AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (cabanachat) — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 22:11:43 GMT

Apprentice Talker wrote:
1. Devil Child - Good performance; looks like little bit of Robbie Williams' voice rendition
2. KKKristy - Good performance; judges loved her and country genre
3. Screamesha - Good voice; sounds like Fantasia
4. Brooke
5. Jason
6. David Cook
7. Irish Bitch
8. Aussie Fattie

B: Devil Child, KKKristy
H: KKKristy,...

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (abrahammy) — Thu, 10 Apr 2008 07:27:23 GMT

1.Jason (He'd have been considered great on any night. One of the most memorable performances of the season, in a GOOD way.)
2.Kristy (I can't believe I just said that.)
3.Syesha (What does that say about the rest?)
4.Brooke (Boring)
5.Archuleta (Boring and annoying)
6.Carly (Strident)
7.Michael (Strained)
8.Cook (What a hot mess!)

Brain: Syesha - Copying Fantasia will kill her
Heart: Archuleta - this boy's win will be an...

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (Wuming Shi) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 20:33:21 GMT

Overall

1. Kristy Lee Cook
2. Carly Smithson
3. Brooke White
4. David Cook
5. Michael Johns
6. Syesha Mercado
7. Jason Castro
8. David Archuleta

Brain: David Cook/Syesha Mercado/Carly Smithson
Heart: Syesha Mercado/Jason Castro/David Archuleta
Gut: David Cook/Carly Syesha Mercado/Carly Smithson

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (louie77) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 14:49:02 GMT

1.Jason
2.Brooke
3.Kristy
4.Cook
5.Archuleta
6.Carly
7.Michael
8.Syesha

Brain:Syesha
Heart:Archuleta
Gut:Carly

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (HardEdge1980) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 13:49:38 GMT

1) Kristy
2) Brooke
3) Jason
4) David A.
5) Carly
6) Syesha
7) Michael
8) David C.

Brain: Syesha
Heart: Syesha
Gut: Either Carly or Brooke (can't decide between the two)

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (AllMenAreIslands) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 13:12:33 GMT

Good point, BillNye. They've never really liked her, have they? She had a good week here and there, but she's not a chosen pet.

Thinking on her choice of performance, what may have done her in was the introduction blah-di-blah. If she had said that sometimes you need to get angry to be inspired to take action, it would have prepared the audience and the judges and their response would have been completely different. I don't think it's invalid to do "angry"...

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (BillNyeSurvivorGuy) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 13:08:20 GMT

To AMAI: I don't feel like the producers have any special feelings toward Carly, she won't take clothing advice and she's too angry, so I couldn't foresee any monkey wrenching but you never know I guess...

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (AllMenAreIslands) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 13:06:51 GMT

I have to say I don't get why some (not all but some) people are still putting the exact same choices for ALL of Brain, Heart, Gut. The point is that at least one of them should be different from the other two.

Brain is what you think, logically, based on all the evidence including judges' comments, comments here, track record of contestant and anything else germane.

Heart is what you want to have happen - it might be the same as your Brain choice, but it...

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (The Purple Parrot) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 10:43:42 GMT

1. Jason
2. Brooke
3. Archuleta
4. Kristy Lee
5. Syesha
6. Michael
7. Carly
8. Cook

Brain: Syesha/Michael/Cook
Heart: Cook/Syesha/Michael
Gut: Syesha/Carly/Kristy

KKKristy Lee and Demon spawn are winning me over. Carly and Michael are losing me.

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (BJ) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 10:01:36 GMT

Jason and Kristy were great, the rest were meh.

Bottom 3 - Carly, Brook, Syesha, with Carly going home.

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (MTeaCups) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 09:44:35 GMT

Another ho-hum night. Just think, one of these losers is gonna win this thing.

