AI7 TOP12: Rate 1-12 and Brain/Heart/Gut

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
SurvivorLDog93		#21	[-]
Posts: 19472 (03/11/08 9:10 PM) Admin/Play-By-Play Guru Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Brooke 2. Jason 3. Jacuzzi 4. Johns 5./6./7./8./9. Pretty much interchangeable: Syesha/Carly/Ramiele/Kristy/Amanda 10. (tie) D. Archuleta / D. Hernandez 12. D. Cook Brain: Kristy, Amanda, David Hernandez Heart: Syesha, Carly, David Archuleta Gut: Ramiele, David Hernandez, Kristy Lee Cook
snowydayze		#22	[-]
Posts: 377 (03/11/08 9:10 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Brooke 2. Jason 3. Carly 4. Michael 5. Chikezie 6. Syesha 7. Hernandez 8. Cook 9. Ramiele 10. Amanda 11. Kristy 12. Archuleta B Kristy, Ramiele, Hernandez - Kristy going H Archuleta, Kristy, Amanda - Archuleta going G Kristy, Chikezie, Syesha - Kristy going
WillyDarko		#23	[-]
Posts: 1073 (03/11/08 9:10 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1.brooke 2.carly 3.jacuzzi 4.jason 5.Amanda everyone else sucked 6.david c 7.ramiele 8.syesha 9.michael 10.david h 11.david a 12.kristy b kristy david h h kristy david a g kristy syesha
Jedijake		#24	[-]
Posts: 4954 (03/11/08 9:11 PM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I saw half of the performances and only saw the other half in the reviews. I think I saw enough. The top few were clear. The bottom were all jumbled. 1. David Cook: takes chances week after week and delivers-now he was on top. 2. Carly-Only saw part of it. That was all I needed to see! 3. Brooke-that could have been a very boring performance but she did something special to it to make it real. Excellent job! How many times has this chick been near the top with very simple performances? 4. Michael-I agree that he could have done something more and he is holding back quite a bit, but I thought he did well. 5. Amanda-a pretty obscure song (B-side to "Can't Buy Me Love") and while I agree with Simon about understanding the words, I thought she did very well. Still, she's starting to sound the same each week. <HUGE ASS GAP THE SIZE OF THE MILKY WAY-NOT THE CANDY BAR EITHER> 6. Ramielle-from what I saw, she was in tune. Again, a slow-ass song! What the dealio! 7. Syesha-I didn't see much but the rest were so bad that she falls here by default. She's not going to last! 8. Jason-Was he in tune whatsoever? 9. David Hernandez-Pains me for putting him so high. Acted like he was in a local play version of High School musical. The fact that he was in tune put him in #9. 10. Chikeze-"She's a Woman"? Not even that great of a Beatles song. Not a good performance! 11. David Archuleta-he could have been a little higher if he remembered more words. He was not horrible otherwise but forgetting lyrics THREE times? No longer a front runner and he should not win after this-not with the top 3 performers doing what they did! 12. Kristy-WTF? That's all I can say. B: Kristy, Chikeze, Ramielle H: Kristy, Chikeze, David H. G: Kristy, Chikeze, Ramielle (But it could be Kristy that goes). Either Kristy or Chikeze will be gone.
McWolcott	Jason's lines are too busy so i'll do this now.	#25	[-]
Posts: 6370 (03/11/08 9:13 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Jason-there's an innocent sweetness to the way he sings that gets me. 2. Michael J-I didn't expect him to be that good. 3. Brooke-beautiful 4. David Cook- great voice 5. Carly-didn't suck 6. Ramiele-same 7.Jacuzzi 8.Amanda-ugh 9.David Archuleta-even though he forgot the words, atleast he can sing 10. Syesha-I forgot her 11.David H- should have stripped 12.KKKristy-worst performance ever on AI. BHG Kristy or David H is gone.
Survivor2345andbeyond		#26	[-]
Posts: 3388 (03/11/08 9:14 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Brooke 2. David Cook 3. Carly 4. Michael That's all that matters in my opinion...throw in Archuleta and that Final 5 will be incredible.
