Whose Funeral Was It?

0 Kudo

Started By	Comment
PoChop		#281	[-]
Posts: 1401 (02/17/08 6:36 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Maybe we haven't seen the person yet?
cindidindi76		#282	[-]
Posts: 8716 (02/17/08 7:46 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	aslanscubs wrote: Ok, I'm actually really tired of this discussion but I'm really surprised that no one has thought that maybe Sayid was in the coffin. That would explain why Kate and Jack acted the way they did. If they felt Sayid betrayed them in some way, that'd definitely explain why Kate said "Why would I go to the funeral?" and why Jack said he was neither friend nor family. Just a thought. And it would explain why no one else was at the funeral, Sayid probably didn't have a whole lot of family in LA. I too am kind of tired of the discussion, just because there's no garauntee that whoever was supposed to be in the coffin is even going to end up being the person in the coffin. Other than the newspaper clipping, was there anything else indicating that it was a man in the coffin?
WiscBadger95		#283	[-]
Posts: 10403 (02/17/08 10:13 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	cindidindi76 wrote: Other than the newspaper clipping, was there anything else indicating that it was a man in the coffin? Even the newspaper clipping as we currently know it can't be fully considered canon anymore. The producers have said they intend to re-write the article, so they could theoretically even go so far as to change the gender.
Ogreat1		#284	[-]
Posts: 1515 (02/18/08 7:02 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	cindidindi76 wrote: aslanscubs wrote: Ok, I'm actually really tired of this discussion but I'm really surprised that no one has thought that maybe Sayid was in the coffin. That would explain why Kate and Jack acted the way they did. If they felt Sayid betrayed them in some way, that'd definitely explain why Kate said "Why would I go to the funeral?" and why Jack said he was neither friend nor family. Just a thought. And it would explain why no one else was at the funeral, Sayid probably didn't have a whole lot of family in LA. I too am kind of tired of the discussion, just because there's no garauntee that whoever was supposed to be in the coffin is even going to end up being the person in the coffin. Other than the newspaper clipping, was there anything else indicating that it was a man in the coffin? While I'm still leaning heavily toward it being Ben in the coffin... I see what you're saying, that the coffin could be a red herring... you know how the writers love to throw us for a loop. ;) It could be some random patient of his, and he's assuming Kate would have been there because she's always been there (and he's starting to really loose it.)
cindidindi76		#285	[-]
Posts: 8727 (02/18/08 7:25 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	WiscBadger95 wrote: cindidindi76 wrote: Other than the newspaper clipping, was there anything else indicating that it was a man in the coffin? Even the newspaper clipping as we currently know it can't be fully considered canon anymore. The producers have said they intend to re-write the article, so they could theoretically even go so far as to change the gender. Yeah, I know, but I knew if I didn't put in thepart about the clipping some asshole would post it as PROOF!
CC1018		#286	[-]
Posts: 1008 (02/23/08 7:56 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	So who pays for the funeral? The county doesn't just randomly hold viewings for beating victims with no family. If the man was from NY, why was there a service in LA?
pakaulaw		#287	[-]
Posts: 7 (03/08/08 12:58 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	it's either jin or sun, i mean there's a coming episode where one of them dies in the future.. its the next one ji yeon i think...
WiscBadger95		#288	[-]
Posts: 10494 (03/08/08 6:57 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	CC1018 wrote: So who pays for the funeral? The county doesn't just randomly hold viewings for beating victims with no family. If the man was from NY, why was there a service in LA? Maybe Ben secretly paid for it out of the $3.2 million he didn't give to Miles.
catspasms		#289	[-]
Posts: 7397 (03/09/08 12:54 PM) I need a life Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Ooooh wait...what if it's Miles in the coffin?
WiscBadger95		#290	[-]
Posts: 10495 (03/09/08 7:39 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	After the last episode, I had the crazy thought that Juliet is the corpse. Don't ask me why, though.
Screerider		#291	[-]
Posts: 21204 (03/10/08 12:21 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I doubt it's Sayid or Ben, only because I'm guessing that Jack's insistance to return to the Island will make him a "risk" that Ben will have to assign Sayid to for elimination.
Shorty		#292	[-]
Posts: 1654 (03/10/08 4:31 PM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	I don't think it would be Juliet just for the reason that surely her sister would come to her funeral. They seem to have been very close. I think Sayid is a good bet, but we supposed to find out who it is by the end of this season. The writers did say that they'd tell us!
pakaulaw	sticking to it...	#293	[-]
Posts: 8 (03/11/08 6:43 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	i still stick to my theory that it's either jin or sun..
The Marquesan Godfather		#294	[-]
Posts: 10304 (03/11/08 9:36 AM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Jack was attending his own funeral via time travel
Ogreat1		#295	[-]
Posts: 1520 (03/11/08 4:46 PM) Registered User Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	catspasms wrote: Ooooh wait...what if it's Miles in the coffin? That thought has crossed my mind too, after this lastest ep. Kate didn't seem too fond of him, so why would she go to his funeral? I also think the funeral could be a red herring...
