Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (8trackmind) — Mon, 08 Jun 2009 12:59:06 GMT

I agree with a lot of what Sunnflower said, but the lack of paragraphing really hurt the posting. However, the 38 million votes from Arkansas thing certainly isn't Sunnflower's idea; it's been all over Sucks and I've seen it in magazines and other places too. Since Kris' win was mildly surprising, it's easy to come up with conspiracy theories about why. In this case, there's even a small chance it's actually true.

I also want to address the question...

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (cardswin5) — Sat, 06 Jun 2009 21:55:14 GMT

Where do you get access to all this top secret cheating that Kris's fans did? Do you work for Fox? =O (Yes I did sludge thru that "paragraph" sue me ) And yes if they were gonna cheat I'm sure they'd cheat for KRIS and not for Adam considering Kris was the chosen one all season right?

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (fitchstudboy) — Sat, 06 Jun 2009 20:40:28 GMT

highwind44029 wrote:

sunnfllower wrote:
Disagree with the poster that said Allen would be up there with Kelly & Carrie & David. I say no way. Nice guy, cute, but just a mediocre singer. Were more songs he butchered than sang well. Only 2 songs of his weren't bad, Ain't No Sunshine ('cept it sounded like he kept saying anal sunshine) &...

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (roachc420) — Sat, 06 Jun 2009 11:34:01 GMT

sunnfllower wrote:
Disagree with the poster that said Allen would be up there with Kelly & Carrie & David. I say no way. Nice guy, cute, but just a mediocre singer. Were more songs he butchered than sang well. Only 2 songs of his weren't bad, Ain't No Sunshine ('cept it sounded like he kept saying anal sunshine) & Heartless, which was better than the original. The Don Henley song was so bad I had to mute...

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (KellysMomCalledMeFine) — Wed, 03 Jun 2009 17:23:36 GMT

Spaces and indents, oh my!

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (eraserhead19) — Wed, 03 Jun 2009 17:22:57 GMT

sunnfllower wrote:
Disagree with the poster that said Allen would be up there with Kelly & Carrie & David. I say no way. Nice guy, cute, but just a mediocre singer. Were more songs he butchered than sang well. Only 2 songs of his weren't bad, Ain't No Sunshine ('cept it sounded like he kept saying anal sunshine) & Heartless, which was better than the original. The Don Henley song was so bad I had to mute...

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (highwind44029) — Wed, 03 Jun 2009 17:00:33 GMT

sunnfllower wrote:
Disagree with the poster that said Allen would be up there with Kelly & Carrie & David. I say no way. Nice guy, cute, but just a mediocre singer. Were more songs he butchered than sang well. Only 2 songs of his weren't bad, Ain't No Sunshine ('cept it sounded like he kept saying anal sunshine) & Heartless, which was better than the original. The Don Henley song was so bad I had to mute...

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (Suzy) — Wed, 03 Jun 2009 16:35:59 GMT

Another huge Justin fan reporting in!! :

1) David Cook
2) Kelly Clarkson
3) Carrie Underwood
4) Kris Allen
The rest are in order from least to most annoying because I don't like their music at all
5) Jordin
6) Ruben
7) Fantasia
8) Taylor

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (sunnfllower) — Wed, 03 Jun 2009 12:28:54 GMT

1. Adam Lambert (the real winner of S8 without the cheating)
2. David Cook - he was a breath of fresh air in that show & most talented top 12 of all seasons
3. Kelly
4. Carrie

All the others weren't great. Fantasia screamed & I'll never understand how she even made it to the finals & Blake Lewis was a joke at F2. Jordin Sparks was boring. Reuben & Taylor were very likeable but forgettable. I want to see Jordin's birth certificate....

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (sunnfllower) — Wed, 03 Jun 2009 12:16:28 GMT

Disagree with the poster that said Allen would be up there with Kelly & Carrie & David. I say no way. Nice guy, cute, but just a mediocre singer. Were more songs he butchered than sang well. Only 2 songs of his weren't bad, Ain't No Sunshine ('cept it sounded like he kept saying anal sunshine) & Heartless, which was better than the original. The Don Henley song was so bad I had to mute & his performances, even at best, are just unremarkable. People will...

