With Cagayan alumni Tony and Sarah becoming the 5th and 6th players to return from that season, it is tied with Borneo for the second-most returnees (The Australian Outback has the most, with 8). I think this is a fair representation of what were probably the three best seasons with all-new players.
Of the remaining players from Cagayan who haven't played a second time, who do you think should be the next returnee?
As a reminder, here are the remaining players:
Trish, Jefra, Jeremiah, LJ, Morgan, Alexis, Lindsey, Cliff, J'Tia, Brice, Garrett and David.