James Bont		#296	[-]
Posts: 22 (03/13/08 9:35 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Not sure if this has been theorized anywhere else, but my guess is that it's Sayid's funeral, but the coffin is actually empty. It being Sayid's funeral, as discussed, would make sense since he doesn't have close family, is definitely someone that gets off the island, and the rest of the losties definitely have a reason to want to avoid him with his new identity. Why else would Ben say it was good that Sayid's identity is now known, as if it was better than the current situation? If he faked his death, then taking someone out would be even MORE unexpected.
SurvivorLDog93		#297	[-]
Posts: 19503 (03/13/08 9:58 PM) Admin/Play-By-Play Guru Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Since we're not excluding any reasonable hypothesis, how about Faraday? His brains are already scrambled from radiation, and leaving the island could start him on a downward suicide spiral like our ladyfriend who exited the ship, stage left. On second thought, I think I'll call it a night now.
hockeymom63		#298	[-]
Posts: 6 (03/14/08 9:47 AM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	Has anyone considered it could be Claire in the casket? Jack went to the visitation and is very distraught because at that point he's learned Claire was his half sister. She has no other family to attend (parents are dead), presumably no friends in the US, and there could be any number of reasons why none of the other "survivors" attend.....Hurley is in the psych ward, Sun is too pregnant to travel, Sayid is busy doing whatever he does for Ben, and Kate is raising Aaron as her own and is bitter about whatever the circumstances were that resulted in Aaron being with her. This also ties into Jack not wanting to go to Kate's house to see the baby. He's torn up about whatever went down with Claire. Claire's death leaves him incredibly distraught. He feels responsible for what ensued and now reasons that they were not supposed to leave the island. When asked at the visitation if he is family or a friend he replies "neither" or possibley "either". Either would fit, and neither could refer to a sort of ambiguous relationship.....because he didn't know until recently that she was his sister. My two cents....we'll see! :)
WiscBadger95		#299	[-]
Posts: 10556 (03/14/08 10:48 AM) Registered user Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	hockeymom63 wrote: Has anyone considered it could be Claire in the casket? Jack went to the visitation and is very distraught because at that point he's learned Claire was his half sister. She has no other family to attend (parents are dead), presumably no friends in the US, and there could be any number of reasons why none of the other "survivors" attend.....Hurley is in the psych ward, Sun is too pregnant to travel, Sayid is busy doing whatever he does for Ben, and Kate is raising Aaron as her own and is bitter about whatever the circumstances were that resulted in Aaron being with her. This also ties into Jack not wanting to go to Kate's house to see the baby. He's torn up about whatever went down with Claire. Claire's death leaves him incredibly distraught. He feels responsible for what ensued and now reasons that they were not supposed to leave the island. When asked at the visitation if he is family or a friend he replies "neither" or possibley "either". Either would fit, and neither could refer to a sort of ambiguous relationship.....because he didn't know until recently that she was his sister. My two cents....we'll see! :) Kate's trial and Sun giving birth both happened well before the funeral.
hockeymom63		#300	[-]
Posts: 7 (03/14/08 12:22 PM) Reply Quote More Recent Posts Message Connection Block Invite	WiscBadger95 wrote: hockeymom63 wrote: Has anyone considered it could be Claire in the casket? Jack went to the visitation and is very distraught because at that point he's learned Claire was his half sister. She has no other family to attend (parents are dead), presumably no friends in the US, and there could be any number of reasons why none of the other "survivors" attend.....Hurley is in the psych ward, Sun is too pregnant to travel, Sayid is busy doing whatever he does for Ben, and Kate is raising Aaron as her own and is bitter about whatever the circumstances were that resulted in Aaron being with her. This also ties into Jack not wanting to go to Kate's house to see the baby. He's torn up about whatever went down with Claire. Claire's death leaves him incredibly distraught. He feels responsible for what ensued and now reasons that they were not supposed to leave the island. When asked at the visitation if he is family or a friend he replies "neither" or possibley "either". Either would fit, and neither could refer to a sort of ambiguous relationship.....because he didn't know until recently that she was his sister. My two cents....we'll see! :) Kate's trial and Sun giving birth both happened well before the funeral. OK. And.....? Like I said there could be a multitude of reasons why none of the survivors were at the funeral. We only know snippits of what happens between the rescue and the funeral. Desmond had a vision of Claire and Aaron on a helicopter. So, one could assume Claire leaves the island with Aaron. Actually, I've been thinking that the 6th of the Oceanic 6 is Claire/the person in the casket. There's been some debate about whether the 6th is Aaron or not. I assumed it was but now I'm not so sure. I think it's plausible. Prove me wrong. :)

<< Previous Topic Next Topic >>

Yuku free message boards

Whose Funeral Was It?

Quick Reply