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (Matt310) — Wed, 03 Jun 2009 07:59:25 GMT

1. Kelly Clarkson
2. Carrie Underwood
3. Kris Allen
4. David Cook
5. Jordin Sparks
6. Ruben Studdard
7. Fantasia
8. Taylor Hicks

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (maadx) — Wed, 03 Jun 2009 07:04:11 GMT

omg omg omg am i late???

no???

k

here goes!
1. Kelly God.dess
2. Carrie God.dess
3. Kris Allen
4. David Cook
5. Jordin Sparks

Shouldn't even be mentioned in the winner's list.. *pulls a WHATEVIA*

6,7,8 - TaylorReubenMantasia

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (eraserhead19) — Sat, 30 May 2009 17:40:46 GMT

Will wrote:
Oh Yelly fans, she'll always be the big ham to you guys. She's the 1 TRU IDOL and everybody else should thank her for winning!

NEVER change.

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (Will) — Sat, 30 May 2009 17:32:32 GMT
Oh Yelly fans, she'll always be the big ham to you guys. She's the 1 TRU IDOL and everybody else should thank her for winning!

NEVER change.

eraserhead19 wrote:
well techincally speaking Kelly could be 5 or she could be 8....I choose...

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (eraserhead19) — Sat, 30 May 2009 16:58:44 GMT

Iminajustinfog wrote:
No, actually, the show is the star, and the fact is both Justin and Kelly were hugely popular after the show. But Kelly hadn't even put out her first album when Season 2 started, and the show was recognized as a phenomenon even then. Then Clay went on to outsell Kelly's first album, and Everybody Loved Simon. Then only AFTER that did Clive engineer Kelly's second album success to the top of the...

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (MakePaulaCry) — Sat, 30 May 2009 16:30:21 GMT

Iminajustinfog wrote:
No, actually, the show is the star, and the fact is both Justin and Kelly were hugely popular after the show. But Kelly hadn't even put out her first album when Season 2 started, and the show was recognized as a phenomenon even then. Then Clay went on to outsell Kelly's first album, and Everybody Loved Simon. Then only AFTER that did Clive engineer Kelly's second album success to the top of the...

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (Iminajustinfog) — Sat, 30 May 2009 14:26:52 GMT
No, actually, the show is the star, and the fact is both Justin and Kelly were hugely popular after the show. But Kelly hadn't even put out her first album when Season 2 started, and the show was recognized as a phenomenon even then. Then Clay went on to outsell Kelly's first album, and Everybody Loved Simon. Then only AFTER that did Clive engineer Kelly's second album success to the top of the charts. By that time we were somewhere around Season 4, and the Carrie phenomenon...

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (8trackmind) — Sat, 30 May 2009 13:32:06 GMT
Allison could be this year's Daughtry, if someone gives her the chance. She's the only one this year who is both good enough and commercial enough for major stardom.

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (frautardz) — Sat, 30 May 2009 08:16:47 GMT
No. Kelly actually became the superstar that the show said it would find. The only other superstar winner is Carrie. The rest
are just running on fumes from the show's mass audience and publicity machine. Ruben, Fantasa and Taylor are not pop
stars even if you like them. Jordin and Cook are barely stars less alone superstars. Kris - looks like another Jordin
style winner to me.

The show really, really needs another superstar because Daughtry is already three...

Re: Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (highwind44029) — Sat, 30 May 2009 08:11:51 GMT
Well, in that context, I suppose we should also thank Ruben because without him, there would be no S3-? winners either!

Inevitable "Rank the Winners" Thread

feeds@yuku.com (highwind44029) — Wed, 20 May 2009 21:01:29 GMT
1. Kris Allen
2. Carrie Underwood
3. Kelly Clarkson
4. Jordin Sparks
5. Ruben Studdard
6. David Cook
7. Fantasia Barrino
8. Taylor Hicks

yw!!!!!!!