bobo1759		#27	[-]
Posts: 366 (03/11/08 9:16 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1 - Brooke - excellent 2 - Carly -great performance 3 - Ramielle - Despite what the judges said, I thought she sang beautifully. Her voice was well controlled and expressive from beginning to end. 4 - Hernandez - A cheesy performance, but he has the best voice of all the men. 5 - Michael Johns - A pretty good job. His pitch was better than usual, but his voice doesn't have a very warm quality to it. The judges were right about it being on the boring side. 6 - Syesha - She got off to a rocky start, but got it going. I generally like her voice. 7 - David Cook - He started out terribly, really terribly. His pitch was all over the place. It did get better toward the end. 8 - Jacuzzi - Lots of energy, but I'm not sold. 9 - Amanda - One of her better performances, but she's a gimmick and a novelty, and the novelty has worn off. 10 - Archuletta - bad 11 - Kristy - Korny 12 - Jason Castro - Horrendous voice, disgusting hair, pretty eyes
Jedijake		#28	[-]
Posts: 4955 (03/11/08 9:16 PM) MESS member Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Brooke 2. David Cook 3. Carly 4. Michael That's all that matters in my opinion...throw in Archuleta and that Final 5 will be incredible. AGREED!!!
Mai4		#29	[-]
Posts: 2834 (03/11/08 9:17 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. David Cook 2 Carly Smithson 3. Brooke Three way tie with these three. Flawless from each and they felt like grammy performances. 4. Amanda - Wow, She won me over tonight. It was wild, funk and unique. 5. Jason Castro - Loved it. 6. Chikeze - Ugh. 7. Ramiele - Great vocals, but she actually put me to sleep tonight. sigh 8. Michael Johns - Meh. It was ok. 9. David Archuleta - OMG WTF WAS THAT? HATED IT! 10. David Hernandez - Over the top and very very cheesy. 11. Syesha Mercado - She didn't scream, but she was all kinds of boring and fake. 12. KKKristy - YOU ROBBED ASIA'H SLUT BITCH! That performance was complete horse-shit. Bottom 3: Ramiele/Syesha/KKKristy LEAVING: Syesha (I'll be happy with her or KKKristy)
memeonly		#30	[-]
Posts: 2907 (03/11/08 9:19 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Survivor2345andbeyond wrote: 1. Brooke 2. David Cook 3. Carly 4. Michael That's all that matters in my opinion...throw in Archuleta and that Final 5 will be incredible. Well, if you could leave out the lyric forgetting twerp, I'm in total agreement.
LedbetterYellow		#31	[-]
Posts: 14 (03/11/08 9:23 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Brooke - her pureness draws me in. 2. David C. - I've never liked an Emo kid so much. It's wierd. Plus my dog's name is Eleanor Rigby. 3. Michael - his hotness conquers all. 4. Castro - I repeat... Jack Johnson love. 5. Jacuzzi - just because he didn't remind me of Chef this week if I closed my eyes. 6.-10. whoever i don't mention. MEH! (Lake Michigan) 11. KKK - hate her with a passion, tonight just built upon that. 12. Archie - HAAHHAAHAHHAHAHAHAAHAHHAHAAHAHHA! points I don't really know what brain/heart/gut is trying to get at.... so i won't even try. :)
opendoor50		#32	[-]
Posts: 609 (03/11/08 9:40 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I loathe Carly, David Cook, Amanda and that Aussie. They'll be doing their rock shit every week now until our heads explode. I'm expecting David A to drop out and then Brooke and one of the rockers will be part of a suck ass finale. That said: bottom 3: Syesha, KKKristy, David H. . It would be so much more fun if Amanda or Aussie left tomorrow but that won't happen. If I were Nigel I'd be getting David A all the medical help he needs pronto.
Ginawantsme		#33	[-]
Posts: 477 (03/11/08 9:48 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. David C. 2. "The Irish Girl" 3. Chickieze 4. Michael 5. Brooke 6. Kristy 7. Jason The other 5 SUCKED! B: Kristy, Ramiele, David H. H: David A, David, H, Amanda G: Kristy, Ramiele, David H.
Joaqenix		#34	[-]
Posts: 512 (03/11/08 9:53 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Brooke Huge gap 2. David Cook 3. That Irish Girl 4. Jason Castro 5. Jacuzzi 6. Michael Johns 7. Ramiele - What Simon said to Archuleta last week applies to her now 8. Amanda 9. Syesha 10. David Hernandez 11. Kristy - Meh. She went second to last AND went all out country, so I think shes definitely safe 12. David Archuleta oops Brain: Stripper David/Syesha/Ramiele Heart: Jacuzzi/Michael Johns/Amanda Gut: Michael/Stripper David/Syesha fuck I forgot how boring/shitty Ramiele is so I'm tossing her in the B/H/G Last Edited By: Joaqenix 03/11/08 9:58 PM. Edited 1 times.
