Craig, I think you got that I just chide for your attampts at persuasion in relation to Edgic, never personal, and yeah, I'd watch Tyra before the "All Parvati Hour", got me there! :-)
Michael
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
OnlyTheHunter |
|
||
|
FLF, trust me, I play nice here but I revel in gallows humor and can always use a laugh. I watched Homicide, she watched Walker. Should've been a sign.
She loved happy Disney endings, I liked how Bambi ended. And worst, I like american Idol, she prefers America's Next Top Model. Paula, Randy, even Ryan
over Tyra any day!
Craig, I think you got that I just chide for your attampts at persuasion in relation to Edgic, never personal, and yeah, I'd watch Tyra before the "All Parvati Hour", got me there! :-) Michael |
|||
AllMenAreIslands |
|
||
|
I like Survivor AND America's Next Top Model AND I watch American Idol. I'm a lost cause when it comes to "scripted TV" except for Medium of
course.
I wonder if Alison can have a dream about who wins S16 for me. Someone send her a link to the LividManda thread... |
|||
Relynn |
|
||
Why is the Danni/Tina thing a non starter, that's not the only case where such a thing has happened. Those are two if not more examples of where the show has switched things up. Since "quiet people in the First episode" have won before, you can't write someone off just because they were quiet in the first episode. I like Amanda as a player, she's one of my favorite players. But honestly, I don't even have the girl on my avatar. I would never attempt to attend a Survivor Finale or anything like that. I don't know the girl she's in reality in many ways a fictional character to me because I have practically no interest in what happens to her outside of Survivor...: I mean I wish her well...But I don't know her. So honestly your statement is kind of insulting. We are allowed to have favorite players. And I'm also the type of person who enjoys debating with people, which is another reason why I'm here.
Last Edited By: Relynn
05/08/08 5:17 PM.
Edited 2 times.
|
|||
fat little fingers |
|
||
|
Nonstarter is a bit much. But those two examples are overwhelmed by the number of seasons in which the end can be traced back to the beginning. But,
you're absolutely right in that any given season can be played like Survivor Outback again and we would have to give it the nod.
And my fan comment wasn't aimed at you any more than it was aimed at OTH. That's why the dividing lines between each comment. I have no sitcoms in my life. Sitcoms are smelly dead, like vaudeville. Seinfeld was my last. (And maybe the first two seasons of Mad About You). btw: Friends usually sucked too much to watch all the way through, too! :P See? Absolutely no reference to the other comments. |
|||
Relynn |
|
||
fat little fingers wrote: Sorry. I was over sensative. I see your point. I do get what your saying about it not happening much, and it's part of the reason why I'm kind of
not sure that Amanda would win.. Because Parvarti's quote sounds like a winner's quote. BUT, I think that if it happens once in awhile, you can't
just ignore it in edgic. Please don't get me wrong if Amanda was edited like Becky/Jen all season long then I totall wouldn't be arguing about her
editing. It's one of the reasons why I've only recently been talking about Amanda as a winner. But Amanda's visibility has been increasing for
quite a while now...So I think it's possible that she's getting a Danni/Tina type edit.
|
|||
fat little fingers |
|
||
|
Poor Eric.
|
|||
Werwanderflugen |
|
||
|
Wow... just... wow.
|
|||
AllMenAreIslands |
|
||
|
Holy shit. Now what?
|
|||
Oowatanite |
|
||
fat little fingers wrote: Fixed |
|||
NickF227 |
|
||
|
I think all of them m.orphed this episode. <3
I know, edgically Natalie won't win, but she should at least get some votes for convincing a guy to give her II. |
|||
speedyforme |
|
||
|
is Erik OTTI (I = idiot)
|
|||
fat little fingers |
|
||
|
"...dumber than either Ozzy or Jason." Ouch.
|
|||
astroline |
|
||
|
Erik gets an M for this episode, right? Or at least an N? It reminded me of a negative version of Jaime's boot.
|
|||
GretchenIsMyGod |
|
||
|
holy fuck.
who came up with the way to get erik to give nat immunity? cirie? wow. holy fuck. |
|||
speedyforme |
|
||
|
I think Erik deserves his own unique rating...
|
|||
GrenadeJumper85 |
|
||
who came up with the way to get erik to give nat immunity? cirie? wow. holy fuck. Cirie. My god, that was just...........wow..........................wow |
|||
MasterDarkNinja |
|
||
|
Wow, I can't believe anyone could be stupid enough to do that.
Can I give Erik a triple -? I don't think it's even possible for anyone to do something stupider then that in Survivor.
Last Edited By: MasterDarkNinja
05/08/08 8:11 PM.
Edited 1 times.
|
|||
GretchenIsMyGod |
|
||
astroline wrote: Let's avoid double negatives.
Rooting for Cirie!
And the fat lip thing v. Ami. I certainly am not looking for ways for Parv to win, and I'm way more inclined to look for Ami (hello, look at my avatar), but I left that episode remembering Parvati got a fat lip vividly, and not thinking once about Ami until I came here and everyone was talking about it. |
|||
unduli clone |
|
||
|
I have no idea how to rate Erik's tone. OTT, for sure, and not P, but was he N? Moronic, obviously, but I don't know if it was N. As far as the others, Cirie was fabulous this episode ("Jedi mind trick") and Parvati was weak. Way too late to change predictions though, and right before the finale I don't see anything wrong with a bad episode. Just casts doubt on the outcome (a very casual watcher who caught tonight's episode commented that Amanda was a lock to win). I think that's one of the best TC's ever, though. I just loved that they showed everyone's voting confessional, and the accompanying music and jury facial expressions. OTTPP for the TC! |
|||
fat little fingers |
|
||
Rooting for Cirie! Yeah, she really cooked tonight. If I was a casual viewer, I'd be giving this game to Cirie or Amanda at this point. They pulled Parvati's bacon out of the fire. "I don't really need to look for the idol." What's that all about? She would have had that little moment of at-risk without that quote. Not just a low-key, background edit, but an arrogant, foolish move edit as well. |
|||