Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (cardswin5) — Wed, 28 May 2008 12:19:14 GMT

Mrs John Frusciante wrote:
Kady sucked. She had the stage presence of a broom. Don't care how good her auditions were, when it was time to bring her A game to the table she struck out.

Her first performance wasn't as bad as the judges made it out to be and they totally crushed her confidence with the pencil comment. Otherwise she would have been amazing and lasted a lot longer imo.

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (Drew B) — Wed, 28 May 2008 11:43:49 GMT

cardswin5 wrote:
My turd could recieve more votes than Garrett.

Your turd could sing better than Josiah...

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (Mrs John Frusciante) — Wed, 28 May 2008 09:24:11 GMT

Kady sucked. She had the stage presence of a broom. Don't care how good her auditions were, when it was time to bring her A game to the table she struck out.

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (April R) — Wed, 28 May 2008 00:19:59 GMT

definitely Michael Johns.

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (cardswin5) — Tue, 27 May 2008 21:20:53 GMT

My turd could recieve more votes than Garrett.

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (ribald2008) — Tue, 27 May 2008 19:53:03 GMT

Josiah was an immature drama queen. I'm glad the judges put him in his place

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (MakePaulaCry) — Tue, 27 May 2008 19:50:26 GMT

Kady was deemed "god-awful" when she tried to be entertaining during "Magic Man."

Okay, I'm sorry but either you're very stupid or deaf as fuck. Magic Man was truly a SHIT performance. She sang out of tune THE ENTIRE FUCKING SONG! How the hell can one praise it when not ONE note was in tune?

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (pjadedd) — Tue, 27 May 2008 17:39:52 GMT

ProbstFan123 wrote:
Probably Josiah and Cardin.

Let's face it, those two deserved to be in the top 24 at least.

Josiah was one of the worst pieces of shit ever on this show. I'm glad they didn't put him through with his stupid faux British accent (seriously, who does that?) and diva temper tantrum/crying jags. Imagine all the bullshit every week about the lack of song...

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (cardswin5) — Tue, 27 May 2008 17:38:18 GMT

Josiah sucked and would have got pity votes for being a crying homeless bitch so its a good thing he didn't make it.

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (Drew B) — Tue, 27 May 2008 15:28:01 GMT

Josiah? Fuck, no! He didn't deserve to go to Hollywood. He should have been sent packing at his initial audition!

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (ProbstFan123) — Tue, 27 May 2008 15:26:48 GMT

Probably Josiah and Cardin.

Let's face it, those two deserved to be in the top 24 at least.

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (Screerider) — Tue, 27 May 2008 15:16:35 GMT

Pre-Top 12 - too much screwing over.
Post-Top 12 - not enough screwing over.

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (Strawman10) — Tue, 27 May 2008 10:26:54 GMT

Cardin, - she was way too hot to not go further, regardless if this is a singing competion or not. Her voice is good, her looks are great (see avatar for proof).

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (VBeauregarde) — Tue, 27 May 2008 04:34:18 GMT

Alexandrea!

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (Relynn) — Mon, 26 May 2008 20:38:08 GMT

David Archuleta and David Cook, but at least David Archuleta, said that he felt that Syesha was very screwed over by the judges. He said that he would listen to Syesha and then hear the judges comments and be like what the heck...? Do these people have ears. David Cook said something similar about Syesha having this amazing voice. The girl was screwed and let's not even get into when Syesha had the brilliant performance in Final 4, and Randy didn't give her credit for it.

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (toomanynachos16) — Mon, 26 May 2008 20:27:55 GMT

Okay, people...

Let's be clear here....David Cook was NOT TPTB choice to win from the beginning...It was Carly, Brooke, and Archtard....David didn't really catch judges' praise until Hello...or Billie Jean...whichever one came first....then Eleanor Rigby came along and cemented the judges' favor.

Secondly, yes Syesha made it a damn far way in the competition, but it had nothing to do with help from the judges. She was constantly given the shaft from the...

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (LKMOSCAR) — Mon, 26 May 2008 17:16:11 GMT

Syesha fell into third place. Whoever was the survivor of that final six, bottom two, was going to go to the final three. Fortunately for her, she was in the bottom the previous week which got her those ''scared'' votes, and Carly wasn't in the bottom the previous week and got good reviews, which made her fans not give those safety votes.

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (Kudo Withholder) — Mon, 26 May 2008 09:39:01 GMT

1. Syesha. Her performances were pretty uneven and often unremarkable, but she still had one of the better voices this year and seldom got credit for it from the judges.
2. Carly. Constantly picked the wrong songs or oversang them, so I was glad to see her go. Still, I think the judges often slammed her pretty harshly just because she didn't perform up to their high expectations.
3. Chikeze. The guy is a fairly good R&B balladeer but he got panned every time he showed...

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (Apprentice Talker) — Mon, 26 May 2008 02:39:29 GMT

Jason Yeager for being became screwed during semifinals. His voice wasn't good in the first two weeks in competition.

Re: Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (LKMOSCAR) — Mon, 26 May 2008 02:08:26 GMT

Carly was most likely screwed over because the show didn't want a controversial winner, and another female winner, which she was the most likely selection if it had been any other season.

Who got screwed over the most by the judges this year?

feeds@yuku.com (Nods) — Sat, 24 May 2008 16:18:23 GMT

The cries of rigging are never new when it comes to reality shows you can't watch America's Next Top Model or Big Brother without seeing producers interfering and certain people eliminated for questionable reasons. American Idol on the other hand rarely deals with the production interference issues on the level of other shows. It's not unusual for certain singers to get favored and over praised is not unusual, but the volume of contestants that received questionable judgments...