CassandraRevisited		#35	[-]
Posts: 2359 (03/11/08 9:56 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Chikezie! 2. Brooke 3. Dave C. 4. Michael 5. Amanda 6. Carly 7. Jason 8. David H. 9. Syesha 10. Ramiele 11. KKKristy Lee 12. Archie!!!! B: Kristy Lee H: David A. G: David H.
jrw245		#36	[-]
Posts: 26 (03/11/08 10:03 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Carly 2. Brooke 3. David Cook 4. Jason 5. Michael 6. Chikeze 7. Syesha 8. Amanda 9. David Archuleta 10. David Hernandez 11. Ramiele 12. Kristy B. Kristy Syesha Amanda H. Kristy Chikeze Hernandez G. Syesha Kristy Hernandez
suckshardcore		#37	[-]
Posts: 11557 (03/11/08 10:04 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. Carly 2. Brooke 3. David C They'd make up my ideal Top 3 at this point, and I see it as possible. They've shown themselves to be consistent, they make good song choices for their styles. If this is a talent competition and these 3 keep on going the way they have been they should be the Top 3, no questions asked. 4. Chikeze 5. Michael 6. David H 7. Jason 8. Ramiele 9. Syesha 10. Amanda Humongous Gap 11. David A 12. KKKristy (how she made the Top 12 over Kady is beyond me, hell how she made it over Asia'H is beyond me too)
cabanachat		#38	[-]
Posts: 2679 (03/11/08 10:07 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	1. David Cook 2. Brooke White 3. Chikezie (surprisingly) 4. Carly Smithson 5. Michael Johns 6. Jason Castro 7. Syesha Mercado 8. Amanda Overmyer 9. David Archuleta 10. Ramiele Malubay 11. David Hernandez 12. Kristy Lee Cook B/H/G: any combo of: Kristy/David H/Ramiele
Jessfrogger88		#39	[-]
Posts: 10386 (03/11/08 10:13 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I think tonight was pretty middle of the road. Not many standout performances few horrendously bad performances and most of them fell in the middle. I know my picks are probably gonna be way different than most, but here goes. 1. Ramielle- I thought it was a great vocal, pure and crisp... It was a slow ballad, but she showed skill.. I didn't find it boring.. but hey 2. David Cook- Not as great as Hello, but pretty close. He is going to have to mix it up some in the future, but I still like him changing up the songs for now 3. Michael Johns- I liked it :) 4. Jason Castro- By far his best for me. I really liked it much better than that over rated failure last week... However I don't really think he will last much longer 5. Jacuzzi- It was refreshing hearing him do something different. It's enough for another week or two HUGE GAP 6. Syesha- Eh... It wasn't horrendous, but she was pitchy.. boring. Not a great song choice 7. David- Same as above... not a great song choice.. some good notes some bad Little Gap 8. Brooke White- I know I know she is real and she cried and she's cute and relevant, but I think vocally that was her weakest performance. The song choice was right on but her voice kept cracking. It started out really well but fell apart bad.. I still like her a lot though. OCEAN SIZED GAP 9. Amanda Ovenmyer- That wasn't as bad in my mind as the last two weeks, but it doesn't fucking matter this bitch just flat out sucks and I can hardly understand her. She hits a view notes with a cool "rock" tone and butchers the rest of the song... It's the same thing every week... 10. Carly- She was extremly shrieky, pitchy and her voice kept cracking ... listen closely... Also I didn't like the way her accent came out Galaxy Sized Gap 11. David Archuletta- WOW... that was bad audition bad... terrible... the vocals were terrible notes were all over the place... and not to mention you forgot a big chunk of the words. It's insane that this wasn't the worst of the night. Seriously I think this one is for the record books.. I still like Archie and it's good to see he can malfunction from time to time. 12............OH.........MY........GOD!!!!!!!!!!!1 BITCH <KRISTY> BITCH... That was literally offensive... to my ears to my brain to the beatles to country fans to the beaver state to kady, alaina, joanne, alex, amy and asia'h.. SOOOOOOOOOOOOOO BAD... Worst of the season bad... HORRIBLE... I HATE YOU... IDIOT HOOOOOOORRRIBLE......Actually it falls into so bad it's good train wreck style... Seriously horrendous. That last note... Brain: Syesha, Amanda, David H. Heart KKKristy, Amanda, Syscreecha Gut Ramielle, David H., Syesha I think Kristy going so late and being that bad is going to save her ass unfortunately.....
AlexDSSF		#40	[-]
Posts: 613 (03/11/08 10:19 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Somewhere, Asia'h Epperson is feeling vindicated. She's probably saying right now, "Serves them right for choosing that fucking blonde whore over me."

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

AI7 TOP12: Rate 1-12 and Brain/Heart/Gut

Quick Reply