1. Brooke--only one who was connected to her song. Dress was horrid.
2. Syesha--yeah, don't take on Fantasia (except, well, Fantasia sucks.)
3. Kristy--I can't believe I have her in the top-half, but they all sucked, so it ain't saying much (belted-out notes sounded better than just plain singing.)
4. Jason--Like Brook, sweet. But why does he get praised for ripping off Iz's...

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (ILoveCurling) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 08:54:24 GMT

1. Michael
2. Brooke
3. Jason
4. Porkchop
5. Kristy
----big drop off ---
6. David Cook
7. Syesha
8. Carly

Bottom 3 - Carly, Syesha, and in a surprise David Cook

Singing the exit song (if there is one, remember last year) - Carly!!!

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (Survivorspoilerlover) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 08:27:16 GMT

1. Jason - unique, fun and best of the night
2. Michael - people complain about the falsetto at the end but it is a vital part of the original and he nailed it
3. Brooke - boring but nice just like Simon said
4. David C. - not his best by a mile but still will be safe due to his track record
5. David A. - I think his "cuteness" is getting old and we are hearing the same thing every week
6. Carly - she totally lost it at the end, was the biggest train wreck...

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (Hillary Wallbanger) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 08:13:57 GMT

Brooke - she's back! great performance

You have got to be fucking kidding me. she was pathetic

they all sucked so bad I can't hardly put them order which was worse.

1. Syesha
2. Carly
3. Michael
4. David A
5. Krusty

GAP........................

6. Brooke
7. David C
8. Jason

B. jason or brooke
H jason or brooke
G Carly

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (blurdog) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 06:30:42 GMT

1. Kristy - It was that kind of night.
2. Jason - Still don't get the love for this guy, but it was enjoyable.
3. Syesha - Sang it well enough. Personality fake as hell.

None of the rest were good.
4. David Cook - His worst by far. Needs to burn the bloody jacket. And drown the backup singers.
5. Michael - WTH was that screeching at the end? Reminded me of Constantcrap.
6. Carly - Angry and desperate. Wish she would just relax and sing.
7. Brooke -...

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (Apprentice Talker) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 06:06:31 GMT

1. Devil Child - Good performance; looks like little bit of Robbie Williams' voice rendition
2. KKKristy - Good performance; judges loved her and country genre
3. Screamesha - Good voice; sounds like Fantasia
4. Brooke
5. Jason
6. David Cook
7. Irish Bitch
8. Aussie Fattie

B: Devil Child, KKKristy
H: KKKristy, Screamesha
G: Brooke, Jason

Going home on Thursday: Irish Bitch or Aussie Fattie

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (illmatic2089) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 06:05:35 GMT

Going home: Syesha

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (Lovejonze) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 05:46:25 GMT

1. Jason
2. David A
3. Kristy
4. David C
5. Brooke
6. Syesha
7. Michael - the ending was so painful, I think I lost consciousness for a moment
8. Carly

I believe the bottom 3 will be Carly, Michael and Syesha with Syesha going.

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (AllAboutMusic) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 04:14:41 GMT

Kristy (I'll give credit where credit's due. She was fabulous. A little shaky in the beginning but she worked it out with the mini-choir!)
Michael (I liked the quality of his voice. He was trying a bit much in the falsetto but overall it was great)

I was really disappointed with Carly's performance. I thought she would have nailed it but I guess the song was too big for her. The rest were just, meh. I don't know why they were creaming over Jason's...

Re: AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (Claymazement) — Wed, 09 Apr 2008 02:15:46 GMT

1) Jason
2) Kristy
3) Archie
4) David C.
5) Michael
6) Carly
7) Brooke
8) Syesha

Bottom Three:

Syesha
Brooke
Carly

Going home:

Syesha

AI7 TOP 8: Rate 1-8 and Brain/Heart/Gut

feeds@yuku.com (SurvivorLDog93) — Tue, 08 Apr 2008 03:57:30 GMT

The Mods or Admins will re-open this thread after the Tuesday show airs on the east coast.