Yuku free message boards

Even though the thread is just for who ruined the season, doing it this way helped me get to my conclusions, with footnotes for why they're in their positions/what I liked and disliked about them

(h)-Humor (If in a positive category, player was funny...in negative category, player thought they were funnier than they were)
(d)-Drama (If in positive category, player created needed drama....in negative category, player created unneeded drama)
(s)-Strategy (If in positive category, player executed good strategy....in negative category, player executed poor strategy)
(a)-Awesomeness (If in positive category, player exhibited some form of awesomeness either in physical challenges, fights/insults/bickering, general presence, etc...in negative category, player did not achieve the level of awesomeness that we were led to believe that they would)
(b)-Boring (If in a positive category, the player improved the show/game by going under the radar....in a negative category, usually means they did nothing and had no impact on the game)
(l)-Likability--(Only used in positive categories for players that were hard to hate/root against, especially if the rest of cast/players' alliance was boring and unlikable)
(f)-Fell in a Fire and ruined shot at an entertaining post-merge
(q)-Quit after fearing sickness because clothes were traded for goods in a market town when tribe still had lots of money left over

S1:
Saved Season: Rudy(h) (Honorable Mention: Sue(d))
Ruined Season: Jenna L(d) (Honorable Mention: Sean(h))
Underrated: BB(a)
Overrated: Greg(h)

S2:
Saved Season: Rodger(l) (Honorable Mentions to Jerri(d) and Maralyn(l))
Ruined Season: Amber(b) (Honorable Mention: Michael(f))
Overrated: Elisabeth(s)
Underrated: Jeff V(a)

S3: Need to rewatch it

S4:
Saved Season: Kathy(s) (Honorable Mentions: Paschal(l), Sean(h))
Ruined Season: Boston Rob(s) (Honorable Mentions: John(d), Zoe(b))
Overrated: Neleh(s)
Underrated: Tammy(a)

S5:
Saved Season: Brian(s,a) (Honorable Mention: Jake(l))
Ruined Season: Jan(s) (Honorable Mention: Ghandia(d)/Ken(a))
Overrated: Helen(s)
Underrated: Stephanie(a)

S6:
Saved Season: Rob C(h) (Honorable Mention: Matthew(a))
Ruined Season: Christy(s)/Deena(l)/Dave(s) (tie) (Honorable Mention: Rodger(l))
Overrated: Heidi(s)
Underrated: Jeanne(d)

S7:
Saved Season: Rupert(a)/Sandra(h)/Lill(s) (tie) (Honorable Mention: JFP(h))
Ruined Season: Andrew(l) (Honorable Mention: Osten(q))
Overrated: Darrah(b)
Underrated: Skinny Ryan(l)

...(missed S8-S14)...

S15:
Saved Season: Courtney(h)/Peih-Gee(a) (tie) (Honorable Mention: Jean Robert(h))
Ruined Season: Amanda(s) (Honorable Mention: Sherea(l)/Denise(b)/Erik(b) (tie))
Overrated: James(a)
Underrated: Chicken(h)

S16:
Saving Season: Erik(a) (Honorable mention: Kathy(h))
Ruining Season: Cirie(s)/Joel(s) (tie) (Honorable Mention: Ozzy(s)
Underrated: Tracy(b)
Overrated: Natalie(b)