? LoL!!!!! Vanuatu: Lisa. Voted out Mia for no reason whatsoever and soon found herself packing for what else, but loyalty issues. Palau: Ian. Until Erik's wonderful decision last night, the clear cut #1 dumbest decision of all time. Guatemala: Stephenie. Completely blew what would have been an easy victory by backstabbing all her allies except Rafe, who she had no chance of beating. Exile Island: Terry. Voting out Dan, his horrific attempts to flip members of Casaya, and going along with Danielle at F4 after she had already betrayed him earlier. Cook Islands: Billy. Yes, Candice really does love you! Fiji: The casters for casting Melissa McCunty and not even thinking to bring an alternate. China: James. Two idols. Three TC's Doesn't use one. Nuff said. Micronesia: Is there any question here? :P Last Edited By: Quiddity 05/09/08 9:43 PM. Edited 1 times.
Edinboro		#4	[-]
Posts: 1124 (05/09/08 9:51 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	well in defense to erik i still think jason was dumber..i mean yeah erik was dumb but he made it really far, and getting ami ousted before him should count for something. chet was dumber than erik...hell johnny fairplay was then dumbest of the season, bastard quit when he was in control of the vote.
ptcruisn56		#5	[-]
Posts: 4375 (05/09/08 9:53 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Survivorboy2005 wrote: Amazon: Alex Bell: This dumb jock only wanted to get in Jenna and Heidi's pants. He failed to get Matthew voted out, not once but twice. Im sure hes back on drugs now. Don't forget he tried with Shawna as well and then actually got hitched with Kim P.
pinoyako		#6	[-]
Posts: 393 (05/09/08 9:55 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	OMG! I agree Erik RAUDERBACH is the dumbest in Micronesia!
tullfan2		#7	[-]
Posts: 2643 (05/09/08 10:02 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Most of the dumbest contestants should be contestants that were voted out early. Borneo - BB (honorable mention to Dr. Sean) Outback - Kimmi (Kel & Debb are tied for second) Africa - Silas (Lindsay, Linda and Lex get honorable mention) Marquesas - Peter (Sarah deserves honroable mention) Thailand - Robb (Jan is 2nd and Ghandia is 3rd) Amazon - Roger (Daniel & Joanna deserve honorable mention) Pearl Islands - Osten (he shouldn't have been there in the first place) All Stars - Lex (Alicia is 2nd) Vanuatu - Dolly (athough no one was terrible) Palau - Caryn (James is second) Guatemala - Judd (terrible lie about HII) Exile Island - Courtney Cook Islands - Billy Fiji - Rocky and Lisi (a tie) China - Dave Micronesia - Jason for overall stupidity (thinking the fake idol is real, quitting the IC and not playing the HII) trumps Erik's one huge blunder. Erik, Joel and Ozzy deserve honorable mention. Last Edited By: tullfan2 05/09/08 10:06 PM. Edited 2 times.
Apprentice Talker		#8	[-]
Posts: 4916 (05/10/08 12:22 AM) WRP Official Spokesperson Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Borneo - Rudy (does not know the questions during immunity challenge) Outback - Kel (talked with Jerri about beef jerky) Africa - Kelly (stealing Clarence's war paint) Marquesas - Hunter (he lost his voice during the season finale) Thailand - Tanya (got dehydrated in first episode) Amazon - Butch (he covered his eyes to not saw Heidi and Jenna naked before they plunged on a water) Pearl Islands - Osten (his shorts is always falling) All-Stars - Kathy (she was abstained the vote and she enjoyed the reward challenge in Chapera) Vanuatu - Chad (he attached his prosthetic foot on a right leg) Palau - Jonathan (he never joined the tribe along with Wanda) Guatemala - Jim (weakest player ever) Panama - Bruce (chose to Exile Island in second episode because of tribal swap) Cook Islands - Sekou (hardest player ever in Hiki tribe; the tribe lost in immunity challenge and he was voted out first) Fiji - N/A China - Chicken (he was terrible in the immunity challenge and the members of Zhan Hu tribe chose to voted him) Micronesia - Jason (for being the most douche player in this season)
cardswin5		#9	[-]
Posts: 335 (05/10/08 12:55 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Borneo- Dr. Sean (alphabet, blew game at Jenna boot) Australia- Colby (gave up million by voting off Keith) Africa- Brandon (Voted off Kelly and gave up Samburu's majority) Marquesas- Zoe (did nothing) didn't watch Thailand Amazon-Alex (told Rob he was voting for him) Pearl Islands- Lill (for sucking so much she was voted out of outcasts) ASS- Lex (kept Amber for empty promise) Vanuatu- Bubba (for talking to other tribe in front of girls) Palau- Ian (honorable mention for everyone but Tom) Guatemala- Rafe (basically quit then bitched at Danni for voting him off) Exile Island- Bruce (for not pooping) Cooks-Raro (all of them) Fiji- Stacy (alienated Dreamz and Cassy at beginning then gave away Yau vote and he used Idol) China- James (no question) Micronesia- Erik (hands down, but that was hilarious) Last Edited By: cardswin5 05/10/08 12:57 AM. Edited 1 times.
