so where was rousseau during this
anyone think that she's an other after all
| Started By | Comment | ||
|---|---|---|---|
bwoliver1 |
the gas |
Lead | |
|
when ben "purged" the island of dharma supposedly all everyone without a mask was killed.
so where was rousseau during this anyone think that she's an other after all |
|||
Screerider |
Re: the gas | ||
|
They only gassed the Barracks, right? The manned Hatches would have had to be taken out one by one. (They left the Swan alone, apparently.)
Rousseau hadn't yet crashed on the Island when the Purge happened. Purge was 1980, right? Rousseau was 2004-16 = 1988? |
|||
PagongSchlong |
Re: the gas | ||
|
Shit. I saw this thread and thought you guys smelled my farts. Taco Bell for lunch, you know.
|
|||
Save The Humans |
Re: the gas | ||
|
Only the Barracks and the van got gassed, as far as we know. I doubt the gas spread out THAT far before it dissipated. As long as Danielle wasn't anywhere near those two locations, she'd have been fine. From Mikhail's tale, I suspect The Purge was around 1994, ten years prior to current Island events. But everyone's just guessing as to the when--unless and until Darlton coughs up the date. I am NOT holding my breath. |
|||
shoeless rye |
Re: the gas | ||
|
The gas used at the barracks must have been a helluva lot stronger than the gas used to kill Roger in the van, I mean those at the barracks seemed to drop instantly, there was seemingly no panic or reaction to the gas attack.
|
|||
bwoliver1 |
Re: the gas | ||
|
what was mikhail's response
|
|||
dksmall |
Re: the gas | ||
|
I'm not up on the whole timeline thing, but I assumed the gas is what killed all the members of rousseau's group, expect for her. Also assumed she was farther away from her group and not effected by the gas.
|
|||
gcodori |
Re: the gas | ||
|
Err...Rousseau KILLED her group, because they had THE SICKNESS. The writers set that up so that you would question whether or not SHE was the one who was sick (in the head) or if the island really was lethal without injections.
Several times in the show people getting shots - but are they (Dharma) giving the shots make people think they need to stay on the island? Another question to be answered. And the swan hatch las left alone because they needed someone to keep pushing the button. |
|||
Save The Humans |
Re: the gas | ||
|
And Mikhail (and The Flame) was left alone cuz he was "a loyalist" (as Ben put it in TTLG) and because they needed someone Dharma trusted to keep up communications with them. (Thus, the drops continued.)
|
|||
tigeranne |
Re: the gas | ||
|
so... I guess this means no more food drops, thanks to John?
I love him, and want to ... well, you know! However, he can be kind of a pill sometimes, can't he? lol I wonder where he went, and what he'll do next... |
|||
Fusili Jerri |
Re: Gas | ||
Quote: Wasn't the same gas used on Kate and Jack when the Others took off? (the cannisters looked the same) How come they were only knocked out and didn't die? |
|||
Save The Humans |
Re: Gas | ||
|
Because it was a different gas.
|
|||
stacy1201 |
Re: Gas | ||
Quote: Screerider, where did you see this? I was trying to figure out the timeline. Also, does anyone else wonder how accurate it is to think Rousseau was on the island for 16 years? The estimate was based on Sayid's calculations...He ESTIMATED the length of the distress signal to be about 30 seconds. The amount of time would make a big difference if the length was a second or two off. |
|||
Save The Humans |
Re: Gas | ||
|
I place the first Incident--which necessitated the button-pushing--around 1979 (since the Swan orientation film was dated 1980).
There was a big falling-out incident between Hanso and DeGroot in 1985 (according to the hatch door map). Cerberus (aka Smokey) went out of control around that time, too. The two are probably connected. There are several times--right up to recently--that Dharmatel had breakdowns. I guess maybe now, after the purple sky, it's down completely? Except, apparently, for short-circuit TV (at the Hydra) and the Looking Glass station. I've put The Purge around 1994--ten years previously (it is 2004 on the Island now). Mikhail arrived in 1993, as a Dharma employee. But made his own deal with the Hostiles. One of "the smart ones," as Ben put it. All we can do is conjecture based on what we know or have been told. This is the best timeline I can come up with. |
|||
stacy1201 |
Re: Gas | ||
|
Good ideas...That would make Ben about 30 when the purge happened, and I thought maybe he was supposed to be a little younger. But we all know the age business is way out of whack anyway, so who knows...
I wonder how Rousseau falls into everything. When they met Patchy, she said that she was still alive because she avoided situations like that, so it sounds like she's been on the island for a lot of weird stuff. |
|||
Save The Humans |
Re: Gas | ||
|
Well, Danielle's sole goal all these years (besides survival) seems to have been capturing AN Other and finding out where Alex is. They seem to have been on to this, though, as it took her 16 years to capture Ben, and he DELIBERATELY allowed that!
|
|||
Screerider |
Re: Gas | ||
Quote:Meh... just seemed like The Purge might have been "The Incident", I don't know. I don't believe Mikhail's story at all. |
|||
SCSL Cyrus |
But.. | ||
|
But didn't Danielle.. and my memory is fuzzy here also came on a plane crash with other survivors from her plane right.. and then she killed all of them.. unlikely an other I would think. Especially if she was pregnant.. and had Alex and we know the others can't get pregnant and deliver on the island.. meaning Danielle MUST have been from the outside world. And she wasn't Dharma either I think..because she doesn't seem to know enough about all the dharma stations and stuff.
|
|||
Fluffynurse |
Re: But.. | ||
|
Danielle came on a research ship that crashed. Or so she told us. He "people" got the sickness & she killed them.
|
|||
stacy1201 |
Re: But.. | ||
Quote: Yeah, and I think her story is one of the few things on this show that is safe to believe....I think.... I also think we need a Rousseau flashback and/or flashforward episode... |
|||
tigeranne |
Re: But.. | ||
Quote: If we believe her story that she gave birth to Alex not too long after arriving, we just need to know Alex's age to determine how long Danielle has been there. Alex looks to be somewhere in that age range. I personally think she looks older than 16, but they usually use older actresses, so I'll over look that. Ben (if he is to be believed) flat out admitted that Alex is Danielle's long lost child. SO, that timeline seems accurate. |
|||