sunflower101		#10	[-]
Posts: 1336 (05/10/08 2:23 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Quiddity wrote: Borneo: Sean. "Alphabet Strategy", Super Pole 2000, the sand bowling alley, all easily net him the prize. Australia: Elisabeth. Ruined Kucha's chances to take back control of the game, when they had the chance to do it twice after Jerri's exit. Africa: Kim Powers. Her refusal to not vote for Brandon at F8 cost all of Samburu the game. Marquesas: Zoe. Showed no loyalty to anyone, guaranteeing herself a quick exit after John's demise. Thailand: Whoever decided it was a good idea to throw the episode 6 immunity challenge. Amazon: Wow, this is a toughie. Heidi, Roger, Dave, Christy, Matt, Alex and Butch probably all deserve induction. From a game standpoint, Butch was probably the most clueless, so I'll go with him. Pearl Islands: Burton. Convinces tribe to throw challenge, only for them to vote him out! And then trying to vote out Lill at F5?! Taking Jon on reward?! All Stars: The Twatwaffle. That one's easy. Voting out all the strong guys on the tribe AND voting out Jerri over Amber? LoL!!!!! Vanuatu: Lisa. Voted out Mia for no reason whatsoever and soon found herself packing for what else, but loyalty issues. Palau: Ian. Until Erik's wonderful decision last night, the clear cut #1 dumbest decision of all time. Guatemala: Stephenie. Completely blew what would have been an easy victory by backstabbing all her allies except Rafe, who she had no chance of beating. Exile Island: Terry. Voting out Dan, his horrific attempts to flip members of Casaya, and going along with Danielle at F4 after she had already betrayed him earlier. Cook Islands: Billy. Yes, Candice really does love you! Fiji: The casters for casting Melissa McCunty and not even thinking to bring an alternate. China: James. Two idols. Three TC's Doesn't use one. Nuff said. Micronesia: Is there any question here? :P At the final 4 (in exile island) Terry really should have just voted out Danielle. Cire was a jury threat, but she wasn't a challenge threat. He would have only had to worry about Aras in the next immunity. I don't know that he could have beat Aras at that challenge, but Cire wouldn't have won it.
ImANewUser		#11	[-]
Posts: 1343 (05/10/08 9:29 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	^^By my recollection, Aras beat Terry at that challenge so at that point, Aras would've taken Cirie (since I think he knew he couldn't beat Terry) and Terry would've still been 3rd.
MyChemicalShowmance		#12	[-]
Posts: 442 (05/10/08 10:38 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Many seasons have multiple players who deserve the award, so here goes: Borneo: Greg / Sean K. Australia: Debb / Kimmi / Nick B. / Colby Africa: Diane / Carl / Silas / Lindsey / Brandon Q. / Lex Marquesas: Gabe / Zoe Thailand: Jed / Ghandia / Shiiann Amazon: Daniel / Roger / Dave J. / Deena / Alex B. / Christy / Butch / Matthew Pearl Islands: Osten / Andrew / Rupert ASS Stars: Rob C. / Sue / Lex / Alicia / Rupert / Jenna L. / Romber I'll come back and do the rest later - the more recent seasons have tons of people that will make the cut
Pulau Tiga		#13	[-]
Posts: 4106 (05/10/08 11:40 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Apprentice Talker wrote: Africa - Kelly (stealing Clarence's war paint) Marquesas - Hunter (he lost his voice during the season finale) Amazon - Butch (he covered his eyes to not saw Heidi and Jenna naked before they plunged on a water) Pearl Islands - Osten (his shorts is always falling) All-Stars - Kathy (she was abstained the vote and she enjoyed the reward challenge in Chapera) Vanuatu - Chad (he attached his prosthetic foot on a right leg) Cook Islands - Sekou (hardest player ever in Hiki tribe; the tribe lost in immunity challenge and he was voted out first) Fiji - N/A
pinoyako		#14	[-]
Posts: 497 (05/10/08 11:47 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Apprentice Talker wrote: Borneo - Rudy (does not know the questions during immunity challenge) Outback - Kel (talked with Jerri about beef jerky) Africa - Kelly (stealing Clarence's war paint) Marquesas - Hunter (he lost his voice during the season finale) Thailand - Tanya (got dehydrated in first episode) Amazon - Butch (he covered his eyes to not saw Heidi and Jenna naked before they plunged on a water) Pearl Islands - Osten (his shorts is always falling) All-Stars - Kathy (she was abstained the vote and she enjoyed the reward challenge in Chapera) Vanuatu - Chad (he attached his prosthetic foot on a right leg) Palau - Jonathan (he never joined the tribe along with Wanda) Guatemala - Jim (weakest player ever) Panama - Bruce (chose to Exile Island in second episode because of tribal swap) Cook Islands - Sekou (hardest player ever in Hiki tribe; the tribe lost in immunity challenge and he was voted out first) Fiji - N/A China - Chicken (he was terrible in the immunity challenge and the members of Zhan Hu tribe chose to voted him) Micronesia - Jason (for being the most douche player in this season) Claude <3333
dettigersnw22		#15	[-]
Posts: 83 (05/10/08 7:06 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	S1-Sean (alphabet strategy) S2-Colby and Kimmi (Colby for not taking Keith to F2, Kimmi for blabbing the TC results) Havent seen S3 S4-Rotu 4 (Too cocky) S5-Ghandia, Jed, Shii Ann (Ghandia was a disaster from the start, Jed wouldve stayed if he worked hard, Shii Ann for the delayed merge mistake) S6-Alex, Christy, Roger (Alex for blabbing his plan to Rob, Christy for not making a decision as a swing vote, Roger for being overly sexist in a men vs. women setup) S7-Osten (Sold his clothes despite the tribe still having plenty of money left over) S8- Lex (Ugh...) Havent seen S9 S10- Ian and Jonathan (Ian for handing the game to Tom on a silver platter; Jonathan for being a young and strong guy yet managing to not get picked over Willard....) S11- Jaime (running himself into the ground with arrogance and paranoia) Havent seen S12-S14 S15- James and Amanda (James went home with 2 HIIs, Amanda didnt boot Todd at F4) S16- Jason, Erik and Joel (Jason didnt do one smart thing the entire time he was out there. Erik played a good game but made the huge blunder. Eriks move is the dumbest ever, but Jason overall was the dumbest player of the season. Joel for over-strategizing and still managing to get voted out before Chet.)
sunflower101		#16	[-]
Posts: 1365 (05/11/08 4:27 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	ImANewUser wrote: ^^By my recollection, Aras beat Terry at that challenge so at that point, Aras would've taken Cirie (since I think he knew he couldn't beat Terry) and Terry would've still been 3rd. Yes but you can't predict what the future and know what kind of immunity challenge you will have. That is why he was dumb for not trying to improve his odds to win the last challenge. He kept Danielle thinking she would take him to the final 2. He had no reason to suddenly trust Danielle's word. So he should have at least tried to better his odds in the next immunity challenge and vote out Cire. Danielle/Aras/Cire where never going to take Terry to the final 2. Even if the results would have ended up the same with Terry losing the challenge, I think it was dumb for not trying to better his odds to win it. It isn't like he had a crystal ball to know this was one of the few challenges he would suck at.
The Very Insane Shark		#17	[-]
Posts: 3630 (05/11/08 7:54 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Kimmi (Colby for not taking Keith to F2, Kimmi for blabbing the TC results) Gonna have to give it to Varner over Kimmi. He confirmed that Debb had voted for him after Kimmi had blabbed it...and then he quit in the endurance IC for a jar of peanut butter, knowing full well that Ogakor had knowledge of his prior votes. Varner definitely played a much bigger role in Kucha's downfall than Kimmi did. I agree about Colby, though...what an idiot.
JLK Name		#18	[-]
Posts: 1347 (05/12/08 5:10 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Fan Erik of Survivor Micronesia Fans VS Favorites
GelEGuy2		#19	[-]
Posts: 27 (05/12/08 9:42 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Borneo: Sean (dishonorable mention to Kelly, Joel, Gervase) Australia: Kimmi Africa: Brandon (dishonorable mention to Clarence, Silas) Marquesas: Gabriel (dishonorable mention to Peter) Thailand: Jan (I guess) Amazon: Alex (dishonorable mention to Ryan, Daniel, Joanna, Shawna) Pearl Islands: Burton (dishonorable mention to Rupert, Nicole) All Stars: Lex Vanuatu: Travis Palau: James (dishonorable mention to Caryn) Guatemala: Jamie (dishonorable mention to Blake) Panama: Shane Cook Islands: Ozzy (dishonorable mention to Adam, Candice, Jessica) Fiji: Dreamz (dishonorable mention to Rocky, Lisi, Alex) China: James (dishonorable mention to Erik, Denise) Micronesia: Jason (dishonorable mention to Erik, Kathy)
seltzer3		#20	[-]
Posts: 857 (05/12/08 9:56 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Erik made the worst move, but Jason was the worst player. Erik did show some strategy by somehow outlasting Ami...and slowly integrating himself in the Ozzy clique. Jason, however? -Immediately shunned Tracy/Kathy/Chet. -Found "HII" -Gave up immunity. -Didn't play immunity, even though he just saw Ozzy get blindsided.

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Dumbest Survivor for Seasons

Dumbest Survivor for Seasons

Quick Reply